Re JSB (A Child) HC Auckland Civ-2004-404-3116

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

PURSUANT TO SECTION 139 OF THE CARE OF CHILDREN ACT 2004

ANY REPORT OF THIS PROCEEDING MUST COMPLY WITH SECTIONS

11B-11D OF THE FAMILY COURTS ACT 1980

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2004-404-3116

IN THE MATTER OF     JSB (A CHILD)

BETWEEN  CHIEF EXECUTIVE, MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

Plaintiff

ANDTS AND SB Defendants

Hearing:         15 October 2009

Counsel:         A Brown, Lawyer for Child

E Parsons, Counsel to Assist the Court
R F von Keisenberg for Defendants
C M Earl for HB
C R Gwyn for Attorney-General

L M Fong for Chief Executive (Court's agent) G Bingham for BOP District Health Board

Judgment:      4 November 2009

Reasons:        16 November 2009

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT OF HEATH J

Solicitors/Counsel:

A Brown, PO Box 13284, Tauranga

Crown Law Office, PO Box 2858, Wellington

BOP District Health Board, Private Bag 12024, Tauranga (G Bingham) E Parsons, PO Box 46 318, Herne Bay, Auckland

R F von Keisenberg, PO Box 42258, Orakei, Auckland

C M Earl, PO Box 9337, Hamilton

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT V TS AND SB HC AK CIV 2004-404-3116

4 November 2009

Contents

Introduction  [1] Administration of the Court’s guardianship of JSB  [17] Potential sources of jurisdiction  [25] Is there jurisdiction under the Care of Children Act 2004?  [28] Can the inherent jurisdiction be invoked?  [49] Should the discretion to make an order be exercised?  [57] Conclusion  [85]

Introduction

[1]      On 29 April 2004, TS and SB celebrated the birth of their baby boy JSB. Less than two months later, on 15 June 2004, JSB’s brain was severely damaged as a result of injuries inflicted deliberately by his mother, TS.   Now aged five years, JSB’s only ability to respond to other human beings is by touch.

[2]      On 18 June 2004, JSB was placed under the guardianship of this Court.  The order was made under the Guardianship Act 1968 (the 1968 Act).   The Court appointed  the  Chief  Executive  of  the  Department  of  Child,  Youth  and  Family Services (the Chief Executive) as the Court’s general agent.  JSB remains subject to the Court’s guardianship.

[3]      TS was prosecuted for causing grievous bodily harm to JSB, with intent to do so.  During the course of a jury trial, she entered a plea of guilty to the charge.  TS was sentenced, on 23 September 2005, to a term of imprisonment of six years.  The underlying facts on which the sentence was based are set out fully in a report of my sentencing notes: (2005) 22 CRNZ 126 (HC).

[4]      While in prison TS married JSB’s father, SB.   TS has since been released from prison, on parole.  She and SB are living in the lower North Island.  As a term of her parole, TS is forbidden from having contact with JSB.

[5]      In late August 2009, JSB suffered a medical episode that gave clinicians serious cause for concern that he may die imminently.  JSB was in hospital and was struggling…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re JSB (A Child) HC Auckland Civ-2004-404-3116 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZHC 2054
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved a five-year-old child, JSB, who was under the guardianship of the High Court of New Zealand due to severe brain injuries inflicted by his mother, TS. The primary dispute was over the potential conflict between the biological parents and JSB's paternal grandmother (HB) regarding the disposition of his remains if he were to die. The Court had to decide whether it had the jurisdiction to make an order, in relation to a living child under its guardianship, that would only come into effect after death. If jurisdiction existed, the Court also had to determine whether any order should be made. The Court held that there was no jurisdiction under the Care of Children Act 2004 for either the Family Court or the High Court to make orders as guardians of a ward, which would take effect only after death. However, the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court could be invoked to make such an order if it was required to protect the best interests of the child after death. The Court exercised its discretion to make an order to create a mechanism to resolve any dispute promptly upon death, without predetermining arrangements to be followed on JSB’s death. The orders made included appointing the Lawyer for the Child as a custodian of JSB’s body with power to deal with relevant authorities in respect of JSB’s death and to consult with all relevant family members to determine whether any conflicts remained for resolution.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established