Stringer v Minister of Lands

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CIV 2013-442-316 [2014] NZHC 776

UNDER

section 26 of the Land Valuation

Proceedings Act 1948

IN THE MATTER OF

an appeal against a decision of the Land Valuation Tribunal on a claim for costs following a claim for compensation under the P ublic Works Act 1981

BETWEEN

PAUL THOMAS STRINGER Appellant

AND

MINISTER OF LANDS Respondent

Hearing: 15 April 2014

Counsel:

G Downing and G Engelbrecht for Appellant
M T Parker for Respondent

Judgment:

1 May 2014

JUDGMENT OF RONALD YOUNG J

Introduction

[1]      In April 2008  a  parcel  of  land  near  State  Highway 60  at  the  Ruby  Bay by-pass owned by Mr Stringer was taken by the state by proclamation.  The land was needed  for  roading.     The  Crown  owned  the  land  from  May 2008  onwards. Mr Stringer and the Minister of Lands could not agree on the compensation payable for  taking  the  land.     The  proceedings  then  issued  by  Mr Stringer  seeking

Tribunal-ordered compensation came before the Land Valuation Tribunal.

STRINGER v MINISTER OF LANDS [2014] NZHC 776 [1 May 2014]

[2]      Mr Stringer sought compensation for the land taken (including compensation for injurious affection and costs, apart from litigation costs) of $1,034,000.   The Crown offered $345,000 plus legal costs, valuation expenses and interest.  The Land Valuation Tribunal awarded $391,750.

[3]      After the judgment  the  Land Valuation Tribunal  invited  submissions and subsequently  issued  a  decision  on  costs  and  interest.    Mr Stringer  sought  total pre-Tribunal  filing  costs  (negotiating  costs)  and  post-Tribunal  filing  costs  of

$133,679.65 plus GST.  In addition, Mr Stringer said that there should be compound interest on the compensation awarded from May 2008.

[4]      The Land Valuation Tribunal awarded  $20,000  in costs, including expert witness expenses and GST, and concluded that non-compounding (simple) interest was appropriate.

[5]      Mr Stringer appeals against the costs and interest orders.   He says that he should  have  full  negotiating  costs  both  legal  and  expert,  full  post-filing  expert witness costs and 75 per cent of post-filing legal costs.   Those sums should have GST added to them.  In addition, Mr Stringer says the Tribunal should have awarded him compound interest, from the date of compulsory acquisition (May 2008) until the compensation ordered was paid (February 2014).

The Tribunal’s decision

[6]      The  Land  Valuation  Tribunal  decision  on  costs  was  driven  primarily  by Mr Stringer’s approach to the litigation before the Tribunal.  The Tribunal rejected his approach to his claim for compensation.  The Tribunal considered that there were two important issues in assessing the value of the compulsorily taken land.  First, if the  land  was  subdividable,  how  should  that  affect  the  assessment  of  value? Secondly, in any event, what was the market for such subdivided land in the relevant area?  The Tribunal accepted the land in question may be subdividable but concluded there was little demand for such land.

[7]      The  order  for  compensation  by  the  Tribunal  was  slightly  above  the respondent’s offer.  Mr Stringer’s claim was over 2.5 times larger than the ultimate award.   The Tribunal concluded that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stringer v Minister of Lands and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 776
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Paul Thomas Stringer appealed a decision of the Land Valuation Tribunal on a claim for costs following a claim for compensation under the Public Works Act 1981. The appeal was heard by Ronald Young J in the High Court of New Zealand, Nelson Registry. The Crown had taken a parcel of land owned by Mr Stringer for roading under the Public Works Act 1981. The Crown and Mr Stringer could not agree on the compensation payable for the taking of the land, and the proceedings issued by Mr Stringer seeking Tribunal-ordered compensation. The Land Valuation Tribunal awarded $391,750 in compensation. The Tribunal awarded $20,000 in costs, including expert witness expenses and GST, and concluded that non-compounding (simple) interest was appropriate. Mr Stringer sought total pre-Tribunal filing costs (negotiating costs) and post-Tribunal filing costs of $133,679.65 plus GST. In addition, Mr Stringer said that there should be compound interest on the compensation awarded from May 2008. Mr Stringer appealed against the costs and interest orders. The Court held that the Tribunal’s decision on costs was driven primarily by Mr Stringer’s approach to the litigation before the Tribunal. The Court rejected Mr Stringer’s approach to his claim for compensation and concluded that a substantially reduced costs award was appropriate. The Court allowed the appeal with respect to the negotiating costs claim and awarded $40,735.22 costs to Mr Stringer. The Court rejected the appeal against the s 90 costs award and held that the Tribunal’s approach was justified. The Court held that costs awards are GST neutral and that interest payable is non-compounding but needs to be recalculated to take into account the order.