Canyon Vineyard Limited v Central Otago District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI O AOTEAROA

 SC 46/2023
 [2023] NZSC 108
BETWEEN

THE CANYON VINEYARD LIMITED
Applicant

AND

CENTRAL OTAGO DISTRICT COUNCIL
First Respondent

BENDIGO STATION LIMITED
Second Respondent
Court:

Glazebrook, O’Regan and Ellen France JJ

Counsel:

L A Andersen KC for Applicant
D J Anderson for First Respondent
P J Page and S R Peirce for Second Respondent

Judgment:

17 August 2023

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application for an extension of time to apply for leave to appeal is dismissed. 

B         The applicant must pay both the respondents costs of $2,500. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Introduction

  1. Bendigo Station Ltd (Bendigo) owns a large farming property in Central Otago.  It sought resource consent to subdivide an area of its land.  The Canyon Vineyard Ltd (Canyon) owns land to the west of Bendigo’s land where it operates, among other things, a vineyard, restaurant and function centre.  It opposed Bendigo’s application for the subdivision consent. 

  2. The Central Otago District Council (the Council) granted consent to the creation of 12 lots, with consents for residential building platforms on eight of them.  Canyon appealed against that decision to the Environment Court.  That Court upheld the Council’s decision but for a slightly amended proposal.[1]  Canyon’s appeal to the High Court against the Environment Court’s decision was dismissed.[2]

    [1]The interim decision granted the resource consents: The Canyon Vineyard Ltd v Central Otago District Council [2021] NZEnvC 136 (Judge Steven and Commissioner Mabin) [Preliminary EnvC judgment]. The subsequent decision was in response to a direction to the parties to confer on the amended conditions of the subdivisions: The Canyon Vineyard Ltd v Central Otago District Council [2021] NZEnvC 187 (Judge Steven and Commissioner Mabin).

  3. Canyon’s application for leave to appeal against the High Court decision was declined by the Court of Appeal on 23 March 2023.[3]  Canyon now seeks leave to appeal directly to this Court against the High Court decision.

  4. Canyon’s grounds of appeal are broadly similar to those raised in the Courts below, although now narrowed to two alleged errors of law:

    (a)the alleged failure by the Environment Court to consider evidence on kaitiakitanga presented by Mr Johnston, the sole director and shareholder of Canyon; and

    (b)an alleged error by the Environment Court and the High Court in their assessments of effects in light of Objective 4.3.3 of the Central Otago District Council Plan (the Plan) to “maintain and where practical enhance rural amenity values”.  

Jurisdiction

  1. The Council submits that this Court has no jurisdiction to entertain this application.  That is because appeals of High Court decisions under s 299 of the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA) are governed by Subpart 8 of Part 6 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 (CPA), with necessary modifications.[4]  Pursuant to ss 303 and 304…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Canyon Vineyard Limited v Central Otago District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZSC 108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Canyon Vineyard Limited sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of New Zealand against the High Court decision in Canyon Vineyard Limited v Central Otago District Council. The Central Otago District Council granted resource consents for a subdivision of land owned by Bendigo Station Limited, which was opposed by Canyon. The Environment Court upheld the Council’s decision, which was subsequently upheld by the High Court. Canyon’s application for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal was declined. Canyon now seeks leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against the High Court decision, raising issues about kaitiakitanga and the interpretation of the Council’s Plan.

The Court of Appeal had already considered and declined the application for leave to appeal on the basis that there were no exceptional circumstances justifying an appeal to the Supreme Court and that the application was out of time. Canyon argues that the Court of Appeal erred in its assessment of the evidence presented by Mr Johnston, the sole director and shareholder of Canyon, regarding kaitiakitanga and the interpretation of the Plan's objective to maintain and enhance rural amenity values. The Council contends that the Court of Appeal’s decision is binding and that there are no exceptional circumstances warranting an appeal to the Supreme Court.

The Court found that the Court of Appeal had properly considered the issues and that the evidence had been rejected for reasons that were explained and did not give rise to an error of law. The Court held that Canyon's application was out of time and that there were no exceptional circumstances justifying an appeal to the Supreme Court. The Court of Appeal's judgment was detailed and reasoned, and there was no risk of a miscarriage of justice. Therefore, Canyon's application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

The Court dismissed Canyon's application for an extension of time to apply for leave to appeal and ordered Canyon to pay both respondents' costs of $2,500.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bendigo Station Ltd (Bendigo) owns a large farming property in Central Otago and sought resource consent to subdivide an area of its land. Canyon Vineyard Ltd (Canyon) owns land to the west of Bendigo's land, where it operates a vineyard, restaurant, and function centre. Canyon opposed Bendigo's subdivision application. The Central Otago District Council (the Council) granted consent for the creation of 12 lots, with residential building platforms on eight of them. Canyon appealed the Council's decision to the Environment Court, which upheld the Council's decision but with slightly amended conditions. Canyon's subsequent appeal to the High Court against the Environment Court's decision was dismissed. Canyon's application for leave to appeal against the High Court decision was declined by the Court of Appeal. Canyon now seeks leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court against the High Court decision.

The matter originated with Bendigo's application to the Council for resource consent to subdivide its land, which was opposed by Canyon. The Council granted consent, leading to Canyon's appeal to the Environment Court. The Environment Court upheld the Council's decision but with amended conditions. Canyon then appealed to the High Court, which dismissed the appeal. Canyon sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was declined. Canyon now seeks leave to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Supreme Court have jurisdiction to entertain this application for leave to appeal directly from the High Court?
2. Are there exceptional circumstances that justify taking this appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court under section 75 of the Senior Courts Act?
3. Does the application meet the criteria for leave to appeal under section 74 of the Senior Courts Act?

Held
1. The Supreme Court held that it does not have jurisdiction to entertain the application for leave to appeal directly from the High Court.
2. The Supreme Court found that there are no exceptional circumstances that justify taking this appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court under section 75 of the Senior Courts Act.
3. The Supreme Court determined that the application does not meet the criteria for leave to appeal under section 74 of the Senior Courts Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court began by considering whether it had jurisdiction to entertain the application for leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The Court found that under section 299 of the Resource Management Act 1991, appeals of High Court decisions are governed by Subpart 8 of Part 6 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011, with necessary modifications. Canyon had already appealed to the Court of Appeal, which declined leave to appeal. The Supreme Court held that the Council's argument that the Court lacks jurisdiction under section 69(a) of the Senior Courts Act was valid in this case, given the existence of another enactment governing the appeal process. Therefore, the Court concluded that it did not have jurisdiction to hear the appeal.

Next, the Court examined whether there were exceptional circumstances justifying the application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court directly from the High Court under section 75 of the Senior Courts Act. The Court noted that this is a difficult barrier to overcome, especially when the Court of Appeal has already declined leave in a fully reasoned judgment. The Court found that Canyon's arguments did not present exceptional circumstances warranting an appeal directly to the Supreme Court.

Lastly, the Court considered whether the application met the criteria for leave to appeal under section 74 of the Senior Courts Act. The Court found that while the issues raised by Canyon could be of general or public importance, this case rested on its particular circumstances. Furthermore, Canyon's arguments did not suggest a risk of a miscarriage of justice. The Court concluded that the application did not meet the criteria for leave to appeal.

In summary, the Supreme Court held that it did not have jurisdiction to entertain the application for leave to appeal directly from the High Court, that there were no exceptional circumstances justifying the application, and that the application did not meet the criteria for leave to appeal under section 74 of the Senior Courts Act. Consequently, the application for an extension of time to apply for leave to appeal was dismissed, and Canyon was ordered to pay the respondents' costs of $2,500.