YL NZ Investment Ltd v Ling

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2017-404-444 [2017] NZHC 1793

BETWEEN

YL NZ INVESTMENT LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

LOUISE LING Defendant

Hearing: 7 August 2017

Appearances:

J L Foster for the Plaintiff
G M Illingworth QC for the Defendant

Judgment:

7 August 2017

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL

Solicitors:

Ben Liu & Co, Mt Albert, Auckland, for the Plaintiff

Hong Hu Lawyers, Auckland, for the Defendant
Counsel:

Jody L Foster, Auckland, for the Plaintiff

Grant M Illingworth QC for the Defendant

YL NZ INVESTMENT LIMITED v LOUISE LING [2017] NZHC 1793 [7 August 2017]

[1]      YL NZ Investment Ltd, the nominee under an agreement dated 21 December

2015 to buy a property at 170 Station Road, Pukekohe, settled the purchase on 13 June

2016.  Under the agreement, the purchase price was $3.5 million inclusive of GST.  YL NZ Investment Ltd was registered under the Goods and Service Tax Act 1985.   The vendor, Louise Ling, gave a warranty that she was not.  When YL NZ Investment Ltd made a claim for an input tax refund, the Inland Revenue turned it down.  It said that while Ms Ling was not registered for GST, she should have been.  In September 2016 it registered her for GST with effect from 8 May 2015.  Because of that, the supply under the agreement of 21 December 2015 was zero-rated under s 11(1)(mb) of the Goods and Services Tax Act.  Because of that zero-rating YL NZ Investment Ltd could not claim the input tax refund which it had calculated at $365,869.57.  In reaching that figure it had taken into account a house and curtilage.

[2]      It sues Ms Ling as vendor for breach of warranty.  It says that if she had been correct in her warranty that she was not registered for GST it would have received the refund  of  $365,869.57.    It  also  claims  professional  fees  for  $5,314.00  incurred  in dealing with the Inland Revenue’s rejection of its claim for an input tax credit.  It has applied for summary judgment.

[3]      In opposition, Ms Ling says that she did not breach the warranty under the agreement because as a matter of fact she was not registered for GST.  She notes that at relevant times the only director of YL NZ Investment Ltd did not live in New Zealand so as to satisfy the requirement of s 10(d) of the Companies Act 1993.  She says that because of that failure to comply with the Companies Act, YL NZ Investment Ltd arguably was not entitled to register for GST and that any damages claimed are tainted with illegality.  She invokes the ex turpi causa doctrine.

[4]      There  is  no  dispute  as  to  the  principles  applied  in  summary  judgment applications.1

1      Krukziener v Hanover Finance Ltd [2008] NZCA 187, (2008) 19 PRNZ 162 at [26]-[27].

Facts

[5]      Ms Ling made an agreement to buy the property at 170 Station Road, Pukekohe, on 2 July 2015.  The property, 4.6089 hectares in area, has a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read YL NZ Investment Ltd v Ling and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1793
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

YL NZ Investment Ltd sued Louise Ling for breach of warranty in a real estate transaction. YL NZ Investment Ltd, a GST-registered company, had purchased a property from Ms Ling on the basis of a warranty that Ms Ling was not registered for GST. When YL NZ Investment Ltd sought a GST input tax refund, the Inland Revenue rejected the claim because Ms Ling had been GST-registered since May 2015, making the transaction zero-rated and ineligible for a refund. YL NZ Investment Ltd sued Ms Ling for breach of warranty and sought damages of $365,869.57 (the amount of the rejected refund) plus $5,314.00 (professional fees for dealing with the rejection). The court had to decide whether Ms Ling had breached the warranty and whether YL NZ Investment Ltd was entitled to damages. The court found that Ms Ling had breached the warranty by falsely stating that she was not registered for GST. Although Ms Ling had not been GST-registered at the time of the transaction, the court found that she had been liable to be registered because she had carried on taxable activities. The court also found that YL NZ Investment Ltd was entitled to damages. The court rejected Ms Ling's argument that YL NZ Investment Ltd could not recover because it had not had a New Zealand-resident director at the time of the transaction. The court also rejected the argument that YL NZ Investment Ltd could not recover because the damages were not within the reasonable contemplation of the parties or because they arose ex turpi causa. The court granted YL NZ Investment Ltd judgment for $390,044.04 (the amount claimed plus interest) and reserved leave to continue the proceeding if YL NZ Investment Ltd was able to show that it had a claim for further liabilities.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.