Talley's Group Ltd v Worksafe New Zealand

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FOR A COURT READY (FEE REQUIRED) VERSION PLEASE FOLLOW THIS LINK

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA316/2017
 [2018] NZCA 587

BETWEEN

TALLEY’S GROUP LIMITED
Appellant

AND

WORKSAFE NEW ZEALAND
Respondent

CA335/2017

BETWEEN

WORKSAFE NEW ZEALAND
Appellant

AND

TALLEY’S GROUP LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

23 April 2018

Court:

Cooper, Winkelmann and Williams JJ

Counsel:

J H M Eaton QC and P C Dawson for Talley’s Group Limited
I R Murray, M L Wong and E F Jeffs for Worksafe New Zealand

Judgment:

14 December 2018 at 3.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to appeal in CA316/2017 is granted.

BThe application for leave to appeal in CA335/2017 is granted.

CThe questions of law are answered as follows:

Question:

(a)Was the Judge correct to find the non-compliant charging document could be saved by reference to s 379 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011?

Answer:

Yes.

Question:

(b)Was the Judge correct to find that an informant’s summary of facts could save a non-compliant charging document under s 379 of the Criminal Procedure Act?

Answer:

Yes.

Question:

(c)If s 379 of the Criminal Procedure Act could save the non-compliant charging document, was the Judge correct to find that there could be no miscarriage of justice under s 379 unless the defect caused the significant prejudice?

Answer:

It is unnecessary to answer this question as we have found there was no miscarriage of justice.

Question:

(d)Was the Judge correct to find that prosecutorial conduct did not amount to an abuse of process warranting a stay of proceedings?

Answer:

Yes.

Question:

(e)Was the Judge correct to conclude that s 17(4) of the Criminal Procedure Act requires each practicable step relied upon by the prosecution in terms of an offence under ss 6 and 50 of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992 to be set out in the charging document?

Answer:

Yes.

DThe appeal in CA316/2017 is dismissed.

EThe appeal in CA335/2017 is dismissed.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Williams J)

Introduction

  1. Te Atatū Hēmi worked at a vegetable processing plant in Fairton near Ashburton. The plant is operated by Talley’s Group Limited (Talley’s). A bulk bin fell from a forklift and struck Ms Hēmi causing her severe injuries. Talley’s was charged by WorkSafe New Zealand (Worksafe) with, contrary to ss 6 and 50(1)(a) of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992 (HSEA), failing to take all practicable steps to ensure that Ms Hēmi was, while at work, not exposed to hazards arising out of the operation of the forklift at the plant. Worksafe did not provide particulars in its charging document of the practicable steps it says Talley’s failed to take.

  2. The issue in this appeal is whether the lack of particulars of those steps in the charging document invalidated the charge.  Judge Maze in the District Court found in favour of Talley’s.[1]  She considered that the charging document was defective in several respects including…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Talley's Group Ltd v Worksafe New Zealand and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 587
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Talley's Group Ltd and Worksafe New Zealand were involved in a legal dispute over charges brought by Worksafe against Talley's for alleged health and safety breaches at a vegetable processing plant. Talley's was charged with failing to take all practicable steps to ensure the safety of employees, specifically in relation to the operation of a forklift. The key issue was whether the charging document provided by Worksafe contained sufficient particulars of the alleged failures, as required by the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 (CPA). The District Court initially found the charging document defective and dismissed the charges, but this decision was reversed by the High Court. Talley's appealed to the Court of Appeal, raising several questions of law, while Worksafe cross-appealed on one issue.

The Court of Appeal first addressed whether the charging document was defective due to the omission of relevant particulars. It found that the charging document was indeed defective because it failed to specify the practicable steps that Talley's allegedly failed to take, which were essential to fully and fairly inform Talley's of the substance of the offence. The Court held that the particulars in the summary of facts served with the charging document could remedy the defect, as they provided sufficient notice of the nature of the alleged failures.

Next, the Court considered whether s 379 of the CPA could save the defective charging document. It concluded that the section was designed to save defective documents provided there was no miscarriage of justice, and that in this case, Talley's had been sufficiently informed of the substance of the offence. The Court also found that Worksafe's practice of providing particulars through the summary of facts, rather than in the charging document, did not warrant a stay of proceedings, as it did not amount to an abuse of process.

Lastly, the Court of Appeal addressed the question of whether the charging document was a nullity due to the omission of particulars. It found that while the charging document was defective, it was not a nullity because it disclosed a recognisable charge, a recognisable defendant, and was in time. The Court emphasised that a charging document will only be considered a nullity if it fails to disclose an offence, a defendant, or is so unintelligible that the nature of the offence cannot be ascertained.

The Court of Appeal ultimately upheld the High Court's decision, answering the questions of law in favour of Worksafe and dismissing both appeals. The charging document was found to be defective but not a nullity, and s 379 of the CPA saved it from invalidity. The Court also found that prosecutorial conduct did not amount to an abuse of process warranting a stay of proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established