The Mall Upper Hutt Limited v Upper Hutt City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2023-485-271

[2025] NZHC 1878

BETWEEN

THE MALL UPPER HUTT LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

UPPER HUTT CITY COUNCIL

Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

J Long and G Barton for Plaintiff T Smith for Defendant

Judgment:

10 July 2025


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SKELTON

[Costs]


[1]         The parties have been unable to agree costs following the discontinuance of the plaintiff’s claim and the discontinuance of the defendant’s counterclaim. That is surprising because correspondence between the parties around the time that the claims were discontinued indicated there was a willingness to agree to the respective claims being discontinued with no issues as to costs.

[2]The defendant now seeks indemnity costs and disbursements in the sum of

$307,447.44 (GST exclusive). Alternatively, the defendant seeks increased scale costs calculated on a 2B and 2C basis with a 50 per cent uplift and disbursements (of

$6,661.74) in the total sum of $104,352.99.1   The plaintiff accepts that it should pay

the defendant’s 2B scale costs in the sum of $43,617.50 and disbursements in the sum of $6,661.74.


1      The 2C costs claimed relate to discovery only.

THE MALL UPPER HUTT LIMITED v UPPER HUTT CITY COUNCIL [2025] NZHC 1878 [10 July 2025]

[3]       Rule 15.23 of the High Court Rules 2016 is clear that, unless the defendant agrees otherwise or the Court otherwise orders, a plaintiff who discontinues a proceeding must pay costs to the defendant of and incidental to the proceeding up to the point of discontinuance. The presumption is designed to give a certain and predictable outcome. There is no implication that an award of increased or indemnity costs follows.2

[4]       The defendant contends that it is entitled to increased or indemnity costs because the plaintiff had a “hopeless case” which “patently lacked merit”. The defendant also contends that much of the plaintiff’s evidence addressed events irrelevant to the pleaded case which increased the burden on the defendant in responding. Counsel for the defendant suggests there is a “strong implication” that the plaintiff knew its case was fundamentally flawed and brought the proceedings with an ulterior motive. The defendant has filed a 191-page affidavit in support of its claim for costs, including selected excerpts from briefs of evidence served by the parties.

[5]       It is well established that increased or indemnity costs may only be awarded in a case which has been discontinued before or during trial where the lack of merit is “utterly clear” and “both obvious and incontrovertible”.3 The Court will not engage in speculation as to the merits, nor consider briefs of evidence that would have been called if the matter had proceeded to trial. To do so would defeat the whole purpose of discontinuance, which is to provide a quick and inexpensive end to the proceedings.4

[6]       Having reviewed the memoranda filed by counsel for the parties and the affidavit filed by the defendant, I am not satisfied that it is “utterly clear”…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Mall Upper Hutt Limited v Upper Hutt City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 1878
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Mall Upper Hutt Limited, a plaintiff, sought a resolution against the Upper Hutt City Council, the defendant, in a matter that was eventually discontinued. The primary focus of the dispute was the disagreement over the costs incurred following the discontinuance of the plaintiff’s claim and the defendant’s counterclaim. The High Court of New Zealand, Wellington Registry, was tasked with determining the costs to be borne by each party. The defendant sought indemnity costs and disbursements amounting to $307,447.44, or alternatively, increased scale costs calculated on a 2B and 2C basis with a 50 per cent uplift, plus disbursements totaling $104,352.99. In contrast, the plaintiff acknowledged the need to pay the defendant's 2B scale costs of $43,617.50 and disbursements of $6,661.74.

The court addressed the legal issues surrounding the applicability of Rule 15.23 of the High Court Rules 2016, which mandates that a plaintiff who discontinues a proceeding must pay costs to the defendant unless otherwise agreed or ordered by the court. The defendant argued that increased or indemnity costs were justified due to the plaintiff's case being fundamentally flawed and lacking merit. However, the court held that awarding increased or indemnity costs requires the case to be utterly clear and incontrovertible in its lack of merit, a standard not met in this instance. The court declined to speculate on the merits of the case or consider untested evidence excerpts, emphasizing the purpose of discontinuance as a quick and inexpensive resolution. Additionally, the court found that the scale of the discovery exercise, while extensive, did not warrant the higher 2C costs claimed by the defendant.

In conclusion, the court determined that the defendant was entitled to costs amounting to $54,372.50 and disbursements of $6,661.74. This decision was based on the plaintiff's acceptance of 2B scale costs and reasonable disbursements, while the court rejected the higher 2C scale costs for discovery, considering the scale of the discovery exercise. The final order thus reflected the court's assessment of the appropriate costs to be borne by the parties following the discontinuance of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.