Pram Enterprises Limited (in liquidation) v Mansfield

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-485-488 [2015] NZHC 230

BETWEEN

PRAM ENTERPRISES LIMITED (IN

LIQUIDATION) Plaintiff

AND

PAUL STEPHEN MANSFIELD Defendant

Hearing: 7 December 2015

Counsel:

D Kerr for the Plaintiff
E Collins for the Defendant

Judgment:

22 February 2016

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH

[1]      The plaintiff (Pram) applies for summary judgment against Mr Mansfield for the sum of $390,855.18 plus interest and costs.  The amount claimed is alleged to have been a loan made by Pram to Mr Mansfield in his capacity as a trustee of a trust known as the TCF Trust.  Mr Mansfield denies that there was any such loan.  He says that the payment made by Pram was made to him in his capacity as trustee of another trust, the BBC Trust, in satisfaction of advances earlier made by the BBC Trust to Pram.

[2]      It is common ground that the $390,855.18 was applied by Mr Mansfield and his co-trustee Mr Bradnock (whether as trustees of the TCF Trust or the BBC Trust) in the purchase of a property at Whitemans Valley (the property).

[3]      Pram contends that Mr Mansfield, as trustee of the TCF Trust, has a right to be indemnified out of the TCF Trust’s assets, including the property.  It says that that

right of indemnity confers on Mr Mansfield an equitable lien over the TCF Trust

PRAM ENTERPRISES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) v PAUL STEPHEN MANSFIELD [2015] NZHC 230 [22 February 2016]

assets,  including  the  property,  and  that  it  is  entitled  to  be  subrogated  to  Mr

Mansfield’s right to enforce that equitable lien.

[4]      In addition to judgment for the sum of money claimed and interest, Pram seeks to enforce its alleged right of subrogation.  It applies for an order for the sale of the property by the registrar of this Court, with the net proceeds of sale (after payment of the costs of sale and settlement of the amount owing to the mortgagee) to be paid to Pram in satisfaction of the judgment, interest and costs.

Background

[5]      For  some  years,  Pram  operated  a  drycleaning  business  in  Petone  and Wellington.   The shares  in Pram were owned  by Mr Mansfield and  Mr Warren Bradnock.  Mr Mansfield was the sole director.

[6]      While Pram operated the drycleaning business, the assets and equipment were owned by the company MARP Holdings Limited (MARP).  Mr Mansfield was also a director of MARP.

[7]      In September 2011 Mr Mansfield entered into an agreement to purchase the property for $390,000.  The purchaser was shown in the agreement as Mr Mansfield or nominee.   The agreement was conditional upon Mr Mansfield entering into a satisfactory agreement for the sale of the drycleaning business.

[8]      The  drycleaning business  was  sold  later in the same month,  and  Pram’s solicitors received a net amount of $1,023,000 on settlement on 1 November 2011. A solicitors’ trust account statement shows that $390,855.18 from the settlement was credited to Messrs Mansfield and Bradnock “for purchase of [the property]”.   It is this $390,855.18 which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pram Enterprises Limited (in liquidation) v Mansfield and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 230
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Pram Enterprises Limited (in liquidation), applied for summary judgment against the defendant, Mr. Paul Stephen Mansfield, for the sum of $390,855.18 plus interest and costs. Pram claims that the amount was a loan made by Pram to Mr. Mansfield in his capacity as a trustee of a trust known as the TCF Trust. Mr. Mansfield denies that there was any such loan and says that the payment made by Pram was made to him in his capacity as trustee of another trust, the BBC Trust, in satisfaction of advances earlier made by the BBC Trust to Pram. The court had to determine whether the payment of $390,855.18 made by Pram to Mr. Mansfield and Mr. Bradnock on 2 November 2011 was an advance to them in their capacities as trustees of the TCF Trust, or was it a payment made in satisfaction of advances earlier made by Mr. Mansfield and Mr. Bradnock in their capacities as trustees of the BBC Trust. If the payment was an advance, the court also had to determine what orders should be made in respect of Pram's claim that it is entitled to be subrogated to Mr. Mansfield's rights as lien-holder over the property, and to have the property sold. The court found that Mr. Mansfield had no reasonably arguable defence on this issue. The shareholders' resolution dated 28 October 2011, only three days before the purchase of the property was settled with funds made available from the proceeds of the sale of Pram's business, quite clearly records that the payment was an advance to Mr. Mansfield and Mr. Bradnock, that it was for the purchase of the property, and that the property was "to be held in trust in accordance with the directions of the TCF Trust Deed." The court also found that Pram is entitled to be subrogated to Mr. Mansfield's rights as lien-holder over the property, and that Pram is entitled to enforce Mr. Mansfield's equitable lien by selling the property. However, the court dismissed Pram's application for summary judgment on its claim for orders for sale of the property, and for an order that it is entitled to enforce Mr. Mansfield's equitable lien by selling the property. Those claims will need to go forward for trial in the ordinary way, with evidence provided of the extent of the TCF Trust's assets, and of such other matters as may be relevant to the Court's exercise of its discretion to make orders and give directions under r 11.22 of the High Court Rules.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.