A1 Properties (Sunderland) Ltd (Appellant) v Tudor Studios RTM Company Ltd (Respondent)

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

[2024] UKSC 27
On appeal from: [2023] UKUT 27 (LC)

JUDGMENT

A1 Properties (Sunderland) Ltd (Appellant) vTudor Studios RTM Company Ltd (Respondent)

before

Lord Briggs
Lord Sales
Lord Hamblen
Lord Leggatt
Lord Stephens

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
16 August 2024

Heard on 8 February 2024

Appellant
Justin Bates KC
Harley Ronan
(Instructed by Brethertons LLP (Rugby))

Respondent
Winston Jacob
(Instructed by the Respondent under the Public Access Scheme)

Intervener (Association of Leasehold Enfranchisement Practitioners Ltd)
Philip Rainey KC
Mark Loveday
(Instructed by Bishop & Sewell LLP (London))

LORD BRIGGS AND LORD SALES (with whom Lord Hamblen, Lord Leggatt and Lord Stephens agree):

(1)Introduction

  1. This appeal is concerned with the operation of the regime in the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002 (“the CLRA”) under which qualifying tenants may acquire the right to take over the management of their block of flats through the formation and interposition of a right to manage (“RTM”) company.

  1. The acquisition process requires the RTM company to serve a notice of claim (which we will call a “claim notice”) to acquire the right to manage their block on, among others, each person who is a landlord under a lease of the whole or any part of the premises: section 79(6)(a). The period of such a lease may be short or long. There is no register of all leases covered by this provision nor any simple and conclusive way of checking who every such landlord might be.

  1. Save in limited circumstances not applicable here the CLRA does not contain a provision which expressly stipulates what is to happen if a claim notice is served on some, but not all, landlords. In light of the absence of any simple means of checking who all the landlords are, there is a real chance that this situation could arise in a significant number of cases. Service on some landlords will trigger the acquisition process, but on the basis of a procedural defect. The question which arises is what is the effect of a failure to comply with section 79(6)(a).

  1. The issues on the appeal are:

    1. Whether a failure to serve a claim notice on a landlord as required by section 79(6)(a) will always invalidate the acquisition of the right to manage powers by the RTM company pursuant to the process purportedly commenced by service of the claim notice on other relevant landlords; and

    1. If not, whether nevertheless the failure to serve the claim notice in this case on all relevant landlords had the effect of invalidating the purported acquisition of the right to manage powers by the RTM company pursuant to the CLRA acquisition process.

    As well as submissions from the parties, the court was assisted by oral and written submissions from the Association of Leasehold Enfranchisement Practitioners Ltd, as intervener.

  1. There is Court of Appeal authority which gives a negative answer to the question posed under issue (1): Elim Court RTM Co Ltd v Avon Freeholds Ltd [2017] EWCA Civ 89; [2018] QB 571 (“Elim Court”).…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A1 Properties (Sunderland) Ltd (Appellant) v Tudor Studios R... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] UKSC 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the effect of a failure to serve a claim notice on a landlord as required by section 79(6)(a) of the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002 (the "CLRA"). The appellant, A1 Properties (Sunderland) Ltd, argued that the failure to serve the claim notice on it invalidated the acquisition of the right to manage powers by the respondent RTM company pursuant to the CLRA acquisition process. The respondent, Tudor Studios RTM Company Ltd, contended that the failure did not invalidate the acquisition and that the reasoning in Elim Court [2017] EWCA Civ 89; [2018] QB 571 was correctly decided. The Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) (Judge Cooke) [2023] UKUT 27 (LC) had considered itself bound by the ruling in Elim Court and dismissed the appeal. The Supreme Court was asked to consider whether the failure to serve a claim notice on a landlord always invalidates the acquisition of the right to manage powers by the RTM company, and if not, whether the failure to serve the claim notice in this case invalidated the acquisition. The Court of Appeal had held in Elim Court that a failure to serve a claim notice on an intermediate landlord with no management functions did not invalidate the acquisition. The Supreme Court agreed with the Court of Appeal's approach in Elim Court, but qualified it. The failure to serve a claim notice on a landlord did not always invalidate the acquisition, but rendered the transfer of the right to manage voidable, at the instance of the relevant landlord, unless or until the tribunal approved the transfer scheme. The Supreme Court concluded that the failure to serve the claim notice on the appellant did not invalidate the acquisition, since the tribunal had approved the transfer scheme and the appellant had the opportunity to support the objections presented by the Management Company. The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established