Wilson v Parua Bay Farms Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WHANGĀREI-TERENGA-PARĀOA ROHE

CIV-2015-488-000106

[2019] NZHC 275

BETWEEN ALLAN ANDREW WILSON and JOAN CECELIA WILSON
Plaintiffs

AND

PARUA BAY FARMS LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 25-29 June, 3-4 December 2018

Appearances:

R A Rosser and D M Fraundorfer for Plaintiffs S R Carey for Defendant

Judgment:

27 February 2019


JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J


This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 27 February 2019 at 3.00 pm

pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date……………………..

WILSON v PARUA BAY FARMS LTD [2019] NZHC 275 [27 February 2019]

Introduction [1]
The claims under the Land Lease [5]
The terms of the Land Lease [5]
Outgoings [18]
Repairs and maintenance to tracks and fences: claim and counterclaim 19]
Gorse [30]
Damaged carpet [31]
Hot water capacity in milking shed [32]
Pond [35]
Dosatron pump [36]
Shed doors [38]
Fertiliser [40]
Rent: counterclaim by PBF [41]
Summary of claim and counterclaim under the Land Lease [44]
The Gates Agreement [46]
The Stock Agreement and Cow Bailment Agreement [49]
The issues [49]
The terms of the Stock Agreement [54]
Were the purchase cows required to be pure-bred Friesian? [67]
What did “vetted-in-calf” mean? [74]
Did PBF agree to pay lease fees on the purchase cows pending a formal
agreement? [78]
The herd as delivered to PBF [80]
How many cows? [80]
The state of the records [81]
The health of the cows [89]
PBF’s counterclaim [108]
Age of stock [108]
Grazing cows off-site [110]
Veterinary fees [111]
Loss of expected profit [112]
The Wilsons’ claim arising from the return of the cows [119]
Events in 2015 [119]
Return of cows [125]
Summary and result [134]

Introduction

[1]    Parua Bay Farms Ltd (PBF) owns a 126-hectare farm near Whangarei which it leased to Allan and Joan Wilson in 2011 (the Land Lease). Mr and Mrs Wilson, who were experienced dairy farmers, ran their herd of dairy cows on the farm until June 2014. At the end of the lease PBF agreed to buy 40 of their cows and lease 160 others for three years (the Stock Agreement). The Wilsons allege a further separate agreement (which PBF denies) relating to the care of the cows and terms on which the herd would be returned at the end of the Stock Agreement (the Cow Bailment Agreement). Disputes arose within a short time of PBF taking over the herd and continued until June 2017, when the term of the Stock Agreement expired.

[2]The Wilsons sue PBF for:

(a)damages, or alternative relief, for the cost of repair work on the farm and outgoings they say PBF was obliged to meet under the Land Lease;

(b)the value of five gates that they say PBF agreed to buy and failed to pay for;

(c)the purchase price and lease fees due under the Stock Agreement;

(d)losses arising from PBF’s failure to provide access to the cows for inspection and proper animal records at the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wilson v Parua Bay Farms Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 275
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wilson v Parua Bay Farms Limited involved a dispute between two parties over the terms of a land lease and a stock agreement. The plaintiffs, Allan and Joan Wilson, leased a farm to the defendant, Parua Bay Farms Limited (PBF), and later entered into a stock agreement for the purchase and lease of cows. Disputes arose between the parties over the terms of the lease and stock agreement, as well as the condition of the cows and farm. The plaintiffs sued PBF for damages, or alternative relief, for the cost of repair work on the farm and outgoings they say PBF was obliged to meet under the Land Lease. The plaintiffs also sought the value of five gates that they say PBF agreed to buy and failed to pay for, the purchase price and lease fees due under the Stock Agreement, and losses arising from PBF’s failure to provide access to the cows for inspection and proper animal records at the end of the Stock Agreement. PBF counterclaimed for damages arising from the Wilsons’ alleged failure to comply with the terms of the Land Lease requiring them to repair and maintain the farm, as well as damages for breaches of the Stock Agreement in relation to the breed of the cows being purchased and the health and age of the herd. The court found that the terms of the Land Lease were those on which the parties expressly agreed, together with the terms implied by the Property Law Act 2007. The Wilsons’ claim for the costs of repairing the tracks and fences and for the outgoings and utility charges failed. PBF’s claim for losses arising from breaches of the Land Lease obligations was allowed in part. The Wilsons’ claim under the Gates Agreement failed because PBF did not agree to buy the gates. The court found that it was not a term of the Stock Agreement that the 40 purchase cows had to be pure Friesian. The Wilsons supplied 200 cows for purchase/lease in accordance with the Stock Agreement. The court found that there was a significant degree of mastitis infection in the herd that amounted to a breach of the term that the cows would be healthy and good milk producers. The court found that the Stock Agreement was subject to implied terms based on industry usage under which the cows were leased with a five-week “in-calf” guarantee and PBF was required to return the same number of cows in a comparable state, with records, at the end of the lease period. The Wilsons’ claim for breach of the Stock Agreement succeeded. The Wilsons were entitled to judgment in the sum of $180,776. PBF’s counterclaim for breach of the Stock Agreement succeeded only in part. PBF was entitled to judgment for $16,317.02. The parties were entitled to interest on their respective judgment sums at 5 per cent per year from the date of filing of the statement of claim and statement of counterclaim, respectively.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established