Wilson v Parua Bay Farms Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WHANGĀREI-TERENGA-PARĀOA ROHE

CIV-2015-488-000106

[2019] NZHC 1355

BETWEEN ALLAN ANDREW WILSON and JOAN CECELIA WILSON
Plaintiff

AND

PARUA BAY FARMS LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 25-29 June, 3-4 December 2018

Appearances:

R A Rosser for Plaintiffs S R Carey for Defendant

Judgment:

14 June 2019


JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

[Costs]


This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney On 14 June 2019 at 3 pm

pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date……………………..

WILSON v PARUA BAY FARMS LIMITED [2019] NZHC 1355 [14 June 2019]

Introduction

[1]                 In my decision of 27 February 2019 (reissued on 16 May 2019), I gave judgment for the plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Wilson, for $200,276.1 I gave judgment for the defendant, Parua Bay Farms Ltd (PBF) on its counterclaim  for  $55,586.09. Each party seeks costs.

[2]                 The Wilsons’ claim and PBF’s counterclaim both arose from contractual arrangements under which the Wilsons leased a farm from  PBF  for  three  years (the Land Lease) and at the end of the lease agreed to sell some of their herd and lease the rest to PBF for three years (the Stock Agreement).2 Despite extensive alternative pleadings by the Wilsons, both claim and counterclaim were properly determined as straightforward contract cases.

[3]                 The issues arising from the Land Lease and the Stock Agreement respectively accounted for roughly one-third and two-thirds  of the time and attention at trial.3  The Wilsons claimed a total of $346,643.32 and obtained a judgment sum of $200,276 (58 per cent of their claim). By comparison, PBF claimed a total of $424,592 but secured a judgment sum for only $55,586.09 (13 per cent of its claim).

[4]                 The litigation has a long history, which has resulted in much higher costs to the parties than should have been necessary. There have been many interlocutory applications. The first trial date was vacated. The second trial was adjourned part-heard. Both parties claim to have succeeded overall. Both seek increased costs. The Wilsons consider that they should have costs and not be required to pay costs on the counterclaim. PBF says that costs ought to be fixed and payable by each party on their respective claim and counterclaim.

[5]                 Rule 14.16 of the High Court Rules 2016 deals with the situation where both a claim and counterclaim have been established:


1      Wilson v Parua Bay Farms Ltd [2019] NZHC 275 at [134]–[137].

2      I treated the  Stock  Agreement  as  encompassing  the  arrangements  pleaded  separately  by  the Wilsons as the Cow Bailment Agreement. In addition there was another minor claim pleaded as the Gates Agreement.

3      The Gates Agreement accounted for a negligible amount of time and attention at trial.

The court must award costs as if each party had succeeded in an independent proceeding, unless, in the court’s opinion, the justice of the case otherwise requires, if—

(a)the plaintiff succeeds in his or her proceeding; and

(b)the defendant succeeds in a counterclaim.

[6]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wilson v Parua Bay Farms Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 1355
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Allan and Joan Wilson and Parua Bay Farms Limited (PBF) centred on contractual disputes arising from the lease of a farm and the subsequent sale and lease of livestock. The High Court of New Zealand, Whangarei Registry, presided over by Justice Courtney, delivered judgment on 14 June 2019. The Wilsons sued PBF for breaches under a land lease and a stock agreement, while PBF counterclaimed for losses under both agreements. The court found in favour of the Wilsons on their claim and in favour of PBF on its counterclaim. Both parties sought costs, with the Wilsons arguing they should be awarded costs without having to pay any on the counterclaim, while PBF argued for a fixed costs regime.

The court ruled that the justice of the case required a departure from the usual position where both a claim and counterclaim are successful. It found that PBF pursued its counterclaim in a manner intended to deter the Wilsons, advancing a claim that it could not substantiate. The court determined that the Wilsons were the overall successful party but reduced their costs to account for various objections raised by PBF, including over-pleading, the late introduction of IT evidence, and the Wilsons' unreasonable stance on the health of the cows. The court also considered settlement offers made by both parties but found no unreasonable refusal to settle. The final costs were calculated with appropriate reductions and allowances for disbursements. The court ordered that the Wilsons, as the overall successful party, would be awarded costs with the specified reductions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established