Urquhart-Barrett v Accident Compensation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CRI-2014-409-000020 [2014] NZHC 1585

BETWEEN

LESLIE WAYNE URQUHART-

BARRETT Appellant

AND

ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION

Respondent

Hearing: 3 July 2014

Appearances:

R J Burnside for Mr Urquhart-Barrett
K B Bell for the Crown

Judgment:

8 July 2014

JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J

Introduction

Conviction

[1]      On  11  July  2013  the  appellant  (Mr  Urquhart-Barrett)  was  convicted  by Judge Farish in the District Court of obtaining a pecuniary advantage by deception in contravention of s 240 Crimes Act 1961.1   The conviction related to offending which extended over an eight month period.  It did not relate to the 16 month full period of offending originally alleged  by the  respondent  (ACC), (being April  2009  to  31

August 2010), but rather for a reduced period of offending “from Christmas 2009 through to August 2010”.2

[2]      In her judgment of 11  July 2013, Judge Farish deferred sentencing until

14 August 2013 and also called for a full pre-sentence report.3

1      ACC v Urquhart-Barrett DC Christchurch CRI-2012-003-549, 11 July 2013.

2 At [25].

3      At [25] – [27].

URQUHART-BARRETT v ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION [2014] NZHC 1585 [8 July 2014]

Sentence

[3]      Ultimately Mr  Urquhart-Barrett  was  not  sentenced  by Judge  Farish  until

12 February 2014, when she imposed a sentence of seven months home detention with orders for payment of reparation and costs.4   In sentencing, Judge Farish took a starting point of 18 months imprisonment, for the obtaining by deception charge and another wilful omission charge that is unrelated to this appeal.5    That was uplifted modestly by three months for previous convictions,6  and then the total 21 month starting point was discounted by an averaged 15 percent credit across all offending for the early guilty plea in  relation  to  the unrelated  offending.7     This  took  the notional  sentence  down  to  18  months.8    Mr  Urquhart-Barrett’s  offer  to  pay reparation, and the fact he was already paying some, resulted in a further reduction down to 15 months imprisonment.9

[4]      This  notional  15  months  imprisonment  sentence  rendered  Mr  Urquhart- Barrett within a range permitting home detention to be considered as a sentencing option.10 On this basis, Mr Urquhart-Barrett was finally sentenced as noted above to

home detention of seven months and additionally he was ordered to pay:11

(a)      $12,030.39 reparation in relation to the unrelated offending.  This is not the subject of consideration on this appeal.

(b)$4,031.21 reparation in relation to the obtaining by deception charge, to be paid at the rate of $30 per week.   I note that weekly compensation, calculated to be around $26,956.12, was not sought by ACC as part of the reparation figure.

(c)       $2,070 in fees to Dr du Plessis, an expert medical witness in the

District Court proceeding, to be added to the reparation order.

4      ACC v Urquhart-Barrett DC Christchurch CRI-2012-003-549, 12 February 2014.

5      At [17] – [18].

6 At [19].

7 At [20].

8 At [20].

9 At [21].

10 At [22].

11     At [23] – [26].

(d)      $960  towards  ACC’s  costs  in  bringing  the  proceeding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Urquhart-Barrett v Accident Compensation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1585
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Leslie Wayne Urquhart-Barrett has appealed against his conviction by the District Court for obtaining a pecuniary advantage by deception in contravention of section 240 of the Crimes Act 1961 and, if that appeal is unsuccessful, against the sentence imposed on him by Judge Farish. The appeal against sentence also challenges the order that Urquhart-Barrett pay $2,070 in fees to Dr du Plessis, an expert medical witness, as part of the total reparation bill. The appeal against conviction raises issues of error of law and fact, while the appeal against sentence focuses on the proportionality of the reparation order. The court found that Urquhart-Barrett had malingered to obtain a pecuniary advantage through deceptive means, and there was no error in the District Court's decision. The appeal against sentence was also dismissed, but the contribution to Dr du Plessis' professional fee is to be determined and confirmed by the Registrar in accordance with the relevant regulations.

The court held that Urquhart-Barrett's appeal against conviction fails and is dismissed. The court found that the evidence was incontrovertible that Urquhart-Barrett was a malingerer, and he had obtained a pecuniary advantage through deceptive means. The court also held that the appeal against sentence was dismissed, but the contribution to Dr du Plessis' professional fee is to be determined and confirmed by the Registrar in accordance with the relevant regulations. The final orders are that the appeal against conviction is dismissed and the appeal against sentence is dismissed subject to the determination and confirmation of the contribution to Dr du Plessis' professional fee by the Registrar.