Stewart v Milano International 2007 Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2018-404-1182

[2018] NZHC 2925

BETWEEN

KRISTINE MARY STEWART

First Plaintiff

JOSEPH MATTHEW BROWN
Second Plaintiff

AND

MILANO INTERNATIONAL 2007 LIMITED

First Defendant

EURO ASIA BUILDING
CONSTRUCTION LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

CRT Hollings for plaintiffs MR Taylor for first defendant

No appearance for second defendant

Judgment:

12 November 2018


JUDGMENT OF FITZGERALD J

[As to costs]


This judgment was delivered by me on 12 November 2018 at 2:30 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:Andrew Seton Law Ltd, Auckland (S West) Maria Taylor, Auckland

Stewart v Milano International 2007 Limited [2018] NZHC 2925 [12 November 2018]

Introduction

[1]                   The first and second plaintiffs are the owners of property in Titirangi. They sue the defendants for trespass and nuisance, claiming the defendants have been unlawfully crossing the plaintiffs’ land to complete construction projects on adjoining properties. Whata J granted interim injunctions to the plaintiffs on 24 August 2018.1 The first defendant consented to the injunctions being granted and the second defendant made no appearance. This judgment determines costs on the application for interim injunctions.

[2]                   The plaintiffs seek indemnity costs or, failing that, an uplift on 2B scale costs against the first defendant. Against the second defendant, which has not engaged with the proceedings, 2B scale costs are sought, along with disbursements. The first defendant submits costs should be reserved until the substantive proceedings are concluded but, if they are determined, they should be at scale.

Costs principles

[3]                   The application for interim injunctions was an interlocutory proceeding and costs must be fixed now, unless there are special reasons not to do so.2

[4]                   Increased and indemnity costs are governed by r 14.6 of the High Court Rules 2016. Indemnity costs may be imposed if, for example, a “party has acted vexatiously, frivolously, improperly, or unnecessarily in commencing, continuing, or defending a proceeding or a step in a proceeding”.3 Increased costs may be imposed if, “the party opposing costs has contributed unnecessarily to the time or expense of the proceeding or step in it” including by “failing, without reasonable justification, to admit facts, evidence, documents, or accept a legal argument”.4 Regardless of the approach taken, an award of costs should not exceed actual costs incurred by a party.5


1      Stewart v Milano International 2007 Ltd [2018] NZHC 2207.

2      High Court Rules 2016, r 14.8(1).

3      Rule 14.6(4)(a).

4      Rule 14.6(3)(b)(ii).

5      Rule 14.2(1)(f).

The competing contentions

[5]                   Ms Hollings, for the plaintiffs, argues the plaintiffs were put to unnecessary expense by the first defendant’s actions. Having filed a notice of opposition and two affidavits in reply, she submits the first defendant consented to the injunctions in almost identical terms to those sought on the afternoon before the hearing. Between those times, the use of a driveway (in respect of which the injunctions were sought) continued, despite the first defendant having been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stewart v Milano International 2007 Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 2925
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Stewart v Milano International 2007 Limited involved a dispute between the plaintiffs, Kristine Mary Stewart and Joseph Matthew Brown, who are the owners of property in Titirangi, and the defendants, Milano International 2007 Limited and Euro Asia Building Construction Limited. The plaintiffs sued the defendants for trespass and nuisance, alleging that the defendants had been unlawfully crossing the plaintiffs' land to complete construction projects on adjoining properties. Interim injunctions were granted to the plaintiffs by Whata J on 24 August 2018. The first defendant consented to the injunctions, while the second defendant did not appear. This judgment determined the costs on the application for interim injunctions.

The plaintiffs sought indemnity costs or, failing that, an uplift on 2B scale costs against the first defendant. Against the second defendant, which had not engaged with the proceedings, 2B scale costs were sought, along with disbursements. The first defendant submitted that costs should be reserved until the substantive proceedings were concluded, but if they were determined, they should be at scale. The court had to decide whether the plaintiffs were entitled to increased or indemnity costs against the first defendant and whether they were entitled to 2B scale costs and disbursements against the second defendant.

The court found that the similarity of the relief ordered on the interlocutory application to that sought in the statement of claim was not a special reason not to fix costs at this point. The court also found that the plaintiffs were not entitled to indemnity costs against the first defendant, as there was no clear cause to justify an increase. However, the court was satisfied that the first defendant had failed to accept what appears to be a good legal argument for an injunction to be granted until the last minute before the hearing, contributing unnecessarily to the plaintiffs' costs. The court considered an uplift of 20 per cent to be appropriate, which amounted to $8,429.40. The actual disbursements sought by the plaintiffs against the first defendant were not challenged and should be awarded. The court also found that the application against the second defendant was not properly brought, and it was necessary to reserve leave for the plaintiffs to file additional submissions on this topic, should they wish to pursue costs against the second defendant. If costs were pursued against the second defendant, the applicants could file further submissions within 10 working days of the receipt of this judgment, and the second defendant could file any submissions within a further five working days. Costs would be determined on the papers.

In conclusion, the first defendant was ordered to pay the plaintiffs costs of $8,429.40 and the actual disbursements sought. The court reserved leave for the plaintiffs to file additional submissions on costs against the second defendant, if they wished to pursue them. Counsel for the plaintiffs was to ensure a copy of this judgment was brought to the second defendant's attention, via its liquidator.