Mafart v Television New Zealand Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA92/05

BETWEENALAIN MICHAEL YVES MAFART AND DOMINIQUE ANGELA FRANCOISE PRIEUR


Appellants

ANDTELEVISION NEW ZEALAND LIMITED


Respondent

Hearing:13 June 2005

Court:Anderson  P, Chambers and O'Regan JJ

Counsel:G P Curry for Appellants


W Akel for Respondent

Judgment:4 August 2005 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The substantive appeal is dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

B        Costs to the respondent of $6,000, together with usual disbursements.

REASONS

Anderson P  [1]

Chambers and O’Regan JJ  [47]

ANDERSON P

Introduction

[1]       On 10 July 1985, French espionage agents, using limpet mines, sank the vessel Rainbow Warrior at its mooring in Auckland Harbour.  Mr Fernando Pereira, a crew member of the vessel, was killed.

[2]       Within a fortnight two of the agents, the present appellants, were arrested and charged with the homicide.  Following a committal proceeding they pleaded guilty to manslaughter and, on 22 November 1985, they were sentenced in the High Court at Auckland to 10 years imprisonment.  The Auckland Registry references for the sentencing files are R v Mafart S89/85 and R v Prieur S90/85. 

[3]       The committal proceedings were recorded on videotape for administrative reasons and, it seems, to provide the District Court Judge with a personal record of the proceeding.  The tapes, along with copies, became the subject of a consent order of the High Court, made by Greig J – see Mafart and Prieur v Gilbert and BCNZ HC AK CP261/86 15 October 1987.  That order characterised the video tapes as documents within the meaning of s 182 Summary Proceedings Act 1957, and as such they constituted part of the committal record. 

[4]       The High Court further ordered that the tapes be transmitted to the Registrar of the High Court as part of the record of the High Court in R v Mafart and R v Prieur in S98/85 and S90/85 “upon and subject to the provisions of the Criminal Proceedings (Search of Court Records) Rules 1974 and subject to the further directions” of the High Court. 

[5]       A procedural constraint was placed on the searching, inspecting or copying of all or any part of the record of the committal proceedings.  The constraining order is in the following terms:

4.FOR the purposes of Rule 2(4) and (5) of the Criminal Proceedings (Search of Court Records) Rules 1974 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DIRECTED that:

(i)Any application by any person for leave to search, inspect or copy all or any part of the record of the committal proceedings referred to in this Order and held by this Honourable Court shall prior to any consideration thereof being made be notified by the Registrar of this Court to the applicants in these proceedings by their solicitors, Messrs Russell McVeagh McKenzie Bartleet & Co., Solicitors, Auckland

(ii)No order granting leave to search, inspect or copy all or any part of the committal proceedings referred to in this order shall be made other than by a Judge of this Honourable Court and no such order shall be made…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mafart v Television New Zealand Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NZCA 197
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, the case of Mafart v Television New Zealand Ltd involved an appeal by espionage agents, Alain Mafart and Dominique Prieur, against a decision of Simon France J in the High Court. The agents sought to prevent Television New Zealand Limited from obtaining access to videotapes of their committal proceedings for the Rainbow Warrior bombing case, which they argued would infringe on their privacy. The legal issues centered on the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal to hear the appeal against the High Court's decision, specifically whether the decision to grant leave to search and copy the criminal records of the court was a judicial or administrative decision, and if it was appealable under the Judicature Act 1908 or the Crimes Act.

The Court of Appeal found that the decision to grant leave under the Criminal Proceedings (Search of Court Records) Rules 1974 was not an appealable decision. The Court held that such decisions are administrative in nature, akin to decisions regarding access to court buildings or courtrooms, and not "judgments, decrees or orders" as described in the Judicature Act. Furthermore, the Court of Appeal concluded that even if the decision was judicial in nature, it would still not be appealable as it related to criminal proceedings. The Court referenced previous decisions that established a long-standing distinction between civil and criminal appeals, and noted that the Crimes Act does not provide for appeals from decisions made in criminal proceedings. Consequently, the substantive appeal was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, and the respondent was awarded costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established