The Canyon Vineyard Ltd v Central Otago District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA583/2022
 [2023] NZCA 74

BETWEEN

THE CANYON VINEYARD LTD
Applicant

AND

CENTRAL OTAGO DISTRICT COUNCIL
First Respondent

BENDIGO STATION LTD
Second Respondent

Court:

French and Mallon JJ

Counsel:

L A Andersen KC and A V J Hamel for Applicant
D J Anderson for First Respondent
P J Page and S R Peirce for Second Respondent

Judgment:
(On the papers)

23 March 2023 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to appeal is declined.

BThe applicant must pay the respondents’ costs for a standard application on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Mallon J)

Introduction

  1. Bendigo Station Limited (Bendigo) owns a vast farming property in Central Otago that takes in much of Bendigo Terrace and parts of the western foothills of the Dunstan Mountain range.  It sought resource consent to subdivide just over 163 hectares of its property.  The site of the proposed subdivision consists of a scrub filled gully interspersed with open areas that are covered in scab weed and rough pasture.  The site is currently used for low intensity dryland grazing. 

  2. The application for consent considered by the Central Otago District Council (the Council) involved the creation of 14 lots of which 12 would have consent for residential building platforms.[1]  The remaining two lots, Lots 1 and 3, contain existing vineyards and were to be retained as such.  The Council granted consent to the creation of 12 lots with consents for residential building platforms on eight of them (Lots 2, 4 to 6, and 8 to 11).  It declined the proposal for dwellings on Lots 7 and 12 because it considered dwellings on those two lots would have significant adverse effects.

    [1]The application considered by the Council was an amended application from that initially lodged.

  3. The Canyon Vineyard Limited (Canyon) opposed Bendigo’s application to the Council.  It owns land to the west of Bendigo’s land separated by a gully.  It contains a restaurant, wine tasting facility, a function centre, and cinema building (collectively referred to as the Function Centre).  A vineyard is on adjacent land.  From Canyon’s Function Centre, there are expansive views to the north/north-west over Bendigo Terrace, and the valley of the Clutha River/Mata-Au as it enters Lake Dunstan.  There is a direct line of sight from parts of the Function Centre site toward that part of the Bendigo land that is to contain proposed Lots 8 to 11. 

  4. Canyon appealed the Council’s decision to the Environment Court.  The Environment Court upheld the Council’s decision but in relation to a slightly amended proposal (the Interim decision).[2]  A subsequent decision of the Environment Court approved the amended conditions (the Final decision).[3]  Canyon’s appeal of both the Interim and Final decisions was dismissed by Doogue J in the High Court.[4]  Canyon now seeks leave to appeal to this Court on three questions of law.[5]  Bendigo opposes the leave application.

Leave jurisdiction

[2]The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Canyon Vineyard Ltd v Central Otago District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZCA 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In The Canyon Vineyard Ltd v Central Otago District Council, the Court of Appeal of New Zealand addressed an appeal concerning the granting of resource consent for a proposed subdivision by Bendigo Station Limited. Canyon Vineyard Limited opposed the application, arguing that it would adversely affect their property. The Environment Court initially upheld the consent, and this decision was affirmed by the High Court. Canyon now sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal on three questions of law. The central issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the Environment Court and High Court correctly interpreted the meaning of "kaitiakitanga," "maintain," and "contrary to" in the context of the Resource Management Act 1991 and the Central Otago District Council Plan.

The Court of Appeal found that the first question regarding the interpretation of "kaitiakitanga" did not involve an error of law. The Court held that the Environment Court and High Court appropriately considered the individual's evidence but ultimately rejected it because it conflicted with other evidence and did not demonstrate a material error in the outcome. The second question concerned the interpretation of "maintain" and "contrary to" in the context of the Plan's objective to maintain rural amenity values. The Court concluded that the Environment Court and High Court correctly applied the relevant provisions and that Canyon's interpretation of these terms misconstrued the Plan's objectives and policies. Finally, the third question related to the Environment Court's jurisdiction to amend the plan after the dismissal of Canyon's appeal. The Court held that the omission of a mound on Lot 8 was an accidental error and could be corrected by the Environment Court.

Ultimately, the Court of Appeal declined the application for leave to appeal and ordered Canyon Vineyard to pay the respondents' costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bendigo Station Limited owns a large farming property in Central Otago and sought resource consent to subdivide 163 hectares of its land into 14 lots. Twelve of these lots were proposed for residential building platforms, while lots 1 and 3, containing existing vineyards, were to be retained as vineyards. The Canyon Vineyard Limited, which owns land adjacent to the west of Bendigo's land, opposed the application due to potential adverse effects on its scenic views and rural amenity. The Central Otago District Council granted consent for the creation of 12 lots, with residential building consents on eight of them, declining the proposal for dwellings on Lots 7 and 12 due to significant adverse effects. Canyon appealed the Council's decision to the Environment Court, which upheld the Council's decision with slightly amended conditions. Canyon's subsequent appeal to the High Court was dismissed, and it now seeks leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal on three questions of law.

The matter originated in the Environment Court, where Canyon Station Limited opposed Bendigo Station Limited's application for resource consent to subdivide its land. The Environment Court initially considered the application and issued an interim decision upholding the Council's decision with certain amendments. A subsequent decision by the Environment Court approved amended conditions. Canyon appealed both the interim and final decisions to the High Court, which dismissed the appeal. Canyon now seeks leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal on three questions of law.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does kaitiakitanga for the purposes of s 7(a) of the Resource Management Act include an individual's relationship with particular land or is it limited to more general evidence by rūnanga?
2. Did the High Court correctly assess effects by applying the correct test to the words "maintain the rural environment" in Objective 4.3.3 of the Central Otago District Council Plan:
(a) By holding it did not require avoidance of effects that breached the specified values; and
(b) By holding that "contrary to" means "opposed in nature, different to or opposite... repugnant and antagonistic"?
3. Does the Environment Court have jurisdiction to amend the plan that forms part of its final decision after the Canyon appeal is dismissed?

Held
1. The Court held that the question of whether kaitiakitanga for the purposes of s 7(a) of the Resource Management Act includes an individual's relationship with particular land or is limited to more general evidence by rūnanga does not give rise to an error of law. The Court found that the High Court's reasoning in this regard was not erroneous.
2. The Court held that the High Court did not misapply the test for assessing whether the proposed subdivision maintained the rural environment as required by Objective 4.3.3 of the Central Otago District Council Plan. The Court found that the High Court correctly interpreted the meaning of "maintain" and "contrary to" in the context of the Plan's objectives and policies.
3. The Court held that the Environment Court has jurisdiction to amend the plan that forms part of its final decision after the Canyon appeal is dismissed, as the omission of the mound on Lot 8 was an accidental error that can be corrected.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court declined the application for leave to appeal, finding that the proposed questions of law did not meet the criteria for leave. Regarding the first proposed question, the Court held that the High Court's consideration of the individual's evidence in the context of kaitiakitanga was not an error of law. The Court found that the High Court's reasoning in this regard was not erroneous and did not give rise to a miscarriage of justice. In relation to the second proposed question, the Court found that the High Court correctly interpreted the meaning of "maintain" and "contrary to" in the context of the Plan's objectives and policies. The Court held that the High Court's approach was consistent with the Plan's objectives and policies, and there was no misapplication of the test for assessing the proposed subdivision's impact on the rural environment. Lastly, the Court held that the Environment Court has jurisdiction to amend the plan that forms part of its final decision after the Canyon appeal is dismissed, as the omission of the mound on Lot 8 was an accidental error that can be corrected. The Court found that the Environment Court's Interim decision was based on the intention to reinstate the mound, and the Final decision's failure to include the mound was an accidental error that can be rectified by the Environment Court.