Vance v Jefferys

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-485-2546 [2015] NZHC 1202

IN THE MATTER OF

an application under sections 136 and 301

Companies Act 1993

BETWEEN

DAVID STUART VANCE AND COLIN DAVID OWENS AS LIQUIDATORS OF BROOKLYN RISE LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

Plaintiffs

AND

NEVILLE WARREN JEFFERYS Defendant

Hearing: 25 May 2015

Counsel:

G J Toebes for plaintiffs

P C Gilbert for defendant (on adjournment application)

Judgment:

2 June 2015

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      In this proceeding, the plaintiffs (the liquidators) seek judgment for the GST liability of Brooklyn Rise Limited (in liquidation) (Brooklyn Rise) on the sales of five residential units in a development in suburban Wellington.  The liquidators have brought the claim against the defendant (Mr Jefferys) on the basis that he was the sole director of Brooklyn Rise and responsible for the conduct of its business.  The liquidators claimed that Mr Jefferys breached his duty not to incur obligations when there were no reasonable grounds for believing that Brooklyn Rise would be able to

perform its obligations when required to do so.1

[2]      The unpaid GST liabilities arose between May and August 2012 and these proceedings  were  commenced  in  February 2014.    In  June 2014,  the  liquidators

1      Companies Act 1993, s 136.

pursued   an   application   for   summary   judgment   on   their   claim,   which   was successfully defended by counsel then acting for Mr Jefferys.

[3]      In   declining   summary   judgment,2    Associate   Judge   Smith   found   that Mr Jefferys had breached the relevant duty under the Companies Act 1993 (the Act). He declined to enter judgment, preferring that the quantum of the compensation Mr Jefferys should be ordered to pay should be determined at trial.

Adjournment application

[4]      In  October  2014,  Associate  Judge  Smith  made  timetabling  orders  for completion of discovery and other pre-trial steps.

[5]      On   18 November   2014,   counsel   then   acting   for   Mr Jefferys   filed   a memorandum seeking leave to withdraw.   On the same day, Mr Jefferys filed a memorandum as to change of representation and address for service, indicating that he was acting for himself.

[6]      In December 2014, the liquidators completed discovery by filing and serving an affidavit of documents.   Discovery was not completed by Mr Jefferys.   The present fixture was allocated on 5 November 2014.

[7]      On 18 May 2015, I convened a telephone conference with the parties to review readiness for the hearing.   Mr Jefferys advised that he believed Mr John Langford,  a Wellington  solicitor,  had  accepted  instructions  but  had  not  advised Mr Jefferys that he would be unable to prepare for and represent him at the hearing. Because of that, Mr Jefferys anticipated making an application to adjourn the fixture. Mr Langford advised the Court by email that he had not received instructions, and had not been involved apart from a brief discussion with Mr Jefferys late in 2014.  In part  because  of  apparent  discrepancies  between  the  indications  the  Court  had received from Messrs Langford and Jefferys, I made the following direction:

I have directed Mr Jefferys to make any application for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vance v Jefferys and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1202
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs in this proceeding are David Stuart Vance and Colin David Owens, liquidators of Brooklyn Rise Limited (in liquidation) (Brooklyn Rise). They are seeking judgment for the GST liability of Brooklyn Rise on the sales of five residential units in a development in suburban Wellington. The defendant is Neville Warren Jefferys. The liquidators claim that Mr Jefferys was the sole director of Brooklyn Rise and responsible for the conduct of its business. They claim that Mr Jefferys breached his duty not to incur obligations when there were no reasonable grounds for believing that Brooklyn Rise would be able to perform its obligations when required to do so. The unpaid GST liabilities arose between May and August 2012, and these proceedings were commenced in February 2014. The liquidators have brought the claim against Mr Jefferys on the basis that he was the sole director of Brooklyn Rise and responsible for the conduct of its business. The liquidators claimed that Mr Jefferys breached the relevant duty under the Companies Act 1993 (the Act). The court was required to decide whether Mr Jefferys breached his duty under s 136 of the Act by incurring obligations when there were no reasonable grounds for believing that Brooklyn Rise would be able to perform its obligations when required to do so. The court also had to determine whether Spinnaker was a shadow director of Brooklyn Rise, and if so, whether it should be liable for the compensation that Mr Jefferys was ordered to pay. The court also had to decide the appropriate level of compensation that Mr Jefferys ought to pay as a director in breach of his s 136 duty.

The court found that Mr Jefferys breached his duty under s 136 of the Act by incurring obligations when there were no reasonable grounds for believing that Brooklyn Rise would be able to perform its obligations when required to do so. The court rejected Mr Jefferys' defence that there had been substantial cost overruns in completing the properties, and that there was a reasonable prospect of profitable returns on a subsequent stage of the development. The court found that Spinnaker was not a shadow director of Brooklyn Rise, and that Mr Jefferys was liable for the compensation that he was ordered to pay. The court also found that the appropriate level of compensation that Mr Jefferys ought to pay was 80 per cent of the two later unpaid GST liabilities, which amounted to $165,000. The liquidators were also entitled to costs on a 2B basis for a one hour formal proof hearing.