Queenstown Lakes District Council v Charterhall Trustees Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA441/2008
[2009] NZCA 374

BETWEENQUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL


Appellant

ANDCHARTERHALL TRUSTEES LIMITED


First Respondent

ANDBLAIR & CO LIMITED


Second Respondent

Hearing:21 May 2009

Court:Chambers, Arnold and Ellen France JJ

Counsel:D J Goddard QC and D J Heaney SC for Appellant


I G Hunt and C J Jamieson for First Respondent
M E Parker and J Taylor for Second Respondent

Judgment:25 August 2009 at 3 pm 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is allowed.

BThe first respondent’s statement of claim against the appellant is struck out.

CThe first respondent must pay the appellant costs for a complex appeal on a band A basis.  We certify for two counsel.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Arnold J)

Introduction

[1]       This case concerns the liability of a local authority to the owner of a commercial building who alleges that, as a result of the local authority’s negligence in the course of the approval and building process, the building had a defect which ultimately caused the owner to suffer loss. 

[2]       The first respondent, Charterhall Trustees Limited (Charterhall), owned and operated an upmarket lodge which suffered damage by fire on 1 December 2003.  The lodge had been built pursuant to consent granted by the appellant, the Queenstown Lakes District Council (the Council).  The Council also conducted inspections during the building’s construction and issued a certificate of code compliance upon its completion. 

[3]       Charterhall sued the Council and the second respondent, Blair & Co Limited (Blair & Co), who were the New Zealand architects for the project, alleging that the fire was caused by the defective design and/or construction of the lodge’s chimney.  In relation to the Council, Charterhall alleged that it had breached a duty of care to it by failing to identify that the chimney was defective both in design and construction and did not comply with the building code, and by failing to require compliance with the code.  Charterhall claimed for the cost of repairs to the lodge and for loss of income while the lodge was closed for repair.

[4]       The Council applied to strike out Charterhall’s claim against it.  Fogarty J rejected that application: HC INV CIV 2007-425-000588 27 June 2008.  The Council appeals against that decision.  In essence, it submits that this case is governed by this Court’s decision in Te Mata Properties Ltd v Hastings District Council [2009] 1 NZLR 460, a decision which post-dates Fogarty J’s judgment.

Background

[5]       Charterhall owns and operates Blanket Bay Lodge, a luxury lodge situated on Lake Wakatipu between Queenstown and Glenorchy.  The lodge was built between June 1998 and December 1999.  Two firms of architects (one based overseas and the other, Blair & Co, based locally) were involved in the preparation of plans and drawings for the lodge and in the oversight of its construction.  In addition, Charterhall retained various other specialist advisers for the project.  Among these were fire…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queenstown Lakes District Council v Charterhall Trustees Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZCA 374
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal is brought by the Queenstown Lakes District Council against a decision of Fogarty J that Charterhall Trustees Limited’s claim against the Council should not be struck out. Charterhall, the owner of a commercial building, alleges that the Council was negligent in granting a building consent, conducting inspections, and issuing a certificate of code compliance, resulting in a fire that damaged the building and caused Charterhall to suffer loss. The Council argues that this case is governed by the decision of this Court in Te Mata Properties Ltd v Hastings District Council, which held that a local authority owed no duty of care to the owner of a commercial building. The Court agrees, and holds that the claim against the Council must be struck out. The appeal is allowed, and Charterhall must pay the Council’s costs of the appeal.

Charterhall owns and operates Blanket Bay Lodge, a luxury lodge situated on Lake Wakatipu between Queenstown and Glenorchy. The lodge was built between June 1998 and December 1999. The Council granted a building consent for the project on the basis of the architects’ plans and specifications, carried out inspections as the building was constructed and, upon its completion, issued a code compliance certificate. The fire occurred on 1 December 2003. Charterhall alleges that it started in a rooftop tower which encased two exhaust flues from a large open fireplace in the lodge’s guest lounge. Charterhall’s allegation is that the design of the tower was defective and not code compliant as the flues terminated at the same level as the top of the tower rather than extending above it. As a consequence, hot embers coming out through the flues were able to accumulate in the cavities of the tower and come into contact with unprotected timber, thus creating the risk of fire. The fire at issue, Charterhall claims, started in this way. Charterhall alleges that Blair & Co were negligent in the preparation of the detailed drawings for the lodge. In relation to the Council, Charterhall’s allegation is that it owed a duty to exercise reasonable care and skill in issuing and administering building consent 980371, which duty required the Council to: (a)Consider the detailed drawings with care, skill and due regard to the requirements of the Building Code; (b)Apprehend that the design represented in the detailed drawings for the main tower did not comply with the Building Code; (c)Apprehend that the design represented in the detailed drawings for the main tower did not comply with Acceptable Solution C1/AS1 and New Zealand Standard 7421:1990; (d)Apprehend that the design represented in the detailed drawings for the main tower posed an inherent fire risk; (e)Conduct inspections of the building work with sufficient diligence and frequency to satisfy itself on reasonable grounds that the building work complied with the conditions of building consent 980371 and with the Building Code; (f)Issue a certificate of code compliance only when satisfied on reasonable grounds, that the building work to which the certificate related complied with the Building Code. Charterhall goes on to allege that the Council breached its duty because: (a)in issuing the building consent it failed to detect that the design of the tower did not meet the requirements of the Building Code or other applicable standards and was unsafe; (b)in carrying out its inspections it failed to detect that some of the fire protection detailed in the drawings which formed the basis for the grant of the building consent was not present; and (c)at the time it issued the code compliance certificate it had no reasonable grounds to believe that the work had been carried out consistently with the Building Code or the building consent. Charterhall claims for the cost of repairs and of replacement chattels, and for loss of income while the lodge was closed. The Council applied to have the claim against it struck out. It argued that: (a)Charterhall was a commercial operator providing luxury accommodation on a commercial basis. Accordingly authorities relating to the liability of councils to owners of residential properties, in particular Invercargill City Council v Hamlin, did not apply; (b)Charterhall was in a position to, and did, retain and rely on its own expert advisors in relation to the design and construction of the lodge. Accordingly it was able to, and did, protect its commercial interests, and did not need to rely on the Council to do so; (c)There were no policy reasons justifying the imposition of a duty of care on the Council towards Charterhall in the circumstances of this case. The Building Act 1991 did not support the imposition of such a duty, nor did the relevant authorities, in particular Hamlin. Fogarty J declined the Council’s application, but the Court holds that the claim against the Council must be struck out. The Court accepts that the Council owed no duty of care to Charterhall to prevent the construction of a building which contained a defect that threatened the health and safety of anyone who might occupy it for the time being. The duty of care recognised in the New Zealand cases “has not always been limited to the avoidance of physical damage to the plaintiff’s property, or danger to the health or safety of the occupants: in appropriate situations a wider duty not to cause economic loss to the plaintiff has been recognised and damages have been awarded on that basis”. The imposition of the duty essentially reflects a value judgment that seeks to recognise the particular housing arrangements that have developed in this country. The considerations which justified the imposition of the duty have little relevance in a commercial context. This is exemplified by the present case. Here Charterhall retained two firms of architects as well as various other specialist advisers, including fire protection engineers. Accordingly, unlike the house-owners discussed by Richardson J in Hamlin, Charterhall was not dependent on the council to protect its interests – it was able to, and did, take steps to do that. The Court also holds that the Building Act does not seek to protect the value of buildings, or income streams from them, for commercial investors. The losses claimed are not ones against which the Building Act seeks to protect. The appeal is allowed, and Charterhall must pay the Council’s costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established