Steggall Nutrition Pty Limited v Hayward

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-003163 [2015] NZHC 413

BETWEEN

STEGGALL NUTRITION PTY

LIMITED Applicant

AND

LLOYD JAMES HAYWARD and JEFFREY PHILIP MELTZER as liquidators of South Pacific Brands Limited (In Liquidation) Respondents

Hearing: 3 March 2015

Appearances:

D D Vincent for Applicant
C A Murphy for Respondents

Judgment:

10 March 2015

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

as to inspection of liquidated company records

A creditor’s application to inspect the records of the company in liquidation

[1]      South Pacific Brands Ltd (SPB) is in liquidation.  Lloyd Hayward and Jeffrey

Meltzer have been its liquidators.

[2]      A creditor, Steggall Nutrition Pty Ltd (Steggall), applies under s 256(1)(a)(ii) Companies Act 1993 for an order permitting Steggall to inspect records of SPB. SPB’s liquidators oppose the application.   If an order of inspection is made, the liquidators  ask  that  the  Court  imposes  conditions  to  protect  the  commercial sensitivity of some documents.

What Steggall wants to inspect

[3]      Steggall seeks an order permitting it to inspect:

STEGGALL NUTRITION PTY LIMITED v HAYWARD [2015] NZHC 413 [10 March 2015]

(a)      a copy of the sale and purchase agreement and all attachments relating to any asset of SPB sold to Davies Foods (2006) Limited (Davies) and businesses and any contingent contract/agreements SPB or any related company or any director of those companies has with any member of the Davies Foods group of companies or businesses.  Such documents to be without any redaction;

(b)a copy of SPB’s secured creditor debt security documentation and all related settlement statements such documents to be without any redaction; and

(c)      a copy of any 2014 SPB financial performance statements including any trial balance, balance sheet, such documents to be without any redaction  including  the  2013  comparative detail  (if  any) on  those documents.

[4]       The requested inspection was explained for Steggall by Mr Vincent in his written synopsis in this way:

The Applicant wishes to inspect the company records in order to assess for itself the sale and purchase agreement with [Davies], the amount of funds received, how it was allocated on receipt and why such a large number of creditors remain unpaid.  It does not expect to receive any distribution from the liquidators so wishes to assess what other options it has to recover what it is owed.

[5]      Mr Vincent accepted, notwithstanding the formal application to inspect the sale agreement in unredacted form, that commercial sensitivity issues raised by SPB are required to be addressed, in relation to any order of inspection, by appropriate conditions.

Inspection under s 256(1)(a)(ii) Companies Act 1993

The statutory provision

[6]      Section 256(1)(a)(ii) Companies Act provides:

256     Duties in relation to accounts

(1)      Subject to subsection (2) of this section, the liquidator of a company must—

(a)       Keep  accounts  and  records  of  the liquidation  and permit those accounts and records, and the accounts and records in the company, to be inspected by—

(i)       …

(ii)      If the Court so orders, a creditor or shareholder;

The principles

[7]      The judgment of the Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Steggall Nutrition Pty Limited v Hayward and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 413
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Steggall Nutrition Pty Limited (Steggall) applied to inspect the records of South Pacific Brands Limited (SPB), which was in liquidation, under s 256(1)(a)(ii) Companies Act 1993. The liquidators, Lloyd James Hayward and Jeffrey Philip Meltzer, opposed the application. The Court had to determine whether Steggall had met the threshold test for inspection and if so, what conditions should apply to the inspection order. The Court found that Steggall had a tangible concern about the directors' decision to trade on while insolvent, which affected its unsecured creditors. The liquidators had not adequately addressed the impact of this decision on unsecured creditors. The Court also found that there were additional lines of enquiry that Steggall could pursue which might inform a decision on the prospects of remedies in relation to reckless trading. The Court ordered that the liquidators permit Steggall to inspect certain documents but with some redactions to protect commercial sensitivity. The liquidators could recover their reasonable costs and disbursements from Steggall for complying with the inspection order. The costs of the application were to lie where they fell.