Harvey & Anor v Brette & Ors (Mauritius)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

[2021] UKPC 23

Privy Council Appeal No 0049 of 2019

JUDGMENT

Harvey and another (Appellants) v Brette and others (Respondents) (Mauritius)

From the Supreme Court of Mauritius

Before

 

Lord Lloyd-Jones

Lady Arden

Lord Kitchin

Lord Hamblen

Lord Stephens

 

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

16 August 2021

The panel met on 29 July 2021 to consider the appeal on the papers

Appellants
P Maxime Sauzier SC
Josephine Robert
(Instructed by AxiomStone Solicitors)

 

Respondents
Gavin Glover SC
Yanilla Moonshiram
(Instructed by Jean Christophe Ohsan Bellepeau Chambers)

 

 

LORD STEPHENS:

Introduction

1.                  Nigel Ryan Brette (“the first respondent”), then seven years and two months, now 18 years old, sustained catastrophic personal injuries in a road traffic collision which occurred at 4.15 pm on Monday 8 March 2010. He was a pedestrian who was either walking on the footpath adjacent to the Royal Road, Mon Loisir, Mauritius, or he was in the process of crossing that road, when he was struck by a Nissan van (“the van”) owned and driven by Johann Lindsay Patrick Harvey (“the first appellant”). The first appellant’s road traffic insurers were Cim Insurance Co Ltd whose obligations were subsequently taken over by Swan General Ltd (“the second appellant”).

2.                  On 19 June 2012, the first respondent and his parents (“the second and third respondents”), who are his full-time carers, commenced proceedings before the Supreme Court claiming damages against the first and second appellants. The appellants’ liability is said to arise, in particular, under article 1384, alinéas (paragraphs) 1, 5 and 6 of the Mauritius Civil Code (the “Civil Code”), which provide, so far as relevant:

“1.       On est responsable non seulement du dommage que l’on cause par son propre fait, mais encore de celui qui est causé par le fait des personnes dont on doit répondre, ou des choses que l’on a sous sa garde. (‘One is liable not only for the harm which one causes by one’s own action, but also for the harm caused by the action of persons for whom one is responsible, or of things which one has in one’s keeping.’)

…

5.         Le gardien de la chose, du dommage causé par le fait de celle-ci. (‘The keeper of a thing, [is liable] for harm caused by the thing.’)

6.         La responsabilité ci-dessus a lieu, à moins que … le gardien de la chose ne prouve que le dommage a été causé par l’effet d’une force majeure ou de la faute exclusive de la victime. (‘The above liability arises, unless … the keeper of the thing proves that the harm was caused by an event of force majeure or by the exclusive fault of the victim.’)”

On this basis the respondents contended that the van was a thing in the keeping of the first appellant, so that he was liable for harm caused by the van unless, as the keeper of the thing, he proved that the harm was caused by the exclusive fault of the first respondent, the victim. In the alternative the respondents contended that the road…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harvey & Anor v Brette & Ors (Mauritius) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] UKPC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established