| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA373/2022 [2023] NZCA 55 |
| BETWEEN | TE WHĀNAU A KAI TRUST |
| AND | GISBORNE DISTRICT COUNCIL |
| Court: | French and Katz JJ |
Counsel: | M S Smith and D C F Naden for Applicant |
Judgment: | 13 March 2023 at 11:30 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe application for leave to appeal is declined.
BThe applicant must pay the respondent costs for a standard application on a band A basis and usual disbursements.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Katz J)
Introduction
Te Whānau a Kai Trust (the Trust) applies to this Court for leave to bring an appeal on a question of law under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). The dispute concerns a decision by the Gisborne District Council (the Council) to adopt the Gisborne Regional Freshwater Plan. The Trust unsuccessfully appealed the Council’s decision to the Environment Court.[1] The Trust then appealed the Environment Court decision to the High Court pursuant to s 299 of the RMA. That appeal was dismissed by Grice J.[2] The Trust now seeks leave to appeal to this Court. The application for leave is opposed by the Council.
Background
[1]Te Whānau a Kai Trust v Gisborne District Council [2021] NZEnvC 115, [2022] NZRMA 372 [Environment Court decision].
[2]Te Whānau a Kai Trust v Gisborne District Council [2022] NZHC 1462, (2022) 23 ELRNZ 991 [High Court decision].
The Trust is the mandated representative entity for the iwi Te Whānau a Kai, an ancient iwi of Tūranganui-a-Kiwa — Poverty Bay. Since at least 2011, the Trust has been seeking to obtain formal recognition of the iwi’s claim to a tikanga‑based proprietary right in freshwater in the Tairāwhiti — Gisborne region.[3] The iwi consider themselves to be “water owners” not mere “stakeholders”.[4]
[3]Environment Court decision, above n 1, at [2] and [9].
[4]At [9].
The Council is a unitary authority and the local authority responsible for local government matters in the Tairāwhiti — Gisborne region. Between 2010 and 2015 the Council developed a Freshwater Plan for the region pursuant to the RMA. In the High Court, Grice J summarised the process of developing the Freshwater Plan as follows:[5]
The eight-stage development of the Plan included consultation with key stakeholders and iwi through a Freshwater Advisory Group. The Plan was notified on 10 October 2015 and Te Whānau a Kai filed submissions with the Council on 9 December 2015. [A Regional Policy Statement] and general matters hearing was held in Gisborne on 6 August 2016, at which the trustees of Te Whānau a Kai made submissions. Other Freshwater Plan hearings were held during 2016.
…
A “decisions version” of the Freshwater Plan was issued by the Council on 17 August 2017. A number of appeals were then lodged following the issue of the plan. By the time of the hearing in the Environment Court eight of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Te Whānau a Kai Trust v Gisborne District Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NZCA 55
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The first was a challenge to the Environment Court’s finding that it did not have jurisdiction to direct the inclusion of provisions in the Freshwater Plan which recognised and provided for the exercise of proprietary interests in freshwater. The Court found that the Resource Management Act 1991 does not provide the Environment Court with jurisdiction to determine the underlying ownership of natural resources, including water. The Trust’s proposed ground of appeal was not seriously arguable because the Court found that the Environment Court was correct to conclude that it did not have jurisdiction to determine issues of native title or ownership of land. The second and third grounds of appeal challenged the Environment Court’s finding that the Trust had not provided sufficient evidence to establish that Te Whānau a Kai has tikanga-based proprietary rights in freshwater in its rohe. Given the Court’s finding that it was not seriously arguable that the jurisdiction finding was in error, the issue of the correct approach under the RMA to assessing evidence of proprietary rights in freshwater was academic and could not justify the grant of leave to appeal. The fourth proposed ground of appeal challenged the funding finding that there is no power under the RMA that enables the Environment Court to require the Council, through provisions in its Freshwater Plan, to resource the Trust with technical and financial assistance in relation to freshwater issues. The Court found that it was not seriously arguable that the High Court erred in this regard, as the RMA does not provide a mechanism to achieve such an outcome. The fifth proposed ground of appeal related to the definition of “Tikanga wai Māori” in the Freshwater Plan. The Court found that the Environment Court did not err in adopting the wording it did, as there are many ways in which the terms used in legal or other documents can be defined. The Court concluded that this ground of appeal did not raise an arguable error of law of general or public importance, justifying a third appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The Court declined the Trust’s application for leave to appeal. The Trust must pay the Council’s costs for a standard application on a band A basis and usual disbursements.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter began with an appeal by Te Whānau a Kai Trust to the Environment Court, which was dismissed. The Trust then appealed to the High Court, which also dismissed the appeal. The Trust has now applied to the Court of Appeal for leave to bring a further appeal on questions of law under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). The application for leave is opposed by the Gisborne District Council.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Environment Court and the High Court err in finding that they did not have jurisdiction to direct the inclusion of provisions in the Freshwater Plan which recognised and provided for the exercise of proprietary interests in freshwater?
2. Did the Environment Court and the High Court err in finding that there was insufficient evidence to establish that Te Whānau a Kai had tikanga-based proprietary rights in freshwater within its rohe?
3. Did the Environment Court and the High Court err in finding that there was no power under the RMA to require the Council, through provisions in its Freshwater Plan, to resource the Trust with technical and financial assistance in relation to freshwater issues?
4. Did the Environment Court err in defining "Tikanga wai Māori" in the Freshwater Plan?
5. Are there any other legal issues that the Court of Appeal should consider in relation to the Freshwater Plan and the Trust's appeal?
Held
1. The Court of Appeal found that the Environment Court and the High Court did not err in their jurisdictional finding that they did not have jurisdiction to direct the inclusion of provisions in the Freshwater Plan which recognised and provided for the exercise of proprietary interests in freshwater.
2. The Court of Appeal found that the Environment Court and the High Court did not err in their finding that there was insufficient evidence to establish that Te Whānau a Kai had tikanga-based proprietary rights in freshwater within its rohe.
3. The Court of Appeal found that the Environment Court and the High Court did not err in their finding that there was no power under the Resource Management Act (RMA) to require the Council, through provisions in its Freshwater Plan, to resource the Trust with technical and financial assistance in relation to freshwater issues.
4. The Court of Appeal found that the Environment Court did not err in defining "Tikanga wai Māori" in the Freshwater Plan.
5. The Court of Appeal declined the application for leave to appeal and ordered that the applicant must pay the respondent costs for a standard application on a band A basis and usual disbursements.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal examined the Trust's application for leave to appeal against the decision of the High Court. The Trust sought to challenge the findings of the Environment Court and the High Court on several grounds, including the jurisdictional finding, the evidence finding, the funding finding, and the definition of "Tikanga wai Māori" in the Freshwater Plan. The Court of Appeal held that the Trust had not established that any of the proposed grounds of appeal met the threshold for leave to appeal, as they were not seriously arguable and did not raise questions of law of general or public importance.
The Court of Appeal examined the jurisdictional finding first, which concerned whether the Environment Court and the High Court had the jurisdiction to direct the inclusion of provisions in the Freshwater Plan recognising and providing for the exercise of proprietary interests in freshwater. The Court of Appeal found that the Trust's argument was not seriously arguable, as the RMA was not designed to recognise ownership or native title rights, and the jurisdiction to determine such rights rested with other courts, such as the High Court or the Māori Land Court.
The Court of Appeal then examined the evidence finding, which concerned whether the Trust had provided sufficient evidence to establish that Te Whānau a Kai had tikanga-based proprietary rights in freshwater within its rohe. The Court of Appeal found that the Trust's argument was academic, as it was not seriously arguable that the jurisdictional finding was in error.
Next, the Court of Appeal examined the funding finding, which concerned whether there was any power under the RMA to require the Council, through provisions in its Freshwater Plan, to resource the Trust with technical and financial assistance in relation to freshwater issues. The Court of Appeal found that the Trust's argument was not seriously arguable, as the RMA did not provide a mechanism to achieve such an outcome, and it would be inappropriate for the Environment Court to circumvent the Local Government Act's framework for decisions about funding and expenditure.
Finally, the Court of Appeal examined the definition of "Tikanga wai Māori" in the Freshwater Plan. The Court of Appeal found that the Trust's argument was not seriously arguable, as the definition adopted by the Environment Court was consistent with existing definitions of "tikanga Māori" in other instruments, and the Court was entitled to take into account the evidence of an expert planner in reaching its decision.
In conclusion, the Court of Appeal declined the Trust's application for leave to appeal and ordered that the applicant must pay the respondent costs for a standard application on a band A basis and usual disbursements. The Court emphasised that its findings were only in relation to the Environment Court's jurisdiction under the RMA, and not the underlying merits of the claim to proprietary rights in freshwater resources.