South Pacific Industrial Ltd v United Telecoms Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CIV 2012-488-202 [2012] NZHC 688

BETWEEN  SOUTH PACIFIC INDUSTRIAL LIMITED

Plaintiff

ANDUNITED TELECOMS LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:         4 April 2012

Counsel:         P F Dalkie and R Wynne-Griffiths for Plaintiff

D M Hughes and R J Brown for Defendant

Judgment:      13 April 2012

JUDGMENT OF HEATH J

This judgment was delivered by me on 13 April 2012 at 3.00pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High

Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Hazelton Law, PO Box 5639, Wellington Kensington Swan, Private Bag 92101, Auckland Counsel:

P F Dalkie, PO Box 392, Shortland Street, Auckland

SOUTH PACIFIC INDUSTRIAL LIMITED V UNITED TELECOMS LIMITED HC WHA CIV 2012-488-202 [13 April 2012]

The application

[1]      South Pacific Industrial Ltd (SPI) seeks a freezing order1  to restrain United Telecoms Ltd (UTL) from transporting most of its New Zealand assets to India and remitting the proceeds of sale of others to that country.   SPI is a medium size engineering company with between 80 and 100 employees, based in Ruakaka.  UTL is an Indian company that is the parent of a multi-national group of companies, based in Bangalore.

[2]      The proceeding was commenced on 30 March 2012, when SPI sought a without notice freezing order.  I declined to make an order on that basis.  Perceiving that there was no imminent danger that the relevant assets would be removed from New Zealand, I directed that the papers be served and that UTL have an opportunity to respond.  The application was heard, on notice to UTL, on 4 April 2012.  UTL opposes the grant of a freezing order and seeks a stay of the proceeding, on the basis

that SPI has submitted to arbitration.2   Both parties agree that there is jurisdiction to

grant interim relief of this type, even though UTL has reserved its position to protest to the jurisdiction of the New Zealand courts.

[3]      Necessarily, the application comes before the Court in circumstances of some urgency.  A number of affidavits have been filed, in support of and in opposition to the application.  It is not possible to determine conflicts in the evidence, save to the extent that one version or the other might be supported by contemporaneous documents.  I have considered the evidence with those difficulties in mind.

Relevant background

[4]      The Marsden B power station was built at Marsden Point, near Whangarei. On 14 October 2008, Mighty River Power Ltd sold most of the assets comprising the

plant to UTL.   The parties intended that UTL would arrange to have the plant

1      High Court Rules, r 32.2. A standard form of freezing order is set out in Schedule 1, form G 38:

see r 32.6.

2      Arbitration Act 1996, First Schedule, arts 8 and 9. See, generally, Pathak v Tourism Transport

Ltd [2002] 3 NZLR 681 (HC).

dismantled, transport the component parts to India for reconstruction in that country and sell any remaining scrap in New Zealand.

[5]      UTL entered into a contract with SPI on 14…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read South Pacific Industrial Ltd v United Telecoms Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 688
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

South Pacific Industrial Ltd (SPI) applied to the High Court of New Zealand for an order restraining United Telecoms Ltd (UTL) from removing most of its New Zealand assets to India and remitting the proceeds of sale of others to that country. SPI claimed it was owed $2.5 million in respect of additional costs incurred in dismantling a power station. The contract between the parties contained a dispute resolution process culminating in arbitration. SPI sought to protect its ability to enforce any arbitral award it may obtain in New Zealand. The court held that SPI had a good arguable case on its substantive claim, that there were assets within New Zealand that could be subject to a freezing order, and that UTL's conduct in dealing with the proceeds of sale of scrap gave rise to a real risk that a judgment or award in favour of SPI would remain unsatisfied. The court declined to grant a freezing order in respect of the assets that UTL intended to ship to India, as SPI's undertaking as to damages would be insufficient to cover the losses UTL would incur if prevented from doing so. However, the court made interim orders prohibiting UTL from dealing with the scrap material remaining in New Zealand and requiring all proceeds of sale of scrap that had not been remitted to India to be paid into the trust account of UTL's solicitors. The application for a freezing order was adjourned for further argument.

The court indicated that costs should follow the event and would be awarded on a 2B basis, together with reasonable disbursements, in favour of SPI and to certify for second counsel.