IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE
CIV-2019-404-1267
[2020] NZHC 1870
BETWEEN PETER ALLAN WORK and ROBYN MARGARET WORK
PlaintiffsAND
IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Defendant
Hearing: 24 July 2020 Appearances:
G Jones for the plaintiffs
C Stevens and H Stanford for the defendant
Judgment:
30 July 2020
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE JOHNSTON
[1] On 23 November 2013 a residential property owned by the plaintiffs in Wellington was damaged or destroyed by fire. On 27 June 2019 the plaintiffs commenced this proceeding against the defendant, their insurer, under a contract of insurance claiming the indemnity value of the house and various other heads of damage. The total claim is for more than $800,000 plus interest and costs.
[2] The defendant denies liability inter alia on the basis that the fire was commenced deliberately by the plaintiffs — or, rather, the first-named plaintiff, Mr Work. This denial is pleaded as an affirmative defence in the defendant’s amended statement of defence dated 6 December 2019. For ease of reference I set out the pleading:
19The policies expressly exclude cover for any loss that is caused intentionally by the insured.
WORK v IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2020] NZHC 1870 [30 July 2020]
20The fire was intentionally caused by one of the plaintiffs, Mr Work.
Particulars
20.1Mr Work used remote access computer software installed on his laptop to remotely access a printer located at the property.
20.2Mr Work had prepared a piece of paper in the printer with cellotape attached.
20.3When he printed the paper, and cellotape pulled through the contact on the switch turning the standard lamp on, which ignited the fire.
21Mr Work had the motive, means and opportunity to cause the fire, and did so. Further particulars will be provided following discovery, but include:
Particulars
Motive
21.1The plaintiffs were in severe financial difficulty. They had very limited income, large debts and unmet tax liability, and their two houses were highly leveraged to ASB Bank plus they had second tier borrowing from Finance Now Limited.
21.2Having received a notice to rectify from Wellington City Council, the Works had substantial code compliance costs for maintenance work on the property. The back wall of the property was also starting to leak.
21.3The Works had tried to sell the property, but had been unsuccessful.
21.4The tenants in the property had moved out due to infighting and it was unlet[.]
21.5Mr Work was struggling with his mental health and alcohol consumption.
21.6On the Thursday before the fire, the Works shifted their remaining personal effects of value out of the house.
21.7Shortly after Mr Work sent the print command which caused the fire, the LogMeIn entries were deleted.
Means
21.8Mr Work had the necessary computing and electrical knowledge to cause the fire.
21.9He built his own multiboard that was being used in the room of origin.
21.10The only power left on at the property was a small sub-main in the downstairs converted garage where the fire…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Work v IAG New Zealand Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] NZHC 1870
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the requirements for pleadings in civil litigation, noting that pleadings must be sufficiently detailed to inform the opposing party of the case they must meet. The court rejected the plaintiffs' argument that arson cases require special pleading rules, stating that the same standards apply to all cases. The plaintiffs sought detailed information about the precise manner in which the fire ignited, the time of ignition, the acts allegedly carried out by Mr Work, and the sequence of events leading to the fire. The court found that the defendant had provided sufficient detail in its pleadings to inform the plaintiffs of the case against them, and that the plaintiffs' requests went beyond what is required for pleadings.
The court declined to order the defendant to provide further particulars, concluding that the plaintiffs were not entitled to any additional information beyond what was already pleaded. The court also found that other requests, such as those seeking to distinguish between direct evidence and inferences, were not proper subjects for a request for particulars. The court held that the defendant was not obliged to offer assurances that it would not call evidence outside the scope of its pleaded case. The plaintiffs' application for particularisation was dismissed, and the defendant was awarded costs on a 2B basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi