Rebnik Properties Limited v Dobbs

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV 2015-404-000964

[2020] NZHC 2187

BETWEEN

REBNIK PROPERTIES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

TROY JOHN DOBBS

First Defendant

AND

ALUMINIUM REPAIRS LIMITED

Second Defendant

CIV 2015-404-001602

BETWEEN

ALUMINIUM REPAIRS LIMITED
First Plaintiff

AND

TROY JOHN DOBBS

Second Plaintiff

AND

MICHAEL GRANT RING

Defendant

Hearing: 24 August 2020

Appearances:

D R Bigio QC and A J Steel for the Plaintiff/Defendants

C R Andrews and K T O’Halloran for the Defendants/Plaintiffs

Judgment:

26 August 2020


JUDGMENT OF CAMPBELL J


This judgment was delivered by me on 26 August 2020 at 3.00pm Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………………

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

D R Bigio QC, Shortland Chambers, Auckland A J Steel, Barrister, Auckland

McVeagh Fleming, Auckland

REBNIK PROPERTIES LIMITED v DOBBS [2020] NZHC 2187 [26 August 2020]

Introduction

[1]                 These two proceedings arise out of construction work carried out by Mr Dobbs (he says on behalf of his company Aluminium Repairs Ltd (ARL)) on a house that belonged to Mr Ring. Mr Ring says that Mr Dobbs overcharged him.

[2]                 In the first proceeding Mr Ring’s assignee, Rebnik Properties Ltd (Rebnik), sues Mr Dobbs (or ARL in the alternative) for the overcharging. In the second proceeding ARL (or Mr Dobbs in the alternative) sues Mr Ring for payment on the last two invoices rendered to Mr Ring (which Mr Ring refused to pay).

[3]                 I will refer to Rebnik and Mr Ring as the plaintiffs, and Mr Dobbs and ARL as the defendants.

Defendants’ application for leave to have supplementary briefs received

[4]                 On 14 August 2020 the defendants applied (by memorandum) for leave under r 9.8 of the High Court Rules 2016 to have two supplementary briefs of evidence received at trial. One brief is by Mr Dobbs, served 4 August 2020. The other brief is by an expert quantity surveyor, Mr Hanlon, engaged by the defendants. It was served 7 August 2020. The defendants’ application was supported by an unsworn1 affidavit from Mr Dobbs addressing the delay in serving the two briefs.

[5]                 The plaintiffs opposed the application, save  for  paragraphs  61  to  64  of  Mr Dobbs’ brief. The plaintiffs served two affidavits in support of their notice of opposition. The affidavits were from two quantity surveying experts that the plaintiffs had engaged, Mr Johnson and Mr Weir, each of whom had earlier provided expert briefs. The import of their affidavits was that they would not have sufficient time to review all the new material in the supplementary briefs before trial, nor could a joint expert report be completed before trial if the new material was to be considered.

[6]                 The trial started on 24 August 2020. After the plaintiffs’ opening, I heard submissions on the defendants’ application. The submissions were detailed


1      It was unsworn because of the then COVID-19 Alert Level 3 restrictions. The plaintiffs took no issue with this.

(necessarily so). They took much of the first day.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rebnik Properties Limited v Dobbs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 2187
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rebnik Properties Limited v Dobbs involves a dispute between Mr Ring and Mr Dobbs, with Mr Ring suing Mr Dobbs for overcharging related to construction work carried out by Mr Dobbs. The proceedings were consolidated into two cases: one where Rebnik Properties Ltd, as Mr Ring’s assignee, sued Mr Dobbs or Aluminium Repairs Ltd (ARL) for overcharging, and another where ARL sued Mr Ring for unpaid invoices. The court had to decide on an application by the defendants for leave to submit supplementary briefs of evidence at trial, which was opposed by the plaintiffs. The legal issues involved interpreting Rule 9.8 of the High Court Rules 2016 regarding supplementary briefs and balancing the prejudice to the parties if the briefs were or were not allowed. The court considered the procedural history, delays in serving the briefs, and the potential prejudice to the plaintiffs if the briefs were admitted. It found that while Mr Dobbs’ supplementary brief could be received with certain exclusions, Mr Hanlon's brief required further consideration, and the court deferred its decision pending further evidence. The plaintiffs were awarded costs for the application.

The reasoning behind the court's decision focused on the discretion provided by Rule 9.8(2) of the High Court Rules, which allows a judge to decide whether to accept supplementary briefs based on the balance of justice. The court noted that the defendants had delayed in serving the briefs and did not adequately explain the reasons for the delay. However, the court acknowledged that the prejudice to the plaintiffs was a significant factor in determining whether to admit the evidence. The court concluded that Mr Dobbs’ supplementary brief could be received with some exclusions, as the plaintiffs would not be unduly prejudiced by its late submission. However, the court deferred its decision on Mr Hanlon’s brief, as it required further assessment of the potential prejudice and the nature of the expert evidence. The court awarded costs to the plaintiffs for the application.