Urquhart-Barrett v Accident Compensation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CRI-2014-409-000020 [2014] NZHC 2030

BETWEEN

LESLIE WAYNE URQUHART-

BARRETT Appellant

AND

ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION

Respondent

Hearing:

3 July 2014

Further submissions received 18 July 2014 and 5 August 2014

Appearances:

R J Burnside for Appellant
K B Bell for Respondent

Judgment:

26 August 2014

JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J (Costs Decision - Dealt With on the Papers

[1]      On 8 July 2014 I delivered a judgment in this proceeding dismissing the appeal of Mr Urquhart-Barrett against conviction and sentence.1    However, in that judgment there remained an issue as to the extent to which Mr Urquhart-Barrett should  be  made  to  contribute  to  the  cost  of  an  expert  witness  in  the  appeal proceeding, Dr du Plessis.2   This issue arose due to an apparent discrepancy between the costs claimed by the Crown and the costs that ought to have been awarded pursuant to the Costs in Criminal Cases Regulations 1987 and the Witnesses and Interpreters Fees Regulations 1974.  This issue had not been signalled by either party nor the Judge in the District Court until raised on appeal.

[2]      In the 8 July 2014 decision I directed that Mr Urquhart-Barrett was still to

contribute to the costs of Dr du Plessis’ professional fee, adjusted only to comply

1      Urquhart-Barrett v ACC [2014] NZHC 1585.

2      At [30] – [32].

with the regulations.3   The Registrar was directed to set Dr du Plessis’ professional

fee   after   counsel   sequentially   filed   memoranda   within   20   working   days.4

Memoranda from counsel have now been  filed.   However, instead of confining submissions to the quantification point, it appears that Ms Burnside for Mr Urquhart- Barrett has sought to raise a further issue.  Namely, that because Mr Urquhart-Barrett was legally aided, she contended that no award of costs whatsoever should be made against him.  This argument was premised on the fact that ss 45 and 46 of the Legal Services Act 2011 apply by analogy and upon a concession said to have been made by  the  Crown  that  no  “exceptional  circumstances”  exist  in  the  present  case. Ms Burnside stated also:

If this position is not acceptable to the Court, then we seek leave of the Court to  have  the Appeal  reconvened  or  file  a  separate  application  after  final judgment.

[3]      On these aspects, first one matter needs to be made plain.   In my earlier judgment,  I reserved  the  position  in  respect  of  this  appeal  solely in  respect  of quantification of Dr du Plessis’s professional fee and not otherwise.   Prior to her memorandum being filed, as I understand the position, Ms Burnside had at no point signalled: (a) that Mr Urquhart-Barrett was legally aided; or (b) that this should in any way impact on the adverse costs award.  And her memorandum did not address the specific issue of quantification of the fees of the expert witness to be awarded.

[4]      As to Ms Burnside’s argument that Mr Urquhart-Barrett’s status as being a recipient of legal aid should militate against this Court making an adverse…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Urquhart-Barrett v Accident Compensation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2030
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand addressed the case of Urquhart-Barrett v Accident Compensation Corporation. Leslie Wayne Urquhart-Barrett, the appellant, was contesting the costs associated with an expert witness, Dr. du Plessis, in his appeal against a conviction and sentence. The dispute centred on the discrepancy between the costs claimed by the Crown and the costs that should have been awarded under relevant regulations. This issue was raised during the appeal and was not initially identified by either party or the Judge in the District Court.

The legal issues before the court involved the applicability of the Legal Services Act 2011 to the appellant's status as a recipient of legal aid in a criminal proceeding, and whether this should prevent the court from making an adverse costs award against him. The court examined whether sections 45 and 46 of the Legal Services Act 2011, which apply to legally aided persons in civil proceedings, could be analogised to this criminal case. The court also considered the implications of the Costs in Criminal Cases Act 1967 and the related regulations, which provide a specific codified regime for dealing with costs in criminal cases.

The court concluded that sections 45 and 46 of the Legal Services Act 2011 do not apply to criminal proceedings and are overridden by the codified regime established by the Costs in Criminal Cases Act 1967 and its regulations. The court rejected the argument that exceptional circumstances should prevent the imposition of costs, as the issue pertained to the quantification of costs in compliance with the regulations. The court further held that the argument should have been raised during the appeal and not post-appeal, and that revisiting the substantive decision was not warranted. Consequently, the court fixed the quantum of Dr. du Plessis's professional fee to be paid by Urquhart-Barrett at $1,388.

The final orders of the court were to accept the Crown's submissions on the quantification of Dr. du Plessis's professional fee and to direct that Urquhart-Barrett pay $1,388 to cover these costs. The court emphasised the importance of finality in resolving proceedings and providing certainty.