Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation v Dotcom

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-001272 [2014] NZHC 2175

BETWEEN

TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX FILM

CORPORATION, DISNEY ENTERPRISES INC, PARAMOUNT PICTURES CORPORATION, UNIVERSAL CITY STUDIOS PRODUCTIONS LLLP and WARNER BROS ENTERTAINMENT INC Applicants

AND

KIM DOTCOM First Respondent

BRAM VAN DER KOLK Second Respondent

RSV HOLDINGS LIMITED (FORMERLY KNOWN AS MEGASTUFF LIMITED) Third Respondent

Hearing: Submissions filed 20 August 2014

Judgment:

9 September 2014

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 9 September 2014 at 4.30 pm

pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar / Deputyr Registrar

Date………………………….

TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX FILM CORPORATION v DOTCOM & ORS [2014] NZHC 2175 [9 September

2014]

[1]      This proceeding started life as an originating application by the plaintiffs for a freezing order restraining Mr Dotcom from dealing with or disposing of assets, and ancillary orders.  The proceedings were commenced to protect the plaintiffs against the possible expiry of criminal restraining orders.1   Pending the determination of that situation the plaintiffs brought an urgent application for an ancillary order requiring immediate  and  full  disclosure  of  Mr  Dotcom’s  financial  position  in  light  of

statements by him suggesting that he had access to substantial funds that were not subject to the criminal restraining orders.   In my decision dated 30 July 2014 I granted the plaintiffs’ application and made an order requiring Mr Dotcom to make full disclosure of his assets by 20 August 2014.2    I subsequently refused a stay of execution  of that  decision  but  varied  the order  so  that  the  extent  of  disclosure required would initially be limited to counsel.

[2]      The plaintiffs have applied for costs on a 3B basis.  Mr Dotcom resists costs being determined at this stage and does not accept that the proceeding meets the criteria for category 3.   Further, he submits that the claim for expert witness fees should be deferred.

Categorisation

[3]      Because of the urgency with which this matter came before the Court there has been no allocation of a category for the purposes of costs.

[4]      Mr Sumpter, for the plaintiffs, seeks to have costs fixed in relation to the ancillary order application on a 3B basis because of its urgency, novelty and complexity.  It is true that the matter fell to be determined under circumstances of considerable urgency.   The matter was first listed before Faire J on 29 May 2014. A timetable was put in place that required all evidence to be filed and served by 17 July

2014 and submissions by 21 July 2014. The matter was then argued before me on 22

July 2014.

[5]      It is also true that the application is of a kind infrequently made in New

Zealand courts.  Only rarely has relief been sought under Part 32 of the High Court

1      That risk has since been allayed by the Court of Appeal’s extension of the restraining orders for a further year: Commissioner of Police v Dotcom [2014] NZCA 408.

2      Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation & Ors v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation v Dotcom and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter, the plaintiffs, including Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation, Disney Enterprises Inc, Paramount Pictures Corporation, Universal City Studios Productions LLLP, and Warner Bros Entertainment Inc, sought an ancillary order requiring Kim Dotcom to disclose his financial position. This application was brought due to statements made by Dotcom suggesting he had access to substantial funds not subject to criminal restraining orders. Justice Courtney granted the application and ordered Dotcom to make full disclosure of his assets by 20 August 2014. However, Dotcom opposed the fixing of costs at that stage and did not accept that the proceedings met the criteria for category 3 costs. He also argued that the claim for expert witness fees should be deferred.

The plaintiffs sought costs on a 3B basis, arguing that the urgency, novelty, and complexity of the application warranted such an allocation. The court found that the matter was indeed urgent, as it was first listed on 29 May 2014, with a tight timetable requiring all evidence to be filed and served by 17 July 2014, and submissions by 21 July 2014. The matter was then argued before Justice Courtney on 22 July 2014. The application was of a kind infrequently made in New Zealand courts, and complex issues arose regarding the available evidence and relevant case law.

However, the court was not satisfied that the proceedings were of such complexity or significance as to be viewed as category 3. The complexity of this particular application was better assessed under band C. The plaintiffs also sought reimbursement of the costs of obtaining expert evidence from Mr Rotstein, a US attorney who gave evidence on US copyright law. The plaintiffs claimed US$15,901.80 and US$17,347.05 for the preparation of an affidavit and reply evidence. Dotcom argued that the claim was unreasonable, as the actual fee was US$66,497.70. The court found that it could not determine the reasonableness of Mr Rotstein’s fee on the information before it and reserved leave for the plaintiffs to file a further memorandum on this issue within 14 days.

There were to be costs to the plaintiffs on the application for the ancillary order and application for execution on a 2C basis. Counsel were to confer as to the calculation of those costs, and leave was reserved to seek further directions if agreement could not be reached. Disbursements of $540 for the filing fee were allowed. If the plaintiffs wished to pursue a claim for Mr Rotstein’s fee, they would need to file a further memorandum and possible affidavit addressing the issue of reasonableness raised by Dotcom.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established