Queenstown Central Ltd v Queenstown Lakes District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY

CIV-2012-425-000405 [2013] NZHC 815

BETWEEN  QUEENSTOWN CENTRAL LIMITED Appellant

ANDQUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL

Respondent

ANDFOODSTUFFS (SOUTH ISLAND) LIMITED

Applicant

ANDSHOTOVER PARK LIMITED Associated Respondent

Hearing:         12-14 February 2013 (Heard at Queenstown)

Appearances: J Young for Shotover Park Limited

J Gardner-Hopkins and E Matheson for Queenstown Central Limited

T Ray and J Macdonald for Queenstown Lakes District Council

N Soper and A Ritchie for Foodstuffs (South Island) Limited
G Todd for Cross Roads Properties Limited

Judgment:      19 April 2013

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF FOGARTY J

Solicitors:

Russell McVeagh, Auckland –  bron.carruthers@russellmcveagh.com and  james.gardner- hopkins@russellmcveagh.com

Anderson Lloyd, Queenstown –  nic.soper@andersonlloyd.co.nz

Macalister Todd Phillips, Wanaka –  tray@mactodd.co.nz

Brookfields, Auckland –  youngj@brookfields.co.nz

QUEENSTOWN CENTRAL LIMITED V QUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL HC INV CIV-2012-425-000405 [19 April 2013]

Contents

Road map ...............................................................................................................[1] Introduction  and  summary  of  both  the  Foodstuffs  and  the  Cross  Roads

appeals decision .....................................................................................................[2] Section 104D issues .............................................................................................[21] The context ...........................................................................................................[21] Preliminary observations .....................................................................................[31] Foodstuffs decision...............................................................................................[42] Cross Roads decision ...........................................................................................[55]

Does Hawthorn apply to the application of s 104D(1)(a), in the context of

this case? ..............................................................................................................[61] Conclusion............................................................................................................[84]

Did the Environment Court err in its interpretation and application of “minor” when applying the alternative numeric analysis, which does take into   account   and   recognise   the   presence   of   PC19(DV)?      Did   the Environment Court err in law when defining a 20% threshold for “minor”

effects?..................................................................................................................[86]

Did the Environment Court err in law in considering all undeveloped industrial land in Queenstown/Wakatipu was the appropriate base against which to measure the loss of industrial land in relation to the Foodstuffs

application?........................................................................................................ [116]

General conclusion on error of law in the Foodstuffs application on the evaluation that the Foodstuffs application could be no more than a “minor” adverse effect, and was not contrary to objective 10 of PC19(DV)...................[128]

Materiality of error of law ..................................................................................[129] Other issues ........................................................................................................[141] Should the Environment Court have adjourned the hearings? ..........................[141] Was the Court prejudiced by an error of law classifying QCL as a trade

competitor?  Did this materially affect the decision? ........................................[144]

Result..................................................................................................................[164]

Road map

[1]      There are two resource consent applications at issue: one application by Foodstuffs to build a Pak’nSave at Frankton Flats, and another by Cross Roads  Properties  to  build  a  Mitre  10  Mega,  also  at  Frankton  Flats. Queenstown Lakes District Council (QLDC) declined the Foodstuffs application.   The Cross Roads application went directly to the Environment Court.   The Environment Court granted both applications.   Now the Environment Court’s decisions have been appealed to the High Court.   The

High Court is releasing two separate decisions, one for each application.1  This

is necessary as there are separate rights of appeal.  Both decisions need to be read together.

Introduction and summary of both the Foodstuffs and the Cross Roads appeals decision

[2]      This summary endeavours to collect in one place the reasoning of both decisions.

[3]      The Resource Management Act 1991 requires applications for consent to be processed promptly; even on the eve of a proposed plan for the locality becoming operative; even when the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queenstown Central Ltd v Queenstown Lakes District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 815
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal by Queenstown Central Limited against a decision of the Environment Court, which had approved applications by Foodstuffs (South Island) Limited and Cross Roads Properties Limited to build a supermarket and a Mega store respectively on the Frankton Flats in Queenstown. The appeal focused on whether the Environment Court erred in its interpretation and application of the statutory standard of “minor” when applying an alternative numeric analysis to the proposed applications, and whether it erred in law in defining a 20% threshold for “minor” effects. The Court found that the Environment Court erred in its interpretation and application of “minor” when it substituted a numeric test for the statutory test, which was a significant error of law. The Court also found that the Environment Court erred in law when it defined a 20% threshold for “minor” effects, as this was not in line with the purpose of the standard. The appeal was allowed, and the case was remitted back to the Environment Court for re-evaluation against the current terms of the proposed plan change.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established