New Zealand Guardian Trust v Ralph

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-Ā-TARA ROHE

CIV-2016-485-742 [2018] NZHC 121

BETWEEN

THE NEW ZEALAND GUARDIAN

TRUST COMPANY LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

TONY WILLIAM RALPH Defendant

Hearing: 5 December 2017

Appearances:

R D Butler and D M Netherclift for the Plaintiff
J K Mahuta-Coyle for the Defendant

Judgment:

13 February 2018

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH

[1]      The plaintiff (NZGT) applies for summary judgment against the defendant (Mr Ralph) for the sum of $407,883.09.  Mr Ralph is the husband of Mrs Rebecca Ralph (Mrs Ralph), who misappropriated the sum of $360,808.30 over a period of

10 years while she was an employee of NZGT. The misappropriated funds were held on trust by NZGT for its clients, and NZGT paid out $407,883.09 to discharge its liabilities to its clients arising from Mrs Ralph’s defalcations. NZGT seeks to recover that sum from Mr Ralph, primarily on the basis that he knowingly received the misappropriated  money,  but  it  also  pleads  causes  of  action  in  conversion  and

indemnity.

THE NEW ZEALAND GUARDIAN TRUST COMPANY LIMITED v TONY WILLIAM RALPH [2018] NZHC 121 [13 February 2018]

Background

The proceeding against Mrs Ralph

[2]      While  she  was  an  employee  of  NZGT,  Mrs  Ralph  was  responsible  for managing client portfolios and accounts. Between 2004 and 2015, she systematically misappropriated $360,808.30 from 20 of her clients’ accounts, including those of elderly and intellectually disabled clients, as well as some for whom Mrs Ralph held enduring  powers of  attorney.    On 9 April  2015,  NZGT discovered  Mrs Ralph’s misappropriations.

[3]      NZGT filed a proceeding against Mrs Ralph in May 2016, seeking summary judgment.  Mrs Ralph did not initially file a notice of opposition.  Rather, she sought an adjournment pending the result of the related criminal proceeding she was facing.1

[4]      In an affidavit filed in support of her adjournment application, Mrs Ralph made certain admissions, and on 26 July 2016 I entered judgment against her on liability, with quantum to be determined at a hearing set for 24 November 2016.2

[5]      Mrs Ralph initially disputed the quantum of NZGT’s claim, but on the eve of the quantum hearing she abandoned this opposition. On 29 November 2016 judgment was entered against her by consent in the sum of $407,883.09.

[6]      Mrs Ralph has not since made any payment to NZGT.  NZGT has registered a charging order over Mrs Ralph’s share of the home she owns with Mr Ralph, but it has been  impracticable to  sell  Mrs  Ralph’s  share  of the property without  Mr Ralph agreeing to a sale. However, the mortgagee of the property has issued a Property Law Act notice against Mr and Mrs Ralph, and I was told at the hearing that a mortgagee

sale was scheduled for 13 December 2017.

1      Mrs Ralph later pleaded guilty to criminal charges of obtaining by deception. At the time of the hearing of NZGT’s summary judgment application against Mr Ralph, she had not yet been sentenced. Her sentencing was scheduled for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New Zealand Guardian Trust v Ralph and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 121
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The New Zealand Guardian Trust Company Limited (NZGT) sought summary judgment against Tony Ralph for the sum of $407,883.09, which represented the funds misappropriated by his wife, Rebecca Ralph, while she was an employee of NZGT. Mr Ralph denied having any knowledge of the misappropriations and claimed he had no involvement in the financial affairs of their business or their domestic finances. The Court had to decide whether there was a real question to be tried regarding Mr Ralph's knowledge or wilful blindness of the misappropriations, and whether there was sufficient evidence to infer that Mr Ralph had a dishonest state of mind. The Court held that there was insufficient evidence to determine whether Mr Ralph had a dishonest state of mind. Mr Ralph's evidence, though late, was not inherently improbable, and it could not be said with certainty that he was aware of the relevant payments or that he was wilfully blind to the misappropriations. Additionally, the Court found that there was no evidence to support NZGT's claim that Mr Ralph received the creditor payments himself, or that he participated in making such a direction. The summary judgment application was dismissed. The costs of the application were reserved, and the interim suppression orders made in this proceeding were discharged.