Thode v Turners and Growers Horticulture Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2015-404-1300

[2018] NZHC 890

BETWEEN

ROBERT WILLIAM THODE and

OLESEN TRUSTEES (2011) LIMITED
as trustees of the Robert Thode Family Trust Plaintiffs

AND

TURNERS AND GROWERS HORTICULTURE LIMITED

First Defendant

ENZA FRUIT NEW ZEALAND INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
Second Defendant

T&G GLOBAL LIMITED

Third Defendant

Hearing: 13 April 2018

Appearances:

M N Dunning QC and R M Dixon for the Plaintiffs W M Irving and A J McLeod for the Defendants

Judgment:

1 May 2018


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL


This judgment was delivered by me on 1 May 2018 at 3:30 pm

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

…………………………………

Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Meredith Connell, Auckland, for the Plaintiffs Russell McVeagh, Auckland, for the Defendants Counsel:

M N Dunning QC, Auckland, for the Plaintiffs

THODE and v TURNERS AND GROWERS HORTICULTURE LIMITED [2018] NZHC 890 [1 May 2018]

[1]    The plaintiffs’ application under r 8.19 of the High Court Rules 2016 for further discovery is to be heard on 5 June 2018. Ahead of that hearing, they have applied for an order under r 9.75:

9.75     Person refusing to make affidavit

(1)        If a person having information relevant to a proceeding or an interlocutory application refuses to make an affidavit as to that information, a party may apply for an order directing the person to appear and be examined on oath before the court, or any person the court appoints, as to that information.

(2)The court may—

(a)make any orders the court thinks just for the attendance of that person before the court, or before the person named in the order, for the purpose of being examined, and for the production of any documents specified in the order; and

(b)impose any terms the court thinks just, as to the examination and the costs of and incidental to the application and examination.

[2]They seek these orders:

(a)a declaration that Murray Robert Malone make an affidavit giving the court all relevant information in his possession;

(b)that the plaintiff may liaise with Mr Malone for that purpose;

(c)any confidential information disclosed by Mr Malone as a result be held on the same terms as the existing undertakings as to confidentiality given by the plaintiffs, and the plaintiffs’ intended witnesses, to the defendants in February and March 2018;

(d)Mr Malone’s affidavit be provided to the defendants 14 working days before it is filed for them to assess whether any issue as to admissibility arises (whether a to privilege, confidentiality, relevance or otherwise); or

(e)in the alternative to the orders sought above, that Mr Malone appear and be examined on oath before the court at the hearing of the interlocutory application on notice by the plaintiffs for particular discovery set down for 5 June.

[3]    The plaintiffs are kiwifruit orchardists in the Bay of Plenty. The first and second defendants are subsidiaries of T & G Global Ltd. Turners & Growers Horticulture Ltd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thode v Turners and Growers Horticulture Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 890
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, kiwifruit orchardists, sought an order under rule 9.75 of the High Court Rules to compel a former director of the defendants to make an affidavit about the location of documents they believed the defendants had not disclosed during discovery. They also sought an order that the deponent appear in person for examination if he refused to make an affidavit. The defendants opposed the application. The court found that the plaintiffs had no basis to make an order under rule 9.75 because the deponent had already sworn an affidavit. In any event, the application for an order under rule 9.75 was not required. The discovery application was a standard one and had no unusual features. The plaintiffs were concerned the defendants had not made proper discovery, but they would likely contend that there were grounds for believing that the defendants had not discovered documents that should have been disclosed. The defendants, on the other hand, made the usual submission as to having made a reasonable search for documents under rule 8.14. At the hearing, the judge would likely apply the four-step approach set by Asher J in Assa Abloy New Zealand Ltd v Allegion (NZ) Ltd. Typically, the court would have regard to affidavit evidence, pleadings and the circumstances of the case to establish whether there were grounds to believe that a party had not discovered documents that should have been disclosed. In run-of-the-mill cases, deponents were not required for cross-examination. The court would only order that a deponent attend court for cross-examination under rule 7.28 if special circumstances were established. There were no circumstances here to suggest that the deponent should be cross-examined on his affidavit. That counted against making an equivalent order under rule 9.75. In the absence of any red flags indicating that something was amiss, warranting a more intensive approach, it was disproportionate for the plaintiffs to look to a former employee and director—who had not been connected with the business for six years— to give information about documents held by the companies with which he had had no recent connection. The case did not call for that over-the-top treatment. The court dismissed the application for an order under rule 9.75. The defendants were entitled to costs on the application.

The court ordered that the defendants were entitled to costs on the application. The plaintiffs were to pay one counsel only. The court expected counsel to agree as to costs but, if they could not, memoranda could be filed.