R v B HC Tauranga Cri-2012-463-54

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CRI-2012-463-54 [2013] NZHC 2415

THE QUEEN

v

B

Hearing: 19-23, 26-28 August 2012

Appearances:

RW Jenson for Crown
T Rickard-Simms for Accused

Ruling:

20 August 2013

Reasons:

17 September 2013

JUDGMENT (NO. 1) OF TOOGOOD J

[Reasons for ruling on application to adduce propensity evidence]

This judgment was delivered by me on 17 September 2013 at 2:30 pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

R v B [2013] NZHC 2415 [17 September 2013]

Introduction

[1]      The accused B   has been retried on one count of causing grievous bodily harm to his son K with reckless disregard for the child’s safety.  At the time of the alleged offending, 28 April 2011, K was four months old.

[2]      This judgment contains the reasons for a ruling I gave on 20 August 2013, during the Crown’s case, allowing in part an application by the Crown under s 344A of the Crimes Act 1961 to adduce propensity evidence.

Background

[3]      At the first trial the accused faced an indictment containing four counts of male assaults female on his former partner, Ms W, who is K’s mother; one count of assaulting Ms W with intent to injure her at Rotoiti; one count of assaulting K (known as the fencing incident); one count of assaulting K with intent to injure him (known as the throwing on the bed incident); one count of causing grievous bodily harm  to  K  with  intent  to  cause  him  grievous  bodily  harm  (the  incident  on

28 April 2011), and an alternative count related to that occasion of causing grievous bodily harm to K with reckless disregard for his safety; and one count of attempting to pervert the course of justice.

[4]      In July 2012, the accused pleaded guilty to a charge of assaulting Ms W on

22 April 2011,  which  is  the  day  they  separated.     During  the  first   trial  in September 2012, before Duffy J and a jury, the accused also pleaded guilty to three of the counts of assaulting Ms W, and was also found guilty by the jury on the count of wilfully attempting to pervert the course of justice, a charge which  involved threats of violence.

[5]      The jury acquitted him of the two other counts alleging violence against Ms W of male assaults female and assault with intent to injure.  He was acquitted on the count of assault on K (the fencing incident); and on the count of assaulting K with intent to injure (the throwing on the bed incident).

[6]      The accused was also acquitted on the count of causing grievous bodily harm to K with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, but the jury failed to agree on the alternative count of causing grievous bodily harm recklessly, relating to the same incident on 28 April 2011. That was the subject of the retrial.

[7]      In the retrial, the Crown applied to call the evidence relied upon to support the charges in relation to Ms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v B HC Tauranga Cri-2012-463-54 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 2415
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v B, heard in the High Court of New Zealand at Tauranga, revolves around the retrial of the accused, B, who stands charged with causing grievous bodily harm to his infant son, K, with reckless disregard for the child's safety. The incident in question occurred on 28 April 2011, when K was four months old. B had previously faced multiple charges related to alleged violence against K and his former partner, Ms W, K's mother, during a retrial. The first trial had resulted in B being acquitted on several counts, including those directly related to K, but the jury failed to reach a verdict on the charge of causing grievous bodily harm to K with reckless disregard. The Crown sought to introduce propensity evidence to establish the likelihood that B was responsible for the grievous bodily harm inflicted on K. The central legal issues involved the admissibility of propensity evidence under section 43 of the Evidence Act 2006, particularly in light of previous rulings in the first trial. The court ruled that evidence related to assaults on Ms W would not be admissible as propensity evidence but could be used as background information. However, evidence concerning the alleged assaults on K, including the fencing incident and the bed throwing incident, was deemed admissible as propensity evidence, given the similarity in circumstances and the probative value in proving the accused's tendency to react violently to K's crying. The court emphasised the importance of properly directing the jury to consider this evidence only as circumstantial and not to presume guilt based solely on past conduct.