Webb v Smith HC Tauranga Civ-2010-470-000264

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CIV-2010-470-000264

IN THE MATTER OF     The Law Reform (Testamentary Promises) Act 1949

AND IN THE MATTER OF the Estate of LOLA ETHEL WEBB

BETWEEN  ROBERT WILLIAM WEBB AND NICHOLAS ANDREW WEBB Plaintiffs

ANDPAMELA SMITH AND LAURENCE JOHN BRYAN AS EXECUTORS AND TRUSTEES OF THE ESTATE OF LOLA ETHEL WEBB

Defendants

Hearing:         23-24 June 2011

Appearances: W Nabney for the Plaintiffs

S Barter for the Defendants

Judgment:      14 October 2011

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF ELLIS J

This judgment was delivered by me on 14 October 2011 at 4 pm, pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:      Simpson Aspen Law, PO Box 13537, Tauranga 3141

Barter & Co, PO Box 197, Albany, Auckland 0755

Counsel:       W Nabney, PO Box 13 007, Tauranga 3141

[1]      Robert and Nicholas Webb are the adult sons of John David Webb who died on 24 August 2007.  The defendants are the executors and trustees of the estate of

WEBB V EXECUTORS AND TRUSTEES OF THE ESTATE OF LOLA ETHEL WEBB HC TAU CIV-2010-

470-000264 14 October 2011

Lola Ethel Webb who died in July 2009.  They are also two of Lola Webb‟s children.

John married Lola on 5 October 1997.

[2]      This judgment concerns claims against Lola‟s estate brought by Robert and Nicholas Webb under s 3 of the Law Reform (Testamentary Promises) Act 1949 and in reliance on the equitable doctrine of Mutual Wills.

Facts

[3]      John Webb‟s first wife (Robert and Nicholas Webb‟s mother) died in 1991. Lola Webb had herself previously been married and had four children of that marriage, Diane Allan, Pamela Smith, Laurence Bryan and Roger Bryan.

[4]      Just prior to marrying Lola, John Webb sold what had been his previous matrimonial  home  and  moved  into  what  had  been  Lola‟s  matrimonial  home  in Yatton Street, Tauranga, over which there was no mortgage.  It was not clear on the evidence what became of the proceeds of the sale of John‟s house (approximately

$140,000) and in particular whether there was any co-mingling of Lola‟s and John‟s finances.  The evidence for the defendants was that Lola continued to pay the rates and outgoings and also paid for overseas holidays.

[5]      Neither Robert nor Nicholas attended John and Lola‟s  wedding in October

1997.  While they both gave reasons for their absence that day it seems moderately clear from the evidence that Robert in particular was not well pleased with  his father‟s remarriage.

[6]      In particular, at about the time of the wedding it seems that Robert wrote a letter, either to his father or (according to Robert‟s evidence) to Lola.  Although that letter has not survived, it was found by Laurence Bryan and his wife Roanne when they were clearing out John and Lola‟s house following Lola‟s death.  Their evidence was that they both read some or all of the letter (which they said was addressed to John) and then gave it, along with other of John‟s possessions, to John‟s younger brother, Derek…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Webb v Smith HC Tauranga Civ-2010-470-000264 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1512
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Webb v Smith was heard in the High Court of New Zealand and concerns claims brought by Robert and Nicholas Webb, the sons of John Webb, against the estate of Lola Ethel Webb. The claims are based on a promise made by Lola in a letter dated October 1997, which the plaintiffs claim was part of a testamentary promise and an agreement of mutual wills. The defendants, Pamela Smith and Laurence Bryan as executors and trustees of Lola's estate, dispute the authenticity of the letter and the validity of the claims. The court found that the plaintiffs' testamentary promises claim under the Law Reform (Testamentary Promises) Act 1949 and their claim for enforcement of mutual wills must fail. The court held that the plaintiffs did not establish the requisite nexus between their alleged forbearance and Lola's promise, and that there was insufficient evidence of an agreement or arrangement between Lola and John to bind them to a future course of inaction regarding their wills. The plaintiffs are to pay the defendants' costs on a 2B basis.