Smith v New Zealand Parole Board

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA238/2018
 [2018] NZCA 295

BETWEEN

PHILLIP JOHN SMITH
Applicant

AND

NEW ZEALAND PAROLE BOARD
Respondent

Counsel:

Applicant in person
M S Smith for Respondent

Judgment:
(On the papers)

7 August 2018 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J
(Review of Registrar’s Decision)

AThe application for review of the Deputy Registrar’s decision refusing to dispense with security for costs is declined.

BSecurity for costs in the sum of $6,600 must be paid into Court by 28 August 2018.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Introduction

  1. Mr Smith applies for review of the Deputy Registrar’s decision to decline to dispense with security for costs on Mr Smith’s appeal. 

Background

  1. Mr Smith appeals against a decision of Simon France J in the High Court dated 7 May 2018 dismissing Mr Smith’s application for judicial review.[1]  Mr Smith had applied for judicial review in respect of a decision by the respondent, the Parole Board, declining Mr Smith parole. 

  2. Simon France J held that the Parole Board had considered all relevant considerations.[2]  Simon France J accepted that proportionality was relevant to parole decisions, but declined to make a declaration to that effect.[3]  He reasoned that the Parole Act 2002 “inherently involves a proportionality assessment”, displacing the procedural formalities of an inquiry pursuant to s 5 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.[4]  On the facts, the Parole Board “did undertake a proportionality assessment” pursuant to the scheme of the Parole Act.[5] 

    [2]At [32].

    [3]At [49].

    [4]At [45].

    [5]At [37]–[39].

  3. Mr Smith filed a notice of appeal against that decision.  Security for costs was fixed at $6600.  On 17 May 2018, Mr Smith applied to dispense with security for costs, on the basis that he is impecunious, and the appeal has merit and raises a question of public importance (being the application of s 5 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act in the parole context). The Deputy Registrar declined the application on 27 June 2018.  

  4. Mr Smith now applies for review of the Deputy Registrar’s decision under r 7(2) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.  He relies on the following grounds:

    (a)He is impecunious (in fact, insolvent) and is unable to pay security for costs;

    (b)He has been successful in all applications he has brought before the High Court as a self-represented litigant, other than the judgment under appeal; and

    (c)The appeal has a strong prospect of success.

Analysis

  1. The relevant principles are well-established.  The default position is that security for costs should be provided in relation to an appeal to this Court.[6]  Departure from that principle is exceptional.[7]  Security for costs should only be dispensed with if it is right to require the respondent to defend the judgment under challenge without the protection as to costs that the security provides.[8]

Impecuniosity

[6]Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, r 35(2). 

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v New Zealand Parole Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 295
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the New Zealand Court of Appeal, Phillip John Smith sought a review of a decision by the Deputy Registrar to refuse his application to dispense with security for costs in his appeal against a decision of the New Zealand Parole Board. Smith's application for judicial review in the High Court was dismissed, and he now appeals against that decision. The Deputy Registrar had declined Smith's application to dispense with security for costs, which was set at $6,600. Smith argues that he is impecunious and that the appeal has merit and raises a question of public importance. The court had to determine whether the Deputy Registrar's decision to not dispense with security for costs was correct.

The court considered the principles governing security for costs, noting that the default position is that security for costs should be provided. Departure from this principle is exceptional. The court examined whether Smith could show he was impecunious, and found that he had not provided evidence of his inability to pay. The court also considered the merits of the appeal, noting that the costs of the appeal outweighed the benefits. The appeal's primary objective was to challenge the High Court's finding that proportionality in the parole context does not engage section 5 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, which was unlikely to succeed. Other grounds of appeal were also unlikely to be successful. The court also noted that Smith had not applied for legal aid, which would have subjected the appeal to a cost-benefit analysis. The court concluded that it was not appropriate to require the Parole Board to defend the judgment without the protection of security for costs.

The Court of Appeal declined the application for review of the Deputy Registrar's decision. Smith was required to pay security for costs in the sum of $6,600 into Court by 28 August 2018.

Background

Background to the litigation

Phillip John Smith appeals a decision of the High Court dismissing his application for judicial review of a decision by the New Zealand Parole Board declining him parole. Simon France J held that the Parole Board had considered all relevant considerations, including proportionality, as required by the Parole Act 2002, and dismissed the application. Mr Smith filed a notice of appeal against that decision, seeking to appeal on the basis of impecuniosity, a strong prospect of success, and the public importance of the issues raised. Security for costs was fixed at $6,600. On 17 May 2018, Mr Smith applied to dispense with security for costs, on the basis that he is impecunious, and the appeal has merit and raises a question of public importance. The Deputy Registrar declined the application on 27 June 2018.

Mr Smith filed a notice of appeal against the High Court decision dismissing his application for judicial review. The Court of Appeal set security for costs at $6,600. Mr Smith applied to dispense with security for costs, which was declined by the Deputy Registrar on 27 June 2018. Mr Smith then applied for review of the Deputy Registrar’s decision under r 7(2) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Should security for costs be dispensed with on the basis that Mr Smith is impecunious?
2. Should security for costs be dispensed with on the basis that the appeal has merit and raises a question of public importance?
3. Are the costs of the appeal outweighed by the benefits of the appeal?

Held
1. The court declined the application for review of the Deputy Registrar’s decision refusing to dispense with security for costs.
2. Security for costs in the sum of $6,600 must be paid into Court by 28 August 2018.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the principles applicable to dispensing with security for costs, noting that the default position requires security to be provided. Departure from this principle is exceptional and should only occur if it is right to require the respondent to defend the judgment under challenge without the protection as to costs that the security provides. The Court emphasised that impecuniosity alone does not justify dispensing with security for costs and that the decision should be guided by whether a reasonable and solvent litigant would reasonably wish to proceed with the appeal.

In this case, the Court found that Mr Smith's appeal did not meet the criteria for dispensing with security for costs. While Mr Smith claimed to be impecunious, he did not provide sufficient evidence to support this claim. More critically, the Court determined that the costs of the appeal outweighed the benefits. The appeal, which primarily sought a declaration that the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act applies in the parole context, had minimal chances of success and, if unsuccessful, Mr Smith would be liable for significant costs. The Court also considered other grounds of appeal and found them to have little chance of success.

The Court further noted that Mr Smith had not applied for legal aid, which might have subjected the appeal to a cost-benefit analysis. Additionally, while there was some public interest in the appeal's outcome, the Court concluded that the costs of the appeal outweighed the benefits, making it inappropriate to dispense with security for costs. Thus, the Court upheld the Deputy Registrar's decision not to dispense with security for costs.