Te R�nunga o Ng�i Tahu v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2021-485-000328

[2022] NZHC 1643

BETWEEN

TE RŪNANGA O NGĀI TAHU

Plaintiff

AND

ATTORNEY-GENERAL

Defendant

Hearing: 23 May 2022

Appearances:

A R Galbraith QC, R E Brown and G F Dawson for Plaintiff M Heron QC, C Tyson and D Hunt for Defendant

Judgment:

12 July 2022


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE PAULSEN


This judgment was delivered by me on 12 July 2022 at 4.00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

TE RŪNANGA O NGĀI TAHU v ATTORNEY-GENERAL [2022] NZHC 1643 [12 July 2022]

Table of Contents

Para No

Background [6]

High Court Rules 2016

[30]

Clause 10.5

[34]

The Crown’s submissions

[44]

High Court Rule 5.49(3)

[45]

High Court Rule 15.1

[51]

What are the issues?

[55]

My analysis

Has Ngai Tahu’s claim been resolved by accord and satisfaction or merger in judgment?

[56]

Is Ngai Tahu’s claim dependent upon a finding by the arbitrator that the Criwb breahed the relativity mechanism?

[83]

Is Ngai Tahu’s claim time-barred by s 11(1) of the Limitation Act 2010?

[86]

Is Ngai Tahu precluded from making a claim in respect of the Waikato

River Co-Management Claims Redress Amounts by the Deed of Settlement in relation to the Relativity Mechanism Dispute dated 22 May 2015?

[97]

Is Ngai Tahu precluded from making its claim insofar as it relates to the Rotoehu West write-down and school site losses because of the absence of a finding of the arbitrator that those amounts are CRAs?

Is Ngai Tahu’s claim otherwise an abuse of process?

[99]

[102]

A final remark

[105]

Result

[106]

[1]                  Te Rūnunga o Ngāi Tahu (Ngāi Tahu) and the Crown settled certain historical claims under the Treaty of Waitangi. The Deed of Settlement contained a mechanism to maintain the relativity of Ngāi Tahu’s settlement to the total value of redress provided in settlement of all historical Treaty claims (the relativity mechanism).

[2]                  Ngāi Tahu brings this proceeding seeking interest on amounts that, following arbitration between the parties, have been found to be owing under the relativity mechanism. Ngāi Tahu’s claim for interest is advanced as damages for breach of contract or at statutory rates under the Judicature Act 1908 and the Interest on Money Claims Act 2016.

[3]The Crown considers Ngāi Tahu is not entitled to interest on any basis.

[4]                  The application before me relates only to Ngāi Tahu’s first cause of action for interest as damages. The Crown seeks an order dismissing the first cause of action under r 5.49(3) of the High Court Rules 2016 on the basis that the Court has no jurisdiction to hear it. Alternatively, it asks the Court to strike out the first cause of action under r 15.1 (1) as disclosing no reasonably arguable cause of action, or as an abuse of process.

[5]                  Ngāi Tahu argues the claim for interest as damages is clearly within the Court’s jurisdiction, was preserved by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Te R�nunga o Ng�i Tahu v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 1643
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Te Rūnunga o Ngāi Tahu (Ngāi Tahu) and the Crown settled certain historical claims under the Treaty of Waitangi, including a mechanism to maintain the relativity of Ngāi Tahu's settlement to the total value of redress provided in settlement of all historical Treaty claims (the relativity mechanism). Ngāi Tahu now seeks interest on amounts found owing under the relativity mechanism. The Crown argues Ngāi Tahu is not entitled to interest on any basis. The Crown seeks to have Ngāi Tahu's first cause of action for interest dismissed under r 5.49(3) of the High Court Rules 2016 on the basis that the Court has no jurisdiction to hear it. Alternatively, the Crown asks the Court to strike out the first cause of action under r 15.1(1) as disclosing no reasonably arguable cause of action, or as an abuse of process.

Ngāi Tahu argues the claim for interest as damages is clearly within the Court's jurisdiction, was preserved by the arbitration agreement between the parties, is well arguable, and is not an abuse of process.

Ngāi Tahu's claim for interest as damages is not barred by accord and satisfaction or merger in judgment. Ngāi Tahu did not agree, expressly or by implication, that its right to claim interest would be discharged by a decision of the arbitrator. The question of interest was not submitted to the arbitrator, but rather was expressly reserved for later determination, including, if necessary, by the High Court.

The Court's analysis of cl 10.5 of the arbitration agreement shows that the Crown's principal obligation must be to calculate and pay the objectively-determined correct amounts under the relativity mechanism to ensure relativity is maintained. The Court rejects the Crown's submission that the Crown's obligation is to pay only what it subjectively considers is owing.

The Court also rejects the Crown's submission that Ngāi Tahu's claim is time-barred by s 11(1) of the Limitation Act 2010. The Court finds that the parties have effectively contracted out of the limitation period because they entered into an agreement that was inconsistent with the limitation defence the Crown now seeks to advance.

The Court dismisses the Crown's application and orders Ngāi Tahu is entitled to costs. Counsel are to submit memoranda of no more than five pages within 21 days in the event of any dispute regarding costs.