Buttle v District Court at Auckland

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2023-404-1276

[2023] NZHC 2279

BETWEEN ANDREW BUTTLE, JAMES BUTTLE and PETER BUTTLE
Applicants

AND

DISTRICT COURT AT AUCKLAND

Respondent

AND

WORKSAFE NEW ZEALAND

Second Respondent

Hearing: 10 August 2023

Appearances:

S W B Foote KC, D Neutze and P Hawkins for Applicant

M J Hodge, S T M Forrest and K Nihill for Second Respondent

Judgment:

22 August 2023


JUDGMENT OF ANDERSON J


This judgment was delivered by me on 22 August 2023 at 3.00 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules 2016.

……………………………… Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:
Brookfields, Auckland

BUTTLE v DISTRICT COURT AT AUCKLAND [2023] NZHC 2279 [22 August 2023]

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction[1]

The threshold the Buttles need to meet[7]

Charges against the Buttles[15]

Talley’s Group Limited v WorkSafe New Zealand (Talley’s case)[17]

WorkSafe’s Whakaari investigation process[31]

Events following charges being laid[40]

Pre-October Ruling exchanges[41]

October Ruling[53]

Transcript of hearing[58]

Exchanges between the October Ruling and May Ruling  [59]

May Ruling[65]

Amendment of charges  [74]

Prejudice – Expert evidence[76]

Is the threshold test met?[79]

A narrow issue?[80]

Irremediable prejudice?[86]

Stay on the basis of the public interest in the integrity of the justice system    [92]

The position before the October Ruling[97]

The position after the October Ruling[103]

WorkSafe’s “assurance” in Talley’s case[108]

Conclusion  [111]

Introduction

[1]    Whakaari/White Island (Whakaari) is an active volcano situated on the east coast of the North Island. Since 1936, Whakaari has been owned by the Buttle family, most recently through Whakaari Trustee Limited (WTL). Until recently it was a popular tourist destination. On 9 December 2019, while 47 people were on the island, Whakaari erupted. A total of 22 people died and 25 were seriously injured.

[2]    Peter, James and Andrew Buttle (the Buttles) were the sole directors of Whakaari Management Ltd (WML), a company established to manage Whakaari. WML entered into licence agreements with tourist operators for access to the island which included requiring operators to meet health and safety obligations. Following the eruption, the Buttles, WML and others, were charged under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 (HSWA). The Buttles were the only individuals charged. The trial commenced in the District Court at Auckland on 11 July 2023. After a break in the trial between 11 and 23 August 2023, it is due to conclude by the end of September 2023.

[3]    The Buttles made two pre-trial applications to have the charges against them dismissed under s 147 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 (CPA) or the proceedings stayed. Judge E M Thomas in the District Court at Auckland declined the applications by way of two rulings: one on 18 October 20221 and the other on 30 May 20232 (the Rulings). The Rulings relate to the appropriate level of particularisation of the HSWA charges against the Buttles, and whether the charges should be dismissed or stayed on the basis of prosecutorial misconduct by the second respondent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Buttle v District Court at Auckland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 2279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Buttle family, owners of Whakaari/White Island, a volcano which erupted on 9 December 2019, killing 22 people, face criminal charges under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015. They sought to have the charges dismissed or stayed by the District Court. The District Court declined to do so. They now seek to have the District Court's decisions reviewed by the High Court. The court held that the threshold for judicial review of the District Court's decisions was not met. In particular, the court held that the Buttles had not shown that they would suffer truly exceptional circumstances that would justify the High Court intervening in the criminal process in this case. The court declined to address the substantive points of review, such as the necessary particularisation of the charges against the Buttles, as they could be pursued on appeal if the Buttles were convicted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.