Ross v Richards

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

NOTE: ANY REPORT OF THIS PROCEEDING MUST COMPLY WITH SS 11B, 11C AND 11D OF THE FAMILY COURT ACT 1980. FOR FURTHER INFORMATION, PLEASE SEE

https:// THIS IS AN ANONYMISED VERSION OF A JUDGMENT AND MAY BE

PUBLISHED IN THIS FORM.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2022-404-000247

[2023] NZHC 797

UNDER the Care of Children Act 2004

IN THE MATTER OF

an appeal against the decision of the Family Court at Auckland on 25 January 2022

BETWEEN

JOHN ROSS

Appellant

AND

CATHERINE RICHARDS

Respondent

Hearing: 28 March 2023

Appearance:

Appellant self-represented

P Le’au’anae for Respondent
G M Webster as Lawyer for Child

Judgment:

17 April 2023


JUDGMENT (ANONYMISED) OF VAN BOHEMEN J

[Reasons for decision]


This anonymised judgment was delivered by me on 17 April 2023 at 2:00 pm Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

……………………………..

Counsel/Solicitors:

P Le’au’anae, Auckland G M Webster, Auckland Copy to: Appellant

ROSS v RICHARDS [2023] NZHC 797 [17 April 2023]

[1]                 John Ross appeals the decision of Judge J G Adams given in the Family Court at  Manukau  on  25  January  2022  granting  parenting  orders  in  relation   to Helen Richards, the daughter of Mr Ross and Catherine Richards.1

[2]In his decision, Judge Adams granted:

(a)a parenting order for day to day care of Helen to Ms Richards, except when Helen is in the day to day care of Mr Ross; and

(b)a parenting order for day to day care of Helen to Mr Ross for alternate weekends during the school term from 4.30 pm Friday to 4.30 pm Sunday, and for half the school holidays – with the long holidays being alternate weeks, arranged  so  Helen  spends  Christmas  Day  with  Mr Ross.

[3]I heard Mr Ross’ appeal on 28 March 2023.

[4]                 After hearing from Mr Ross, who is self-represented, counsel for Ms Richards, Mr Le’au’anae, and counsel for the child, Mr Webster, I advised Mr Ross that I intended to dismiss his appeal. However, having heard from Mr Webster that Helen wished the orders made by Judge Adams to be varied to increase the time she spent with Mr Ross, and from Mr Le’au’anae that Ms Richards was prepared to consent to the variations that Helen had indicated to Mr Webster, I offered Mr Ross the opportunity to resolve his appeal and to vary Judge Adams’ orders by consent. I adjourned the hearing to give Mr Ross and counsel the opportunity to agree on the terms of varied orders.

[5]                 In the event, Mr Ross refused to agree to the variations which Helen had indicated to Mr Webster and insisted on more extensive variations that would have equalised the amount of time that Helen spent with him. Ms Richards would not consent to vary the orders to that extent at that time.


1      Richards v Ross [2022] NZFC 611.

[6]                 Accordingly. I dismissed Mr Ross’ appeal and said I would issue my reasons as soon as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ross v Richards and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 797
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

John Ross appeals the decision of the Family Court at Manukau on 25 January 2022 which granted parenting orders in relation to Helen Richards, the daughter of Mr Ross and Catherine Richards. In his decision, Judge J G Adams granted: (a) a parenting order for day to day care of Helen to Ms Richards, except when Helen is in the day to day care of Mr Ross; and (b) a parenting order for day to day care of Helen to Mr Ross for alternate weekends during the school term from 4.30 pm Friday to 4.30 pm Sunday, and for half the school holidays – with the long holidays being alternate weeks, arranged so Helen spends Christmas Day with Mr Ross. The appeal was heard on 28 March 2023. After hearing from Mr Ross, who is self-represented, counsel for Ms Richards, Mr Le’au’anae, and counsel for the child, Mr Webster, I advised Mr Ross that I intended to dismiss his appeal. However, having heard from Mr Webster that Helen wished the orders made by Judge Adams to be varied to increase the time she spent with Mr Ross, and from Mr Le’au’anae that Ms Richards was prepared to consent to the variations that Helen had indicated to Mr Webster, I offered Mr Ross the opportunity to resolve his appeal and to vary Judge Adams’ orders by consent. I adjourned the hearing to give Mr Ross and counsel the opportunity to agree on the terms of varied orders. In the event, Mr Ross refused to agree to the variations which Helen had indicated to Mr Webster and insisted on more extensive variations that would have equalised the amount of time that Helen spent with him. Ms Richards would not consent to vary the orders to that extent at that time. Accordingly, I dismissed Mr Ross’ appeal and said I would issue my reasons as soon as possible. The grounds of Mr Ross’ appeal challenge the Family Court’s jurisdiction to grant a final parenting order in favour of one parent where the parties are migrants on temporary visas; allege unspecified breaches of the Care of Children Act, the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 and the principles of natural justice; allege predetermination, partiality, irrationality, prejudice, defamation and the suborning of perjury on the part of Judge Adams; allege failures by Judge Adams in not ascertaining Police reports on Helen’s circumstances when Helen was taken from Mr Ross, in denying Mr Ross’ request for a psychological evaluation of Helen, and in using an improper procedure when interviewing Helen; and allege failures by Judge Adams in his assessment of the evidence and in not considering the effects of the separation of Mr Ross from Helen, which altered the status quo against Mr Ross and meant that Mr Ross was disadvantaged when the Court was considering what was in Helen’s best interests. I dismissed Mr Ross’ appeal. An appeal under s 143 of the Care of Children Act is a general appeal. Accordingly, the principles set out by the Supreme Court in Austin, Nichols & Co Inc v Stichting Lodestar apply. This Court is free to reach its own view on whether parenting orders should have been made in the terms set out in the Family Court’s orders, based on the evidence before the Family Court and any further evidence admitted on appeal. However, the appellant bears the onus of satisfying the appeal court that the Family Court was wrong. Mr Ross has not discharged that onus. It is clear that Judge Adams’ first and paramount consideration throughout his decision was on Helen’s welfare and best interests in her particular circumstances, as required by s 4 of the Care of Children Act. It is equally plain that Judge Adams had regard to the principles in s 5 of the Act and to Helen’s views as required by s 6 of the Act. Mr Ross’ criticisms of the Judge’s judgment relate largely to the Judge’s findings and observations about Mr Ross’ conduct and circumstances. I consider those findings and observations were open to the Judge on the basis of the evidence before him. I also consider they were appropriate and relevant to the Judge’s assessment of what would be in Helen’s welfare and best interests. I do not accept Mr Ross’ attempts to reinterpret the evidence. I do not accept that the Judge failed to remain impartial or acted against Mr Ross’ interests. The Judge acknowledged that Helen’s relationship with her father was important to her and that a mix of activities with both her parents was beneficial. As with much of the case presented by Mr Ross, those aspects of Mr Ross’ submissions were focused on Mr Ross’ views of his rights and responsibilities, were not objective or supported by independent evidence and took little account of Helen’s views or her welfare and best interests. There was no error in the Judge taking account of the family’s immigration situation. Where Helen and her parents were able to reside was directly relevant to Helen’s welfare and best interests. The Judge also proceeded on the basis that it was possible that both parents could remain in New Zealand. There was no error in the Judge’s assessment of the resources of the respective households. It is obvious that Ms Richards can provide a more stable and financially secure home for Helen. Mr Ross’ current situation is better than it was when Judge Adams made his decision. Mr Ross now has the right to reside in New Zealand and has access to WINZ benefits. He has also moved to rental accommodation in Whangaparāoa, which means he is closer to Helen and it is easier for her to be with him. However, these improvements in Mr Ross’ situation would not have persuaded me to reach a different conclusion from Judge Adams regarding the resources of the respective households. It remains the case that Ms Richards is in a much sounder position than Mr Ross in terms of their respective abilities to provide for Helen. Mr Ross’ criticisms of Judge Adams’ interview with Helen are without foundation. The Judge met with Helen in the company of her lawyer – which is standard practice. There was no requirement under the Care of Children Act for the Judge to obtain a psychological report just because Mr Ross said there should be one. In accordance with s 133 of the Act, the decision on whether such a report should be obtained was for the Judge to make, bearing in mind the criteria of which the Judge had to be satisfied under s 133(6). The Judge’s decision not to obtain a report before meeting with Helen was based on his assessment that it would delay the hearing by “many months”. In those circumstances, to seek a psychological report would not have been consistent with the statutory directions in s 133(6). Furthermore, on interviewing Helen, Judge Adams found he had “no cause to think that she had been coached, coerced or alienated by her mother”, and instead found that she was under “some emotional pressure from her father”. Mr Ross’ attempts to cast doubt on the validity of the views the Judge obtained from Helen have no credible basis. They suggest that Mr Ross finds it difficult to accept that Helen may have views that differ from his own. There is nothing in the Notes of Evidence that supports Mr Ross’ contention that Ms Richards was present at the Judge’s interview with Helen. Judge Adams’ recording of what Helen said to him about visiting Hindu temples in South Africa was factual and made

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.