Bott & Co Solicitors Ltd (Appellant) v Ryanair DAC (Respondent)

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read
Hilary Term
[2022] UKSC 8
On appeal from: [2019] EWCA Civ 143

JUDGMENT

Bott & Co Solicitors Ltd (Appellant) v Ryanair DAC (Respondent)

before

Lord Briggs
Lady Arden
Lord Leggatt
Lord Burrows
Lady Rose

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
16 March 2022

Heard on 20 May 2021

Appellant
Nicholas Bacon QC

Ben Smiley

(Instructed by Rosenblatt Ltd)

Respondent
Brian Kennelly QC
Tom Coates
(Instructed by Oracle Solicitors (Holborn))

LORD LEGGATT AND LADY ROSE: (dissenting)

A.INTRODUCTION

  1. Expectations about how disputes should be resolved in the United Kingdom and the role of legal representatives in that process have changed significantly over recent years. In Gavin Edmondson Solicitors Ltd v Haven Insurance Co Ltd[2018] UKSC 21; [2018] 1 WLR 2052 (“Gavin Edmondson”), this Court considered a small but important piece of the jigsaw of that litigation landscape: the solicitor’s equitable lien for their costs. This remedy has been recognised by the courts for over two hundred years. In its traditional form, it entitles a solicitor who assists a client to recover money (or other property) through litigation to recoup the costs of doing so out of the money recovered. Any proceeds of a judgment or settlement will normally be paid to the solicitor’s firm, which can then deduct its costs before accounting to the client for the balance. But if the opposing party pays the money directly to the solicitor’s client despite knowing or being on notice of the solicitor’s interest in the debt, and the client then fails to pay the solicitor’s costs, the court may order the opposing party to pay those costs to the solicitor - in addition to the payment already made to the solicitor’s client.

  1. For many years the equitable lien was thought to arise only where there were court (or arbitration) proceedings in existence when the money was recovered. However, in Gavin Edmondson this Court held that the lien applied in cases where the claimant’s solicitors had notified a claim under the pre-action protocol for low value personal injury claims in road traffic accidents (the “RTA Protocol”) and the claim was then settled without the need to issue proceedings. The result was that, in the three cases before the court in Gavin Edmondson where the defendant had paid the settlement sum directly to the claimant despite knowing of the solicitor’s involvement and the claimant had not paid his or her solicitor’s costs, the defendant was ordered to pay those costs directly to the solicitor.

  1. Following the decision in Gavin Edmondson, there is no doubt that the solicitor’s equitable lien can arise where no formal proceedings have been commenced. The question raised by this appeal is where the boundary of the equitable lien lies and, specifically, whether the lien covers costs charged to clients by the appellant solicitors, Bott & Co, for claiming compensation for flight delays from the respondent, Ryanair.

  1. In our view, for the reasons given below, the rationale for the lien requires that, for a lien to arise, there must be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bott & Co Solicitors Ltd (Appellant) v Ryanair DAC (Responde... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] UKSC 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom was asked to determine whether the equitable lien of a solicitor can arise in the context of claims for flight delay compensation under Regulation (EC) No 261/2004. The central issue was whether a dispute, actual or reasonably anticipated, is necessary for the creation of the lien. The case involved Bott & Co Solicitors Ltd, which had been handling claims for flight delay compensation from Ryanair DAC, and the question of whether Bott could claim an equitable lien over the compensation sums paid by Ryanair to Bott’s clients.

The court's reasoning revealed a split decision. The majority, consisting of Lord Burrows, Lady Arden, and Lord Briggs, held that the equitable lien could indeed arise without the necessity of an actual or reasonably anticipated dispute, provided that the client is making a legal claim. They argued that the lien serves to promote access to justice and that its scope should be extended to cover any legal claim, whether or not a dispute is involved. On the other hand, the minority, comprising Lord Leggatt and Lady Rose, disagreed, asserting that the lien should remain tied to the resolution of disputes and that extending it beyond this boundary would undermine its foundational purpose.

The majority's decision was grounded on the evolving landscape of access to justice, where alternative dispute resolution methods are encouraged. They believed that the lien should cover any legal claim, regardless of the presence of a dispute, as this would support solicitors in offering their services on credit to clients who lack the financial means to pay upfront. The minority, however, emphasized that the lien's original purpose was to facilitate access to justice through litigation and that extending it beyond dispute resolution could lead to its misuse and a departure from its core principle.

The final orders of the court reflected the majority's stance, allowing Bott to claim an equitable lien over the compensation sums paid by Ryanair to its clients, thus enabling Bott to recover its costs from Ryanair directly. This decision expanded the scope of the solicitor’s equitable lien but also sparked debate on the balance between facilitating access to justice and maintaining the integrity of the lien's original purpose.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.