Brichris Holdings Limited v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-7973 [2012] NZHC 2089

UNDER  the     Weathertight     Homes     Resolution

Services Act 2006

IN THE MATTER OF      an   Appeal   pursuant   to   s   93   of   the Weathertight Homes Resolution Services Act 2006

BETWEEN  BRICHRIS      HOLDINGS      LIMITED Appellant

ANDAUCKLAND COUNCIL First Respondent

ANDALLAN FORSTER IRWIN Second Respondent

ANDDEAN CHANDLER Third Respondent

ANDWAYNE JOHN MCDONNELL Fourth Respondent

ANDBRENT MICHAEL BARRETT Fifth Respondent

ANDIGOR ARAKELIAN Sixth Respondent

ANDJAN PONICHTERA Seventh Respondent

Hearing:         17 July 2012

Counsel:         D K Wilson for Appellant

F Divich for Auckland Council

Judgment:      16 August 2012

JUDGMENT OF MILLER J

BRICHRIS HOLDINGS LIMITED V AUCKLAND COUNCIL HC AK CIV-2011-404-7973 [16 August 2012]

[1]      Brichris  Holdings  Limited  brings  this  appeal  from  a  decision  of  the Weathertight Homes Tribunal removing the Auckland Council as a respondent to its claim for compensation concerning its two leaky townhouses.

[2]      The Tribunal reasoned that Brichris was the developer of the townhouses and a local authority owes no duty of care to a developer.1   Brichris says that the Tribunal was wrong to characterise it as a developer, and argues that its claim ought not to have been struck out in limine.

The procedural setting

[3]      The Tribunal’s decision responded to an application by the Council under s

112 of the Weathertight Homes Resolution Services Act 2006.  That section provides that the Tribunal may remove a party from proceedings if the Tribunal thinks it fair and appropriate in all the circumstances to do so.

[4]      The parties agree that the question is whether the claim against the Council is untenable, and that when answering that question the Tribunal might consider not only the pleadings but also other documents filed and evidence for and against the removal application.2

[5]      In this case the record included assessors’ reports and several affidavits.  For the Council, Malcolm McCluskey swore an affidavit attaching substantial parts of the Council’s file and reciting the hearsay claims of other respondents about the role played by one of Brichris’s directors, Brian Davis.  For the claimant, affidavits were sworn by Mr Davis and Keith MacKinlay and Pamela Clews.  The latter witnesses deposed that Mr Davis is a jeweller rather than a builder or developer, and Mr Davis explained how the townhouses came to be developed and what role he played.

[6]      The Tribunal had all of this material before it but the application was decided on the papers, so allegations in the affidavits could not be tested.  Counsel agree that

1      Brichris Holdings Limited v Auckland Council & Ors WHT TRI 2011-100-16, 14 November

2011.

2      Yun v Waitakere City Council HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-5944, 15 February 2011.

oral evidence and cross-examination will probably be required at the substantive hearing in the Tribunal.

[7]      The Tribunal’s decision  was a final determination under the Act, and an

appeal lies on law or fact.3

The narrative

[8]      The  following  narrative  is  drawn  from  the  affidavits,  principally  that  of Mr Davis.  Counsel agree that the Tribunal might accept his evidence at the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brichris Holdings Limited v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2089
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Brichris Holdings Limited brought this appeal from a decision of the Weathertight Homes Tribunal, which removed the Auckland Council as a respondent to its claim for compensation in respect of its two leaky townhouses. The Tribunal held that Brichris was the developer of the townhouses and, as such, the Council owed no duty of care to a developer. Brichris contends that the Tribunal was wrong to characterise it as a developer, and that its claim should not have been struck out in limine.

The Tribunal’s decision was a final determination under the Weathertight Homes Resolution Services Act 2006, and an appeal lies on law or fact. The court held that the Tribunal had applied an over-inclusive test in this case, focusing too much on Brichris’s role in the subdivision and construction and too little on its original objective for the townhouses. The court set aside the Tribunal’s decision to remove the Council as a party.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established