The North Face Apparel Corp v Sanyang Industry Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA638/2012
[2014] NZCA 398

BETWEEN

THE NORTH FACE APPAREL CORPORATION
Appellant

AND

SANYANG INDUSTRY COMPANY LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

15 April 2014

Court:

Randerson, Harrison and French JJ

Counsel:

G Arthur and L C Carter for Appellant
M C Warburton and C A Warburton for Respondent

Judgment:

15 August 2014 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A    The appeal is dismissed. 

BThe cross-appeal is dismissed.

CThe appellant is ordered to pay 50 per cent of the respondent’s costs on a Band A basis for a standard appeal together with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

Introduction

  1. Sanyang Industry Co Ltd (Sanyang) applied to the Intellectual Property Office to register a trade mark for four different classes of goods.[1]  The North Face Apparel Corp (North Face) opposed the application for registration for one class only on the ground that Sanyang was not the owner of its proposed mark.  Following a defended hearing, an Assistant Commissioner of Trade Marks granted Sanyang’s application.[2] 

    [1]Trade Marks Act 2002, s 32(1).

    [2]Sanyang Industry Co Ltd v The North Face Apparel Corp [2012] NZIPOTM 3 [IPONZ decision].

  2. Collins J dismissed North Face’s appeal from the Assistant Commissioner’s decision.[3]  He was satisfied that Sanyang owned the mark.  North Face now appeals to this Court.  Sanyang cross-appeals against the Judge’s threshold finding that North Face has used one of its unregistered marks for some items within the contested class before Sanyang applied for registration. 

Background

  1. The background facts can be stated shortly.

  2. Sanyang is a Taiwanese company which manufactures a wide range of products including cars, motorbikes and parts and accessories.  Recently it has added clothing and other apparel to its range of goods. 

  3. As Collins J observed:

    [13]      Sanyang ha[s] explained that its original trade mark was a stylised moving arrow incorporated into the letter “Y” of its SYN trade mark.  The arrow was adopted to indicate forward movement of its motor cycles and motor vehicles.  In 2006 Sanyang developed its trade mark which it describes as being a stylised arrow.  Sanyang says that its trade mark is simply a modernised version of the trade mark it used from 1954 to 2006.

  4. Sanyang applied to register its mark under classes 7, 16, 25 and 35 of the Ninth Edition of the International Trade Mark Classification System adopted as part of the Nice Agreement.  North Face’s opposition to registration was restricted to class 25 only, which covers:

    Clothing; swimsuits; shirts; beachwear; vests; tee-shirts; coveralls; coats; liveries; footwear; scarves; neckties; headwear; earmuffs; socks; mittens; waistbands; all included in this class. 

  5. Sanyang’s device mark, which the Assistant Commissioner accepted for registration, is as follows:

  1. North Face is a well-established company operating from California.  It produces and sells worldwide clothing and equipment used by mountaineers, trampers, snow sport participants and travellers.  It has developed a number of trade marks for products.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The North Face Apparel Corp v Sanyang Industry Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 398
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The North Face Apparel Corp (North Face) appealed against a decision of Collins J which dismissed its appeal against the decision of an Assistant Commissioner of Trade Marks that Sanyang Industry Co Ltd (Sanyang) was the owner of a trade mark for class 25 goods and that it should be registered. Sanyang cross-appealed against the Judge’s threshold finding that North Face had used one of its unregistered marks for some items within the contested class before Sanyang applied for registration. The Court of Appeal dismissed both the appeal and cross-appeal and ordered North Face to pay 50 per cent of Sanyang’s costs on a Band A basis for a standard appeal together with usual disbursements.

Sanyang applied to the Intellectual Property Office to register a trade mark for four different classes of goods. North Face opposed the application for registration for one class only on the ground that Sanyang was not the owner of its proposed mark. Following a defended hearing, an Assistant Commissioner of Trade Marks granted Sanyang’s application. Collins J dismissed North Face’s appeal from the Assistant Commissioner’s decision. He was satisfied that Sanyang owned the mark. North Face now appeals to the Court of Appeal. Sanyang cross-appeals against the Judge’s threshold finding that North Face had used one of its unregistered marks for some items within the contested class before Sanyang applied for registration.

Two related issues arise on North Face’s appeal and Sanyang’s cross-appeal. First, what was the nature and extent of North Face’s use of its composite and S device marks in New Zealand before 22 January 2008? Second, depending in part on the answer to the first, did North Face own Sanyang’s proposed mark?

The Court of Appeal found that North Face had established ownership by prior use of its S device mark for gloves and mittens prior to the date of Sanyang’s application for registration of its proposed mark. The Court of Appeal also found that North Face’s ownership of its S device mark for gloves and mittens did not extend to ownership of the same mark for other items of apparel within class 25. North Face’s ownership of its composite mark for other items of apparel was not divisible and the S device mark did not operate as a separate component. In the absence of proof that its S device mark was identical to Sanyang’s proposed mark, North Face could not oppose Sanyang’s claim to ownership of its mark. Even if a test of substantial identity was nevertheless arguable, North Face’s S device and Sanyang’s proposed mark were not substantially identical. The Assistant Commissioner, upheld by Collins J, was correct to grant Sanyang’s application for ownership of its proposed mark.

The appeal and cross-appeal are dismissed. In substance Sanyang has succeeded. However, the Court of Appeal’s finding that North Face used one of its trade marks on some items means Sanyang’s cross-appeal has failed. It is appropriate in these circumstances to award Sanyang a reduced figure for costs. North Face is ordered to pay 50 per cent of Sanyang’s costs on a Band A basis for a standard appeal together with usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established