IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
CIV-2013-404-4750 [2014] NZHC 1179
BETWEEN VINCENT ROSS SIEMER
Plaintiff
AND
REGISTRAR, SUPREME COURT First Defendant
MINISTRY OF JUSTICE Second Defendant
Hearing: 7 April 2014 Appearances:
The plaintiff in person (by audio link) B Keith for defendants
Judgment:
29 May 2014
JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J
Introduction
[1] The plaintiff, Mr Siemer, has commenced these proceedings to judicially review a decision of the Registrar of the Supreme Court declining him access to Court documents. The first and second defendants have applied on notice to strike out those proceedings. They do so on the basis that this Court has no jurisdiction to consider those proceedings.
Factual background
[2] In considering this strike-out application, I accept as true the factual claims made by Mr Siemer in his application for judicial review.
[3] On 2 October 2013 Mr Siemer emailed the Registrar. In that email he said:
SIEMER v REGISTRAR, SUPREME COURT [2014] NZHC 1179 [29 May 2014]
Hi Gordon,
I am launching newzealandsupremecourt.co.nz, which is merely a website with links to the Supreme Court Judgments, transcripts and submissions. My question is how can I obtain copies of the legal submissions, including the applications for leave?
[4] The Registrar (Mr Gordon Thatcher) replied: “I will take advice on this and get back to you”.
[5] Mr Siemer emailed again on 25 October 2013 asking for an update. The
Registrar replied by letter dated 30 October 2013 in the following terms:
Dear Mr Siemer,
I have now given full consideration to your email of 2 October 2013.
The courts judgments and the transcriptions of its hearings are in the public domain, so you are able to link to them from the Courtsofnz website.
You also seek copies of applications for leave to appeal and any submissions filed.
There are no regulations which permit a search of this courts files. This is unlike the other Higher Courts which have a specific enabling regulation – see Court of Appeal (Access to Court Documents) Rules 2009, by way of example.
Because of this I am unable to make available copies of applications for leave to appeal and the submissions lodged.
Yours faithfully
(Signed)
Gordon Thatcher
REGISTRAR
[6] That same day Mr Siemer made a request of the Registrar to access submissions filed in the proceedings Harrison v Auckland District Health Board.1
The Registrar declined to provide that access to Mr Siemer, referring to his letter of that day.
Mr Siemer’s judicial review application
[7] Mr Siemer challenges the Registrar’s decision to decline him access to Court documents as requested on the following grounds:
(a) The decision was based on an error in law. There was no lawful basis for a “blanket” prohibition against access to public court documents of the type effected by the Registrar’s letter. Reliance upon there being an absence of regulations which permit a search of the Supreme Court’s files was an error in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Siemer v Registrar, Supreme Court and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 1179
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key legal issue was whether the High Court had jurisdiction to review the Registrar's decision. The defendants relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Mafart v Television New Zealand Ltd, which held that control of court records was a matter within the inherent power of each court. The defendants argued that actions of the registrars of higher courts could only be challenged by review by one or more judges of that court.
The Court held that the defendants' application to strike out must succeed. The Court found that the Registrar's decision to decline Mr Siemer's request was properly reviewable by a Supreme Court judge as part of the Supreme Court's inherent supervisory powers. The Court also found that judicial review was not available to challenge the actions of the higher courts. While Mr Siemer's substantive concerns about the Registrar's decision were valid, the appropriate remedy was to apply to the Supreme Court to review that decision. The Court declined to award indemnity costs to the defendants.
In summary, the High Court found that it lacked jurisdiction to review the Registrar's decision and struck out Mr Siemer's proceedings. The appropriate remedy was for Mr Siemer to apply to the Supreme Court to review the Registrar's decision.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi