Michaelmas Term
[2017] UKSC 67
On appeal from: [2016] EWCA Civ 1093
| JUDGMENT |
Ivey (Appellant) v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd t/a Crockfords (Respondent)
before
Lord Neuberger
Lady Hale
Lord Kerr
Lord Hughes
Lord Thomas
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
25 October 2017
Heard on 13 July 2017
Appellant Respondent Richard Spearman QC Christopher Pymont QC Max Mallin QC Siward Atkins
| (Instructed by Archerfield | (Instructed by Kingsley |
Partners LLP) Napley LLP) LORD HUGHES: (with whom Lord Neuberger, Lady Hale, Lord Kerr and
Lord Thomas agree)1. This case, in which a professional gambler sues a casino for winnings at Punto Banco Baccarat, raises questions about (1) the meaning of the concept of cheating at gambling, (2) the relevance to it of dishonesty, and (3) the proper test for dishonesty if such is an essential element of cheating.
The facts
2. Over two days in August 2012 Mr Ivey, the claimant in this case, deployed a highly specialist technique called edge-sorting which had the effect of greatly improving his chances of winning. He had the help of another professional gambler,
Cheung Yin Sun (“Ms Sun”). First they set up the conditions which enabled him to
win. Then, later that evening and the following day, over the course of some hours, he won approximately £7.7m. The casino declined to pay, taking the view that what he had done amounted to cheating. His case is that it was not cheating, but deployment of a perfectly legitimate advantage.
3. What happened is not in dispute. It was set out with admirable clarity by Mitting J and very little is necessary by way of addition or subtraction. What follows in this section is almost entirely in his words.
4. Punto Banco is a variant of Baccarat. It is not normally, to any extent, a game of skill. Six or eight decks or, in English nomenclature, packs of 52 cards are dealt from a shoe, face down by a croupier. Because the cards are delivered one by one from the shoe, she has only to extract them; no deviation is permitted in their sequence. She places them face down in two positions on the table in front of her,
marked “player”, the “Punto” in the name, and “Banker”, “Banco”. Those
descriptions label the positions marked on the table; there need be no person as
“player” and ordinarily there is not. She slides the cards from the shoe, face down,
one card to player, one to banker; a second to player and a second to banker. In prescribed circumstances she must deal one further card, either to player or to banker or to both, but this possibility is irrelevant to what occurred.
5. The basic object of the game is to achieve, on one of the two positions, a combination of two or three cards which, when added together, is nearer to 9 in total than the combination on the other position. Aces to 9 count at face value, 10 to King inclusive count as nothing. Any pair or trio…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd t/a Crockfords and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] UKSC 67
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Supreme Court's decision clarifies the meaning of the concept of cheating in the context of gambling and the role of dishonesty in determining whether an activity amounts to cheating. The court held that cheating in gambling is an objective concept, determined by the nature and rules of the game, and does not necessarily require dishonesty. This decision provides guidance to casinos and gamblers alike in determining what activities may amount to cheating in gambling, and the potential legal consequences of such activities.