Richard Zhao Lawyers Limited v Chen

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

-

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA293/2016
[2016] NZCA 540

BETWEEN

RICHARD ZHAO LAWYERS LIMITED
Appellant

AND

JIE PING CHEN
Respondent

CA502/2015

BETWEEN

RICHARD ZHAO LAWYERS LIMITED
First Appellant

RICHARD ZHAO
Second Appellant

AND

THE FAMILY COURT AT AUCKLAND
First Respondent

JIE PING CHEN
Second Respondent
Court:

Randerson, Wild and French JJ

Counsel:

F C Deliu and R Zhao for Appellants
P F Chambers for Respondent Chen

Judgment:

(On the papers)

17 November 2016 at 10.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe decision of Winkelmann J declining to grant the appellant’s application for dispensation of payment for security for costs is set aside.

BThe appellant’s application is remitted to the Registrar for consideration and determination.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by French J)

  1. Under r 35 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005 an appellant may apply to the Registrar for payment of security for costs to be dispensed with.  If the Registrar declines the application then the appellant may ask for a Judge of this Court to review the Registrar’s decision.

  2. The issue in this case is whether a single judge can determine a dispensation application in the first instance.

  3. It has arisen in the following context.

  4. On 22 July 2016 counsel for the appellant, Mr Deliu, applied to the Registrar under r 35 for dispensation from payment of security for costs in appeal CA293/2016.  Alternatively, he sought a reduction of the amount of security.

  5. Subsequently, Mr Deliu requested a conference call.  The reason for this request was that Mr Deliu wanted the appeal to be heard with another related appeal (CA502/2015) that had been scheduled for hearing on 29 September 2016.[1]  He also wanted an order that a hearing in the High Court be transcribed.

    [1]The appeal CA293/2016 is against judgments of Bell AJ dismissing a bankruptcy application, refusing to recall his judgment, and granting costs: Richard Zhao Lawyers Ltd v Jie Ping Chen [2016] NZHC 1134; Richard Zhao Lawyers Ltd v Jie Ping Chen HC Auckland CIV-2016-404-397, 10 June 2016 (Minute of Bell AJ); and Richard Zhao Lawyers Ltd v Jie Ping Chen HC Auckland CIV-2015-404-2086, 16 June 2016 (Minute of Bell AJ).  The appeal CA502/2015 is against a costs decision of Asher J in the High Court at Auckland: Richard Zhao Lawyers Ltd v Family Court at Auckland [2015] NZHC 1837.

  6. The conference call was duly convened on 9 September 2016 by Winkelmann J, who was the Judge presiding over the hearing of the related appeal.  Justice Winkelmann ordered the appeals be heard together but declined the application for a transcript.[2]

    [2]Richard Zhao Lawyers Ltd v Family Court at Auckland CA502/2015 and CA293/2016, 12 September 2016 [Minute 1 of Winkelmann J].

  7. During the course of the conference call Winkelmann J raised the issue of Mr Deliu’s application for dispensation from payment of security for costs.  After hearing from counsel, the Judge dismissed the application.  The main ground of the application was that security had already been paid in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Richard Zhao Lawyers Limited v Chen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 540
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand heard an appeal against a decision by Winkelmann J declining an application for dispensation of payment for security for costs in two related appeals. The appellants, Richard Zhao Lawyers Limited and Richard Zhao, sought the dispensation in relation to costs awarded to the respondents, Jie Ping Chen and the Family Court at Auckland, in proceedings that had originated in the High Court at Auckland. The Court of Appeal found that Winkelmann J did not have jurisdiction to determine the application for security for costs, as the application had already been made to the Registrar and had not been determined. As a result, the decision of Winkelmann J was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Registrar for consideration and determination.

The key legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether a single judge can determine a dispensation application in the first instance. The Court of Appeal found that under s 61A(1) of the Judicature Act, a single judge of the Court of Appeal may make incidental orders and give incidental directions, but only in circumstances where an application has not been made to the Registrar. In this case, an application had already been made to the Registrar, and it had not been determined. Therefore, Winkelmann J did not have jurisdiction to determine the application for security for costs. The Court of Appeal also noted that the arguments raised by the appellants about alleged breaches of natural justice were ill-founded, as the appellants had not appreciated that security for costs was inextricably entwined with the issue of the appeal being brought on for hearing at short notice.

The Court of Appeal found that the decision of Winkelmann J declining the application for dispensation of payment of security for costs was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Registrar for determination. The Court of Appeal did not consider it necessary to consider the arguments raised by the appellants about alleged breaches of natural justice, as it found that the appellants had not appreciated that security for costs was inextricably entwined with the issue of the appeal being brought on for hearing at short notice. The Court of Appeal also found that the appellants had been given an opportunity to be heard, and that they had made the application for dispensation and must have known the grounds for it and been ready to argue them.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two appeals by Richard Zhao Lawyers Limited against judgments of the High Court at Auckland. In appeal CA293/2016, Richard Zhao Lawyers Limited appeals against the dismissal of a bankruptcy application, refusal to recall a judgment, and the granting of costs. In appeal CA502/2015, the firm appeals against a costs decision of Asher J in the High Court at Auckland. Counsel for the appellant, Mr. Deliu, applied to the Registrar under rule 35 for dispensation from payment of security for costs in appeal CA293/2016, alternatively seeking a reduction of the amount of security. Mr. Deliu requested a conference call to discuss the appeal alongside a related appeal (CA502/2015) and an order for a transcript of a hearing in the High Court. Winkelmann J convened the conference call, ordered the appeals to be heard together, and declined the application for a transcript. During the call, Winkelmann J dismissed the application for dispensation, considering the commonality of issues insufficient to justify reducing or dispensing with payment of security for costs. Mr. Deliu later questioned the judge's jurisdiction, and it was agreed that the matter could be dealt with on the papers by a panel of three judges.

The case came before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand as an appeal against decisions of the High Court at Auckland. In CA293/2016, the appeal was against judgments dismissing a bankruptcy application, refusing to recall a judgment, and granting costs. In CA502/2015, the appeal was against a costs decision in the High Court. Counsel for the appellant applied to the Registrar for dispensation from payment of security for costs, which was declined by Winkelmann J. Mr. Deliu questioned the judge's jurisdiction to determine the application and complained of insufficient notice that security for costs would be argued. A further conference call was convened, and it was agreed that the matter could be dealt with on the papers by a panel of three judges under section 61A(2) of the Judicature Act 1908.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a single judge can determine a dispensation application in the first instance under rule 35 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.
2. Whether the decision of Winkelmann J declining the application for dispensation of payment for security for costs should be set aside and the matter remitted to the Registrar for consideration and determination.

Held
1. A single judge does not have jurisdiction to determine a dispensation application in the first instance under rule 35 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.
2. The decision of Winkelmann J declining the application for dispensation of payment for security for costs is set aside, and the matter is remitted to the Registrar for consideration and determination.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered whether a single judge could determine a dispensation application for the payment of security for costs under rule 35 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005. The case arose from an application by the appellant, Richard Zhao Lawyers Limited, seeking dispensation from payment of security for costs in relation to an appeal against judgments in the High Court. Initially, the Registrar declined the application, and the appellant then sought a review by a judge of the Court of Appeal. The matter was heard by Winkelmann J, who dismissed the application. The appellant subsequently argued that Winkelmann J lacked jurisdiction to make the decision.

The Court held that Winkelmann J did not have the jurisdiction to determine the application for security for costs because there was an extant application to the Registrar that had not been determined. The Court referred to the provisions of section 61A(1) of the Judicature Act 1908, which allow a single judge to make incidental orders and directions, but only in the absence of an application to the Registrar. In Siemer v Stiassny, the Supreme Court had suggested that the powers under section 61A(1) could be invoked to alter the security for costs where no application had been made to the Registrar. The Court concluded that, given the existing application to the Registrar, Winkelmann J's decision was beyond his jurisdiction.

The Court also dismissed the appellant's arguments about alleged breaches of natural justice, noting that the appellant had requested the appeal to be brought on at short notice and should have anticipated that security for costs would be an issue. The Court found that the appellant had been given an opportunity to be heard.

Consequently, the Court set aside the decision of Winkelmann J and remitted the matter to the Registrar for consideration and determination, in line with the referral made under section 61A(2) of the Judicature Act 1908. This decision highlights the procedural boundaries within which single judges operate when handling applications under rule 35 and underscores the importance of following established processes for such applications.