Te Whānau a Kai Trust v Gisborne District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND GISBORNE REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TŪRANGANUI-A-KIWA ROHE

CIV-2021-416-000021

[2022] NZHC 1462

BETWEEN

TE WHĀNAU A KAI TRUST

Appellant

AND

GISBORNE DISTRICT COUNCIL

First Respondent

AND

RONGOWHAKAATA IWI TRUST

Section 301 Party

AND

ATTORNEY-GENERAL

Intervener

Hearing: 4-5 April 2022

Appearances:

D M Smith and D C F Naden for the Appellant

P T Beverley, T J Ryan and E L Bennett for the First Respondent No appearance for the Second Respondent

D A Ward and K Peirse-O’Byrne for the Intervener

Judgment:

23 June 2022


JUDGMENT OF GRICE J (SUBSTANTIVE)


TE WHĀNAU A KAI TRUST v GISBORNE DISTRICT COUNCIL [2022] NZHC 1462 [23 June 2022]

Contents

Introduction[1]

Grounds of appeal[4]

Appeal on question of law[11]

Background[19]
The Environment Court decision[22]

Jurisdiction[53]

Evidential issues[63]

First issue on appeal — jurisdictional issue  [72]

Appellant’s arguments[72]

Analysis[84]

Second issue on appeal — evidence of tikanga-based customary rights          [91]

Third issue on appeal — provision of resourcing to support exercise of
tikanga-based rights[104]
Fourth issue on appeal — wording of specific amendments[114]

Definition of “Tikanga wai Māori”[120]

Customary rights[122]
Mana whenua values[126]
Other documents outside planning documentation[129]

Working together: methods[132]

Conclusion  [137]

Costs[140]

Introduction

[1]    This is an appeal on a question of law under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA) from a decision of the Environment Court dated 4 August 2021 (the Environment Court decision).1 The Environment Court dismissed an appeal by the  Te Whānau a Kai Trust (the Trust) against the decision of the Gisborne District Council (the Council) relating to submissions  the  Trust  had  made  on  the Regional Freshwater Plan (the Freshwater Plan).

[2]    The Trust is an incorporated charitable trust and mandated representative entity of the iwi of Te Whānau a Kai, an ancient iwi of Tūranganui-a-Kiwa (Poverty Bay) whose ancestors arrived in the region about 1100 AD. Its historical Treaty claims span four separate Waitangi Tribunal inquiry districts from the headwaters of the Waioeka Gorge in the west to Matawhero in the east. The iwi has suffered serious breaches of te Tiriti o Waitangi | the Treaty of Waitangi (the Treaty or te Tiriti), including the confiscation of their lands at Pātūtahi and the loss of other traditional lands, and deaths and atrocities inflicted by the Crown.2 It is yet to settle its historical Treaty claims with the Crown.

[3]    The Council is a unitary authority and the local authority responsible for local government matters in the Tairāwhiti area.3 In its regional capacity, it is required to have a Regional Policy Statement (RPS) and Regional Coastal Plan in place. It may also prepare regional plans in relation to its other functions.4 It was responsible for preparing the Freshwater Plan, which contains both the RPS and regional plan provisions for freshwater.

Grounds of appeal

[4]    At its heart, the Trust’s appeal seeks recognition in the Freshwater Plan of the customary rights and interests (including proprietary interests) of Te Whānau a Kai in


1      Te Whānau a Kai Trust v Gisborne District Council

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Te Whānau a Kai Trust v Gisborne District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 1462
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Te Whānau a Kai Trust sought to appeal against the Gisborne District Council's decision on the Regional Freshwater Plan, arguing for recognition of its customary rights and interests in freshwater within its rohe. The Trust's appeal was dismissed by the Environment Court and subsequently appealed to the High Court on questions of law. The High Court was asked to determine whether the Environment Court had erred in law in four respects: the jurisdiction of the Court to recognise and provide for tikanga-based proprietary rights in freshwater, the sufficiency of the evidence to support the appellant's claim of unextinguished tikanga rights, the power under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA) to require the Council to provide resourcing to support the exercise of tikanga rights, and the appropriateness of specific amendments to the Freshwater Plan. The Court found that the Environment Court had not erred in law, dismissing the appeal on all four issues. The Court held that the Environment Court did not have jurisdiction to recognise and provide for tikanga-based proprietary rights in freshwater under the RMA, which provides a regulatory framework for land use rather than recognising ownership or native title rights. It also found that the evidence before the Environment Court was insufficient to support a finding of unextinguished tikanga rights. The Court further held that there was no power under the RMA to require the Council to provide resourcing to support the exercise of tikanga rights, as this fell under the Local Government Act 2002. Finally, the Court found that the Environment Court did not err in rejecting certain amendments to the Freshwater Plan, as these were not before the Court and would have required fresh evidence. The appeal was dismissed, and the issue of costs was reserved for later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established