Queenstown Central Ltd v Queenstown Lakes District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY

CIV-2012-425-000514 [2013] NZHC 817

BETWEEN  QUEENSTOWN CENTRAL LIMITED Appellant

ANDQUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL

Respondent

ANDCROSS ROADS PROPERTIES LIMITED Applicant

ANDFOODSTUFFS (SOUTH ISLAND) LIMITED

Applicant in CIV-2012-000405

CIV-2012-425-000515

AND BETWEEN            QUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL

Appellant/Respondent

ANDCROSS ROADS PROPERTIES LIMITED Applicant

ANDFOODSTUFFS (SOUTH ISLAND) LIMITED

Applicant in CIV-2012-425-000405

ANDSHOTOVER PARK LIMITED Objector

Hearing:         12-14 February 2013 (Heard at Queenstown)

Appearances: G Todd for the Appellant

J Gardner-Hopkins and E Matheson for First Respondent

T Ray and J MacDonald for Queenstown Lakes District Council

Judgment:      19 April 2013

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF FOGARTY J

QUEENSTOWN CENTRAL LIMITED V QUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL HC INV CIV-2012-425-000514 [19 April 2013]

Table of Contents

Introduction ............................................................................................................[1] Errors applying s 104D(1)(a) of the Resource Management Act 1991 ..................[2] Alleged errors of law interpreting PC19(DV)........................................................[8]

Whether there was an error of law when interpreting objective 10 of

PC19(DV) ............................................................................................................ [11] Summary of Environment Court reasoning on objective 10 in Foodstuffs ..........[15] Summary of Environment Court reasoning in Cross Roads.................................[17] Analysis of the Environment Court’s interpretation of objective 10 ....................[20]

Taking into account the Foodstuffs consent in Cross Roads, s 104D

analysis.................................................................................................................[42] Materiality of error ...............................................................................................[43] Result....................................................................................................................[44]

Introduction

[1]      These  are  two  appeals.    One  is  by  Queenstown  Central  Limited (QCL), which owns property on the Frankton Flats.   The other is by the Queenstown Lakes District Council (QLDC).  Both are against one decision of the Environment Court granting consent to Cross Roads Properties Limited’s proposal for a Mitre 10 Mega on the Frankton Flats, which is the

subject of plan change 19.   I call that the  Cross Roads decision.1     That

decision was released shortly after the Foodstuffs decision.2

[2]      This judgment needs to be read after reading this Court’s decision allowing the appeal against the Foodstuffs judgment.3   While some overlap is unavoidable, so far as possible the goal in this decision is to address all the issues in the Mitre 10 Mega appeal without duplicating the reasoning from the Foodstuffs decision.

Errors applying s 104D(1)(a) of the Resource Management Act 1991

[3]      Applying s 104D(1)(a), the Environment Court in Cross Roads, by a majority, was satisfied that there is only a minor adverse effect, by reason of the reduction in supply of industrial zoned land should this proposal go ahead. It found that:

[59]      ... adopting the analysis in Foodstuffs, as a matter of law the supply of possible industrially zoned land under proposed PC19(DV) is  not  part  of  the  (future)  environment  for  the  purposes  of section 104D.

[4]      As in Foodstuffs, in the alternative, putting aside Queenstown Lakes

District Council v Hawthorn Estate Ltd, 4  the Court went on to consider whether the removal of 1.8 hectares of industrial land would only be minor or

1      Cross Roads Properties Ltd v Queenstown Lakes District Council [2012] NZEnvC 177 at [59] (Cross Roads).

2      Foodstuffs (SI) Ltd v Queenstown Lakes District Council [2012] NZEnvB5.

3      Queenstown Central Ltd v Queenstown Lakes District Council [2013]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queenstown Central Ltd v Queenstown Lakes District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 817
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Queenstown Central Limited and the Queenstown Lakes District Council appealed against the Environment Court's decision to grant consent to Cross Roads Properties Limited's proposal for a Mitre 10 Mega on the Frankton Flats, which was subject to plan change 19. The primary legal issue in this case was whether the Environment Court made any errors in applying section 104D(1)(a) of the Resource Management Act 1991 and interpreting objective 10 of PC19(DV). The Court found that the Environment Court had made errors in applying section 104D(1)(a) and interpreting objective 10 of PC19(DV). The Court concluded that the Environment Court's interpretation of objective 10 was incorrect and that the Court should not have read the plan change as a whole to determine whether the proposal was contrary to the objectives and policies of the proposed plan. The Court held that the Environment Court should have focused on whether the proposal was contrary to the objectives and policies before conducting the s 104 analysis. The appeals were allowed, and the decision was remitted back to the Environment Court for re-evaluation against the current terms of PC19, as amended in February 2013. Costs were reserved, and the parties were required to circulate draft submissions on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established