R v B HC Rotorua Cri-2011-087-1316

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

NOTE: PUBLICATION OF NAME OR IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF COMPLAINANT PROHIBITED BY S 139 CRIMINAL JUSTICE ACT 1985. NOTE: PUBLICATION OF NAMES OR IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF WITNESSES UNDER 17 YEARS OF AGE PROHIBITED BY S 139A OF THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE ACT 1985.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CRI-2011-087-001316 [2012] NZHC 2434

THE QUEEN

v

B 

Hearing:         27-31 and 3-4 September 2012

Counsel:         G C Hollister-Jones and R W Jenson for the Crown

A F Rickard-Simms for the Accused

Judgment:      4 September 2012

Reasons:        20 September 2012

REASONS JUDGMENT OF DUFFY J [Re Propensity of Evidence]

This judgment was delivered by Justice Duffy on 20 September 2012 at 11.00 am, pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Date:

Solicitors:    Ronayne   Hollister-Jones   Lellman   P    O   Box    13063   (DX   HP40041) Tauranga Central Tauranga 3141 for the Crown

Pacific Coast Law P O Box 11208 Palm Beach Papamoa 3151 for the Accused

R v B   HC ROT CRI-2011-087-001316 [4 September 2012]

[1]      At the close of the evidence in this trial, there was a discussion with counsel regarding the extent to which the Crown could, in closing, rely on propensity evidence to prove the charges against the accused, Mr B  .   Because counsel were to present their closing addresses the next day, it was important that counsel knew as soon as possible of the limits I would place on the use of the proposed propensity evidence.   Thus, I delivered a result ruling (R v B   HC Rotorua CRI-2011-087-1316, 4 September 2012) with reasons to follow.  I now provide those reasons. This judgment should be read together with the earlier result ruling.

Background

[2]      The Crown says that prior to the trial, it had indicated to the defence that the Crown sought to rely on the direct evidence proving each count in the indictment as mutually supporting propensity evidence capable of proving other counts in the indictment as well. At that time, the defence did not object to this course.  However, this was in circumstances where Mr B   had pleaded not guilty to all the counts in the indictment.  Thus, evidence that the Crown wanted to rely on as propensity evidence was at the pre-trial stage also directly relevant to proof of particular counts and, for this reason, it could not have been excluded from admission.

[3]      At the commencement of the trial, Mr B   pleaded guilty to what was then  count  2  in  the  indictment.    Later,  at  the  close  of  the  Crown’s  case,  the indictment was amended and Mr B   then pleaded guilty to what were counts 2 and 9 in the amended indictment.  The effect of the guilty pleas meant that evidence that was directly relevant to proof of those counts was no longer needed, but the jury had seen and heard it during the course of the Crown’s case.  The Crown wanted in its closing address to rely on this evidence, as well as other evidence adduced in the trial as propensity evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v B HC Rotorua Cri-2011-087-1316 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2434
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the accused, Mr B, was on trial for various charges, including assaults on his partner and child. The court heard arguments about the admissibility of propensity evidence to support the charges. The Crown argued that evidence of prior assaults on the complainant, Ms W, and the child, K, should be allowed as propensity evidence to demonstrate Mr B's tendency to assault vulnerable persons. The accused objected to the proposed use of the evidence, arguing that it should not be considered for certain counts, particularly those involving more serious intent. The court had to determine the extent to which the Crown could rely on propensity evidence in its closing address.

The court considered the statutory provisions and legal principles regarding the use of propensity evidence, particularly the provisions of the Evidence Act 2006 and relevant case law. The court ruled that evidence of assaults on Ms W could be used as propensity evidence to prove other counts of male assaults female, as the similarity, frequency, and timing of the offences gave the evidence high probative value. However, the court found that the propensity evidence could not be used to prove the intent to injure in the assault on Ms W, as the specific intent required for that offence was not present in the prior assaults. Regarding the assaults on K, the court ruled that evidence of assaults on K could be used to establish a tendency to assault him, but not to prove the mental elements of the various charges relating to the child, as these required different levels of intent.

In summary, the court allowed the Crown to use some propensity evidence in its closing address, while restricting the use of other evidence to prevent prejudice to the accused. The court's decision was based on a careful analysis of the probative value and prejudicial effect of the evidence, in accordance with the statutory criteria and legal principles.