Easter Term
[2021] UKSC 15
Applicant Respondent Aidan Eardley Timothy Crosland (Instructed by The Government Legal
Department)
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:
1. This application by Her Majesty’s Attorney General for permission to pursue an application for committal for contempt concerns an alleged breach of an embargo on publication of a judgment of the Supreme Court in R (Friends of the Earth Ltd) v Heathrow Airport Ltd [2020] UKSC 52; [2021] PTSR 190 by Mr Timothy Crosland, an unregistered barrister who represented the charity Plan B Earth in those proceedings. That appeal concerned the lawfulness of the Airports National Policy Statement, (“the ANPS”), and its accompanying environmental report. The ANPS was designated as national policy on 26 July 2018 by the Secretary of State for Transport. The ANPS is the national policy framework which governs the construction of a third runway at Heathrow Airport. Any future application for development consent to build this runway will be considered against the policy framework in the ANPS. The ANPS does not grant development consent in its own right.
2. The alleged breach of embargo was referred by Lord Reed, President of the Supreme Court, to the Attorney General and the Attorney General decided to apply for permission to pursue proceedings against the respondent, Mr Crosland, seeking his committal or such other penalty as the court considers appropriate for contempt of court. This application is being heard by a different panel of the Supreme Court from that which sat on the Heathrow Airport case.
3. This hearing is not concerned with the substance of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the Heathrow Airport case. That judgment has been handed down by the Supreme Court and, as with all judgments in all courts in this country, members of the public are free to subject it to the closest scrutiny and to express their views on the decision. The present proceedings are about a distinct and very limited matter: the conduct of Mr Crosland in disclosing the result of the appeal in breach of the embargo before it was made public by the Supreme Court and whether that constitutes a contempt of court.
The grounds of committal
4. The grounds of committal relied on by the Attorney General are as follows:
The applicant applies for the committal of the respondent or such other penalty as the court considers appropriate for his contempt of court on the following grounds:
“1. On 7 and 8 October 2020 the court heard an appeal in the case of R (Friends of the Earth Ltd) v Heathrow Airport Ltd. The respondent to this application represented the second respondent to the appeal, Plan B Earth, in his capacity as director of that organisation.
2. On 9 December 2020, a copy of the court’s draft judgment in the appeal was circulated to the parties’ representatives in accordance with paragraphs 6.8.3 to 6.8.5 of Practice Direction 6. The draft was marked ‘in confidence’. The rubric on the title page stated that those…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Her Majesty’s Attorney General (Applicant) v Crosland (Respo... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] UKSC 15
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Supreme Court granted permission for the Attorney General to pursue proceedings, finding that Crosland's actions constituted a serious contempt of court. The Court held that Crosland was aware of the embargo and deliberately breached it, intending to interfere with the administration of justice. Crosland's claims that his actions were justified by concerns over global warming and the perceived injustice of the Supreme Court's decision were rejected. The Court found that Crosland's conduct was a serious interference with the administration of justice, undermining the authority of the court and its judgments.
Regarding penalty, the Court imposed a fine of £5,000, considering factors such as the seriousness of the contempt, the lack of remorse shown by Crosland, and the deterrent effect of the penalty. The Court also took into account Crosland's positive character and his pending disciplinary proceedings before his professional body. The fine was deemed a necessary and proportionate penalty to maintain the authority and impartiality of the judiciary.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi