IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-Ā-TARA ROHE
CIV 2014-485-11493 [2017] NZHC 2512
BETWEEN STRATHBOSS KIWIFRUIT LIMITED
First Plaintiff
SEEKA LIMITED Second Plaintiff
AND
THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL Defendant
Hearing: Began on 7 August 2017 and continues Counsel:
D M Salmon, M Heard, J P Cundy and S Y M Chew for the
PlaintiffsJ E Hodder QC, S V McKechnie, P H Higbee and J C Catran for the Defendant
Judgment:
11 October 2017
RULING OF MALLON J (INSURANCE)
Introduction
[1] This trial is in its tenth week of a scheduled 12 weeks. It is a claim alleging negligence by the defendant in its biosecurity functions. What is described in the case law as a “novel duty of care” is pleaded. Whether the duty of care exists is a key issue in the trial. Within this issue a key sub-issue is whether it is appropriate to recognise the alleged duty of care on policy grounds. In relation to this sub-issue, the plaintiffs seek discovery of the defendant’s insurance arrangements as they relate
to this claim.
STRATHBOSS KIWIFRUIT LIMITED v THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL [2017] NZHC 2512 [11 October 2017]
Background
[2] During the discovery process prior to trial the defendant sought discovery of the plaintiffs’ insurance arrangements. Initially the plaintiffs objected to this on the basis that the information was not relevant and the request was too broad. The defendant responded on 23 May 2016 that the arrangements were “[r]elevant to duty
– the vulnerability or not” of the plaintiffs. The defendant confirmed this in a letter
dated 14 June 2016 which said:
To clarify our request, we consider insurance arrangements in relation to claimants’ kiwifruit vines and/or fruit, including for events such as a biosecurity incursion, are relevant to this claim. Any comparable insurance held by Seeka in its capacity as a PHO would also be relevant.
[3] At this time, the plaintiffs’ claim pleaded that policy factors that went to the fairness and justice of a duty of care included that the plaintiffs, and members of the plaintiff classes, “were particularly vulnerable to serious consequences if MAF and officers, agents and/or employees of MAF failed in their biosecurity responsibilities”.1 The plaintiffs agreed to provide discovery of any relevant insurance arrangements. However the plaintiffs did not hold any relevant insurance and so had no documents to disclose.
[4] The plaintiffs did not ask the defendant to discover any relevant insurance arrangements at this time. The defendant’s insurance arrangements were first raised in the plaintiffs’ opening. The relevant exchange was as follows:
THE COURT:
… obviously there is the orchardists themselves so they have to bear the cost through insurance. …
MR SALMON:
… More particularly, the costs of that insurance will be massively affected by whether MPI is careful in its job or not. So effectively, it will be asking those usually small importers, [the] middle persons, to somehow insure against MPI’s competence or incompetence and that raises another gloss that the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Strathboss Kiwifruit Limited v Attorney-General and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZHC 2512
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The plaintiffs sought discovery of the defendant's insurance arrangements as they relate to this claim. The defendant opposed this request, arguing that its insurance arrangements were not relevant to any issue in the proceeding. The court held that the availability of insurance can be a relevant factor in assessing the policy factors that support or detract from the existence of a duty of care. However, the court was not persuaded that it was appropriate at this stage in the trial for either party to call new evidence about the availability or not of insurance for biosecurity risks.
The court ruled that the defendant must give discovery of its insurance cover as it relates to this claim. The purpose of this discovery is to ensure the information before the Court about the defendant’s insurance position is accurately corrected from the plaintiffs’ perspective. The court noted that neither the plaintiffs nor the court have details about the actual insurance cover, and that it will reserve leave to either party to apply to call further evidence once the plaintiffs have discovery of the defendant’s policy or policies as they relate to this claim.
This case highlights the importance of considering policy factors, such as the availability of insurance, when determining whether a duty of care exists in a novel situation. The court's decision to order the discovery of the defendant's insurance arrangements demonstrates the need for accurate information to be presented to the court when assessing the fairness, justice, and reasonableness of imposing a duty of care. However, the court also emphasised that it is not appropriate to call new evidence about the availability of insurance at this stage in the trial, as such evidence may be based on assumptions that could be unwise.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi