Vance v Vey Group Ltd (in liq and rec)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE PAPAIOEA ROHE

CIV 2018-485-505

[2022] NZHC 75

UNDER the Companies Act 1993 and the Receiverships Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF

Vey Group Limited (in receivership and liquidation)

BETWEEN

DAVID VANCE and IAN MILLARD

Plaintiffs

AND

VEY GROUP LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION AND RECEIVERSHIP)

First Defendant

LESLIE WILLIAM FUGLE
Second Defendant

COMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE

Third Defendant

Hearing: 2 and 3 September 2021 via VMR

Counsel:

R L Roff for Plaintiff

R L Pinny for Liquidators of First Defendant

F E Geiringer and J K Mahuta-Coyle for Second Defendant (interlocutory applicant)

K I S Naik-Leong for Third Defendant

Judgment:

2 February 2022


JUDGMENT OF MALLON J


Table of contents

Introduction  [1]

Review of Orana debt  [2]

Background  [2]

VANCE v VEY GROUP LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION AND RECEIVERSHIP) [2022] NZHC 75 [2 February 2022]

Grounds for challenge  [10]

Review standard  [11]

Liquidators’ decision  [16]

Documentation  [25]

Nature of the transactions  [30]

Limitation  [46]

Conclusion  [64]

Application to terminate liquidation  [65]

Application for approval of share transfer  [69]

Result  [71]

Introduction

[1]    Vey Group Limited (Vey) was initially placed into receivership, then into liquidation, following a successful application made by the trustees of the Orana Trust (Orana) that Vey, through Mr Fugle, was being conducted in a manner that was oppressive, unfairly discriminatory and unfairly prejudicial to Orana as minority shareholders.1 Mr Fugle now applies to the Court to review the liquidators’ decision to admit a debt claimed by Orana in the liquidation.2 If that application is successful, he also applies for an order terminating the liquidation of Vey.3 Lastly, he applies for an order authorising the transfer of legal title to 49 shares in Vey from the trustees of Orana to Mr Fugle.4

Review of Orana debt

Background

[2]    Orana brought an application under s 174 of the Companies Act seeking relief from the unfairly oppressive, unfairly discriminatory and unfairly prejudicial conduct of Mr Fugle. At that time, he was the sole director of Vey and was in a position to


1      Companies Act 1993, s 174; Vance v Vey Group Ltd [2018] NZHC 1994; Vance v Vey Group Ltd [2019] NZHC 1676, [2020] NZCCLR 5 [Vance v Vey Group Ltd (HC, 2019)] at [66]–[72]; Vey Group Ltd v Vance [2020] NZCA 232, [2020] NZCCLR 24 [Vey Group Ltd v Vance (CA, 2020)] at [36], [61] and [68]–[69]; and Vance v Vey Group Ltd [2020] NZHC 2592 [Vance v Vey Group Ltd (HC, 2020)].

2      Companies Act, s 284(1)(b). Leave was earlier granted by the Court: Vance v Vey Group Ltd HC Palmerston North CIV-2018-485-505, 12 April 2021, Minute of Thomas J.

3      Section 250.

4      Section 248.

control it. There were a range of issues in the conduct of Vey of concern to Orana. One of them was a dispute between Orana and Mr Fugle over a debt claimed by Orana against Vey.

[3]A demand for that debt…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vance v Vey Group Ltd (in liq and rec) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was asked to review the liquidators' decision to admit a debt claimed by Orana in the liquidation of Vey Group Limited. The Court was also asked to terminate the liquidation and approve the transfer of shares from the trustees of Orana to Leslie Fugle. The liquidators had admitted a debt of $1,040,810 owed by Vey to Orana, which Fugle contested on the grounds of inadequate documentation, improper treatment as a running current account, and limitation. The Court found that the liquidators' decision to admit the Orana debt was reasonable, as there was sufficient documentation to support the validity of the debt, the liquidators had properly treated the debt as a shareholder's current account, and no limitation defence was available. The application to terminate the liquidation was not pursued as it was dependent on the outcome of the review application, which was unsuccessful. Finally, the Court approved the transfer of the trustees' 49% shareholding to Fugle on the agreed terms.

The Court held that the liquidators' decision to admit the Orana debt was reasonable, as there was sufficient documentation to support the validity of the debt, the liquidators had properly treated the debt as a shareholder's current account, and no limitation defence was available. The Court found that the liquidators had exercised their discretion reasonably by accepting the receivers' analysis that there was sufficient documentation to support the validity of the Orana debt. The Court also held that it was reasonable for the liquidators to treat the transactions as a shareholder's current account, as it was consistent with the relationship between the parties, the way in which the debt arose, the treatment of the debt in the financial statements, and standard accounting practice for reconciling intermingled funds between related entities. Finally, the Court held that no limitation defence was available, as the cause of action did not accrue until demand was made, which occurred on 28 June 2018. The Court also approved the transfer of the trustees' 49% shareholding to Fugle on the agreed terms, and dismissed the application to terminate the liquidation as it was dependent on the outcome of the review application, which was unsuccessful.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.