International Consoidated Business Pty Ltd v S C Johnson & Son Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA72/2018
 [2019] NZCA 61

BETWEEN

INTERNATIONAL CONSOLIDATED BUSINESS PTY LTD
Appellant

AND

S C JOHNSON & SON INC
Respondent

Hearing:

23 August 2018

Court:

Kós P, French and Brown JJ

Counsel:

G C Williams and L E Mannis for Appellant
G F Arthur and L Carter for Respondent

Judgment:

19 March 2019 at 4.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal against the order quashing the Assistant Commissioner’s finding that ICB is the owner of the ZIPLOC trade mark is dismissed.

BThe direction that the proceeding be referred back to the Assistant Commissioner for a new hearing of the issues at [159] of the High Court judgment is quashed.

C        Trade mark application 975954 for ZIPLOC is to proceed to registration.

DThe appellant must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1]
Obtaining and removing registered trade marks  [7]

Applying for registration  [8]
Revocation of registration of trade mark   [13]

Relevant background  [19]
The Assistant Commissioner’s decision  [23]
The High Court judgment  [26]
Issues on appeal  [34]
Did the High Court err in treating 19 April 2013 as the effective
revocation date of RTM 648953?  [36]
Was the presence on the register of ICB’s RTM 648953 on
19 April 2013 a bar to Johnson’s application for registration?           [46]

The position prior to 2002   [49]
Section 68(2)   [55]
The legislative history  [62]
The implications of s 66(3) and (4)   [69]
The technique for backdating the effective date of removal                 [79]
Conclusion   [83]

Does first use of a trade mark determine ownership in perpetuity
or can an initial entitlement to ownership be lost through
cessation of use?  [86]
Was a reference back of the ownership question erroneous?              [92]
Result  [96]
Costs  [99]

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Brown J)

Introduction

  1. Both the appellant, International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd (ICB) and the respondent, S C Johnson & Son Inc (Johnson) aspire to be the registered owner in New Zealand of the trade mark ZIPLOC in class 16.[1] 

    [1]Of the Nice Classification system (the tenth edition then applied).

  2. On 26 June 2014 ICB’s previous registered trade mark (RTM) number 648953 for ZIPLOC was removed from the trade mark register with effect from the date of Johnson’s application for removal of 22 April 2013.  ICB filed a further application for registration of ZIPLOC under application number 1005952 on 26 September 2014.

  3. On 19 April 2013, three days prior to its application for removal of ICB’s RTM 648953, Johnson filed its own application to register ZIPLOC under application number 975954.  Being first in time Johnson’s application had priority over ICB’s further application.

  4. ICB’s opposition to Johnson’s application was upheld by the Assistant Commissioner of Trade Marks on two grounds:[2]

    (a)On the date of Johnson’s application, 19 April 2013, ICB was the owner of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read International Consoidated Business Pty Ltd v S C Johnson & S... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZCA 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd (ICB) appealed against a decision of the Trade Marks Registry which found that ICB was not entitled to registration of the ZIPLOC trade mark in respect of plastic bags and plastic film for wrapping purposes in class 16. S C Johnson & Son, Inc (Johnson) opposed ICB’s application on the grounds that ICB was not the owner of the trade mark and that registration would be contrary to the Fair Trading Act 1986. ICB’s application was held in abeyance as Johnson’s application, filed earlier, had priority. ICB argued that the registration should take effect from 22 November 2001, the date of application, or from 7 December 2001, the date of the revocation of the earlier registrations. The primary issue for the court was whether the Trade Marks Act 2002 applied the date of the application for revocation as the effective date of revocation, as opposed to the date when the order for revocation was made.

The court found that the relevant provision of the Act, s 68(2), operated to backdate the effective date of revocation to the date of the application for revocation. The court held that the revocation of the earlier registrations of the trade mark was effective from the date of the application for revocation, meaning that ICB’s application should take effect from the date of application. This was significant because it meant that the date of the application for revocation was the relevant date for determining priority of applications for registration. The court also found that ICB was not entitled to registration because it was not the owner of the trade mark and that registration would be contrary to the Fair Trading Act 1986.

The court found in favour of Johnson. ICB’s application for registration was dismissed and the order for revocation of Johnson’s registration was affirmed. ICB’s appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Of particular significance for the issues on this appeal is s 68(2) which backdates the effective date of revocation in similar fashion to applications for registration:68 Revocation of registration of trade mark(1)If grounds for revocation exist in respect of only some of the goods or services in respect of which the trade mark is registered, revocation relates only to those goods or services.(2)If the registration of a trade mark is revoked to any extent, the rights of the owner, to that extent, cease on—(a)the date of the application for revocation of the registration of the trade mark; or (b)if the Commissioner or the court is satisfied that the grounds for revocation of the registration of the trade mark existed at an earlier date, that date. Over the past 45 years there have been a number of registrations of the ZIPLOC trade mark in New Zealand. Consequent upon the acquisition of DowBrands in 1998, S C Johnson Home Storage Inc became the owner of RTM 109101 in class 16 for plastic film for wrapping purposes which was registered in 1974 and RTM 140148 in class 16 for plastic bags which was registered in 1981. In 1999 it obtained RTM 313887 in class 21 for plastic containers. On the application of ICB, RTM 109101 and RTM 140148 were removed from the register on the ground of non-use of the trade mark with effect from 7 December 2001. RTM 313887 was also removed from the register on ICB’s application on the ground of non-use as from 5 September 2005. On 8 June 2006 ICB obtained RTM 648953 for the ZIPLOC trade mark in class 16, the registration being deemed to take effect from the date of application on 22 November 2001.[16] On 22 April 2013 Johnson filed an application for revocation of RTM 648953 and an order for removal of that registration on the ground of non-use was made on 26 June 2014.[17] [16]The specification of goods was: bags in this class, including plastic bags; kitchen tidy bags and garbage bags; plastic bags for food storage, snacks and sandwiches; plastic freezer bags and plastic bags for medical products; clingwrap.[17]International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd v S C Johnson & Son, Inc [2014] NZIPOTM 27. On 26 September 2014 ICB filed a further application number 1005952 in class 16. ICB’s application was held in abeyance pending the processing of Johnson’s application number 975954 in class 16 which had priority having been filed earlier on 19 April 2013.[18] Johnson’s application was opposed by ICB on four grounds:(a)the application for registration was not made by a person who at the relevant date was the owner or proprietor of the mark;[19](b)use of the mark by Johnson on its goods would have been likely to deceive or cause confusion;[20](c)use of the mark by Johnson would be contrary to law because it would (i) amount to passing off at common law and/or (ii) be contrary to various provisions of the Fair Trading Act 1986. Use of the mark by Johnson would be disentitled to protection in any court;[21](d)the mark was identical to a trade mark which at the relevant date belonged to a different owner, namely ICB, registered in respect of the same goods.[22]