Vance v Jefferys

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-485-2546 [2014] NZHC 1932

IN THE MATTER OF

An application under section 136 and 301

of the Companies Act 1993

BETWEEN

DAVID STUART VANCE AND COLIN DAVID OWENS

Plaintiffs

AND

NEVILLE WARREN JEFFERYS Defendant

Hearing: 17 June 2014

Counsel:

J Grant for Plaintiffs
A Isac for Defendant

Judgment:

15 August 2014

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH

[1]      Brooklyn Rise Limited (Brooklyn) was incorporated on 7 February 2012. The defendant, Neville Jefferys, was the sole director.

[2]      Brooklyn’s only activity appears to have been the purchase and subsequent sale of five completed or nearly completed townhouses at Tiketike Way, Brooklyn, Wellington.   Brooklyn bought the five townhouses a few days after it was incorporated, from a company called Spinnaker Investments No. 1 Limited (Spinnaker).    The  sale  by Spinnaker  was  made  in  the  exercise  of  its  rights  as mortgagee   under   a   mortgage   or   mortgages   given   by  an   earlier   developer, Gordon Place Development Limited (Gordon Place).

[3]      Brooklyn  agreed  to  pay  Spinnaker  $1,950,000  plus  GST  for  the  five townhouses. That was the amount then owing by Gordon Place to Spinnaker.

DAVID STUART VANCE AND COLIN DAVID OWENS v NEVILLE WARREN JEFFERYS [2014] NZHC

1932 [15 August 2014]

[4]      An unusual feature of the transaction was that Brooklyn put no money into the purchase.  Spinnaker provided vendor finance for the full $1,950,000 plus GST, and also agreed to provide a $250,000 development facility so that Brooklyn could complete certain work, including the erection of a new retaining wall, which had to be built before code compliance certificates could be obtained for the townhouses. There were also brokerage and facility fees of $44,000 which Spinnaker agreed to fund.

[5]      Spinnaker did not require any personal guarantee from Mr Jefferys.

[6]      The term of the loan was four months from the date of the initial advance, which was expected to be on 16 February 2012.  Interest over the term of the loan (estimated to be $70,000) was to be capitalised monthly in arrears.

[7]      In total, Spinnaker agreed to fund a total of $2,314,000 for the acquisition and development of the townhouses by Brooklyn.

[8]      One of the townhouses (number 77 Tiketike Way – “No. 77”) was already subject to a sale agreement entered into by Gordon Place.   This agreement was adopted by Brooklyn as part of the agreement it made with Spinnaker.   Brooklyn completed the work on the townhouses, and over the period between February and 6

May 2012, it entered into agreements to sell the four unsold townhouses.

[9]      Another  unusual  feature  of  the  arrangements  between  Spinnaker  and Brooklyn was that Spinnaker exercised direct control over the development work.  It decided  which  contractors  were  to  be  engaged,  and  all  contractors’  accounts, although addressed to Brooklyn, were emailed to Spinnaker for payment direct to the contractor.  As Mr Jefferys put it in his evidence, Spinnaker “micro-managed” the project, making unilateral decisions as to who would get paid, how much, and when.

[10]     Brooklyn was liable for GST…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vance v Jefferys and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1932
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, David Stuart Vance and Colin David Owens, the liquidators of Brooklyn Rise Limited, sought an order under section 136 and 301 of the Companies Act 1993 against Neville Warren Jefferys, the sole director of Brooklyn. The liquidators argued that Mr Jefferys had no reasonable grounds to believe that Brooklyn would be able to meet its GST liabilities, which resulted in the company being put into liquidation. The key legal issues were whether the summary judgment procedure was appropriate for this case, whether Mr Jefferys had a reasonable defence that Spinnaker promised to cover the GST liability, and whether Spinnaker acted as a shadow director. The court held that the case was unsuitable for summary judgment as there were significant questions over the extent of Mr Jefferys' culpability and the role of Spinnaker. The court found that Mr Jefferys had no reasonable grounds to believe that Brooklyn would be able to meet its GST liabilities, but it was arguable that Spinnaker may have acted as a shadow director and shared responsibility for the GST shortfall. Therefore, the application for summary judgment was refused.