Property Sales Direct Limited v Hawken Lane Development LP

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2019-404-1435

[2022] NZHC 943

IN THE MATTER of the Companies Act 1993 and the Limited Partnership Act 2008

BETWEEN

PROPERTY SALES DIRECT LIMITED

Plaintiff/First Counterclaim Defendant

AND

HAWKEN LANE DEVELOPMENT LP

Defendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff

STEPHEN JOHN DAVIES

Second Counterclaim Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

H Holmes for Plaintiff/First Counterclaim Defendant E St John for Defendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff

S Pasley for Second Counterclaim Defendant

Judgment:

5 May 2022


JUDGMENT OF HARVEY J

[Costs]


This judgment was delivered by me on 5 May 2022 at 4.00pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date: ………………………….

Counsel/Solicitors:

E St John, Barrister, Auckland Keegan Alexander, Auckland Heritage Law, Auckland

Robertsons Law, Auckland

PROPERTY SALES DIRECT LTD v HAWKEN LANE DEVELOPMENT LP - Costs [2022] NZHC 943 [5 May 2022]

Introduction

[1]                  By judgment dated 9 March 2022, the applications of Property Sales Direct Ltd (PSDL) for leave to serve a third-party notice on its former counsel and for separate trials were dismissed.1 As foreshadowed, the defendant Hawken Lane Development LP is entitled to costs and counsel have now exchanged memoranda in the absence of agreement over costs.2

[2]                  It is accepted that Hawken is entitled to costs as the successful party and to the sums claimed. However, PSDL seeks an order that either costs be shared between themselves and Mr Davies, or an order that PSDL and Mr Davies are jointly and severally liable. Mr Davies opposes those orders and instead seeks indemnity or increased costs for those costs incurred in responding to the plaintiff’s claim.

[3]                  Also relevant is a Notice of Discontinuance, dated 24 March 2022 and signed by all parties, which confirmed that Hawken discontinued its claim against the second counterclaim defendant, with no issue as to costs.

[4]Accordingly, the issues for determination are:

(a)Should Mr Davies be required to contribute to costs?

(b)Should costs be awarded for the preparation of the costs memoranda?

(c)Should Mr Davies be awarded increased or indemnity costs?

Hawken’s submissions

[5]                  On 22 March 2022, Mr St John for Hawken filed a memorandum seeking 2B costs of $7,050.50 and disbursements of $160. Hawken also seeks scale costs for the preparation of the costs memorandum.  Counsel submitted that on 11  March 2022,   a letter was sent to counsel for PSDL setting out its costs calculation and seeking agreement by 16 March 2022.  However, there was no response.  Accordingly, Mr  St John argued that PSDL’s failure to cooperate to agree costs was inexcusable and


1      Property Sales Direct Ltd v Hawken Lane Development LP [2022] NZHC 403.

2 At [36].

that there should have been no need to waste the court and counsels’ time by requiring a judgment on costs.

PSDL’s submissions

[6]                  On 30 March 2022, Mr Holmes for PSDL filed a one-page memorandum in reply, acknowledging that it is not in dispute that Hawken is entitled to costs and agreeing with the sums calculated.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Property Sales Direct Limited v Hawken Lane Development LP and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 943
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Property Sales Direct Limited sought leave to serve a third-party notice and for separate trials in a proceeding against Hawken Lane Development LP. The applications were dismissed by judgment dated 9 March 2022. By Notice of Discontinuance, dated 24 March 2022 and signed by all parties, Hawken discontinued its claim against the second counterclaim defendant. The issues for determination were: (a) whether Stephen John Davies should be required to contribute to costs; (b) whether costs should be awarded for the preparation of the costs memoranda; and (c) whether Davies should be awarded increased or indemnity costs. Hawken argued that Property Sales Direct Limited's failure to cooperate to agree costs was inexcusable and that there should have been no need to waste the court and counsels' time by requiring a judgment on costs. Property Sales Direct Limited sought an order that either costs be shared between themselves and Davies, or an order that Property Sales Direct Limited and Davies were jointly and severally liable. Davies opposed those orders and instead sought indemnity or increased costs for those costs incurred in responding to the plaintiff's claim. The Court held that there was no basis to depart from the principle that the losing party should pay costs to the successful party. It was inappropriate for Davies to be required to contribute to Hawken’s costs. The Court considered that Property Sales Direct Limited alone was liable for the costs incurred in relation to Hawken and Davies’ engagement in this costs application, given their own lack of engagement in relation to costs matters. The Court considered it appropriate that a costs award of 2B costs with a 50 per cent uplift to Davies for the preparation of the costs memorandum was warranted in these circumstances. Property Sales Direct Limited was ordered to pay scale costs of $7,050.50 and disbursements of $160 to Hawken Lane Development LP. Property Sales Direct Limited was ordered to pay Davies' costs of preparing the costs memorandum on a 2B basis, with a 50 per cent increase.