Shivneel Shahil Kumar v The Queen, and Bryne Permal v The Queen

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 86/2016
[2016] NZSC 147
BETWEEN

SHIVNEEL SHAHIL KUMAR
Applicant

AND

THE QUEEN
Respondent

SC 87/2016 

BETWEEN

BRYNE PERMAL
Applicant

AND

THE QUEEN
Respondent

Court:

William Young, Arnold and O'Regan JJ

Counsel:

R M Mansfield and S R Lack for Applicant SC 86/2016
I A Jayanandan and P L Borich for Applicant SC 87/2016
Z R Johnston for Respondent

Judgment:

7 November 2016

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The applications for leave to appeal are dismissed.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

  1. The applicants, Mr Kumar and Mr Permal, were found guilty of murdering Shalvin Prasad following a trial before Venning J and a jury.  Both were convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum period of 17 years’ imprisonment.[1]  The Court of Appeal having rejected their appeals,[2] they seek leave to appeal to this Court.

    [2]Kumar v R [2016] NZCA 329 (Harrison, Simon France and Woolford JJ) [Kumar (CA)].

  2. Both applicants argue that the Court of Appeal was incorrect:

    (a)to hold that the Judge had not erred by leaving the Crown’s one transaction theory to the jury;

    (b)to find that there was a sufficient evidential foundation for the jury’s finding that, on the Crown’s one transaction theory, the applicants had assaulted the deceased with murderous intent before setting him alight; and

    (c)to hold that the trial Judge’s directions on the one transaction theory were correct and sufficient.

  3. In addition, Mr Permal argues that the Court of Appeal was wrong to find that the trial Judge’s directions on withdrawal were sufficient, and Mr Kumar argues that the trial Judge was wrong to find that the requirements of s 104 of the Sentencing Act 2002 were met.

  4. The factual background is well summarised in the Court of Appeal’s judgment[3] and we will not repeat it.  It is sufficient to say that Mr Prasad was rendered deeply unconscious and, while unconscious but still alive, was set on fire and died as a consequence.  The Crown alleged that the applicants intended to kill Mr Prasad but advanced two alternative factual bases – one was that they intended to kill him by setting him on fire; the other was that they had murderous intent when they assaulted him and setting him on fire was the last step in their enterprise (the “one transaction” theory).  On the one transaction theory, the Crown alleged that the applicants wanted to gain access to Mr Prasad’s money and were prepared to use force and, if necessary, to kill Mr Prasad to do so; while carrying put their plan they assaulted Mr Prasad so severely that they mistakenly thought they had killed him, and then did kill him by setting him on fire.

    [3]At [6]–[20].

  1. We consider that the only ground of those set out in [2] above that arguably raises a question of general or public importance is that in [2](a).  In Thabo Meli v R,[4] the Privy Council upheld convictions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shivneel Shahil Kumar v The Queen, and Bryne Permal v The Qu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZSC 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of New Zealand, the case of Shivneel Shahil Kumar v The Queen and Bryne Permal v The Queen involved two applicants, Mr Kumar and Mr Permal, who had been found guilty of murdering Shalvin Prasad and were sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum period of 17 years. The applicants sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court after their appeals were rejected by the Court of Appeal. The primary legal issues for the Court to decide were whether the Court of Appeal was correct in its decisions that the trial Judge had not erred in leaving the Crown’s one transaction theory to the jury, that there was a sufficient evidential foundation for the jury’s findings, and that the trial Judge’s directions on the one transaction theory were correct and sufficient. Additionally, Mr Permal argued that the Court of Appeal was wrong to find that the trial Judge’s directions on withdrawal were sufficient.

The Court held that the only ground that arguably raised a question of general or public importance was whether the Court of Appeal was correct to hold that the Judge had not erred by leaving the Crown’s one transaction theory to the jury. The Court agreed with the Court of Appeal’s interpretation of Thabo Meli v R, which held that it was not necessary for the Crown to prove an antecedent plan that extended to and incorporated commission of the fatal act. The Court also found no risk of a substantial miscarriage of justice in relation to the other grounds raised by the applicants. The applications for leave to appeal were dismissed.

In summary, the Supreme Court upheld the Court of Appeal’s decision and dismissed the applications for leave to appeal by Mr Kumar and Mr Permal. The Court found that there was no risk of a substantial miscarriage of justice and that the Court of Appeal’s interpretation of the one transaction theory was correct.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established