Philpott v Noble Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2010-409-002984 [2013] NZHC 830

IN THE MATTER OF     Caveats Numbers 8322656.1 and

8003770.1

BETWEEN  SHAYNE PHILPOTT, NEW ZEALAND TRUSTEE SERVICES LIMITED, COLIN PETER STOKES, FAY EUNICE RICHARDSON, BURNSIDE TRUSTEES LIMITED AND GREGORY ROBERT SMITH

Applicants

ANDNOBLE INVESTMENTS LIMITED Respondent

Hearing:         18 April 2013

(Heard at Christchurch)

Appearances: W J Palmer/J D Silcock for Applicants

S M Dwight for Respondent

Judgment:      18 April 2013

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE [as to costs]

[1]      In previous judgments in this proceeding, I determined initially an application for orders that caveats not lapse1 and then competing applications for supplementary orders.2

[2]      In delivering both judgments I had reserved costs.

1      Philpott v Noble Investments Ltd [2012] NZHC 1431.

2      Philpott v Noble Investments Ltd [2013] NZHC 400.

PHILPOTT V NOBLE INVESTMENTS LIMITED HC CHCH CIV-2010-409-002984 [18 April 2013]

The proceeding itself

[4]      The applicants had caveated the respondent’s title.   The applicants, in late

2010, received notice that the respondent had triggered the caveat-lapsing procedure under s 145A Land Transfer Act 1952.   The applicants therefore commenced this proceeding in order to sustain their caveats.

[5]      There  were  delays  in  the  litigation  caused  in  part  by  the  Christchurch earthquakes but also by commercial negotiations between the parties.  In the absence of resolution, the proceeding first came before me for hearing on 9  May 2012 resulting in my first judgment of 28 June 2012.  I concluded that the caveators had established a reasonably arguable case in relation to each caveat.  I found in relation to one caveat that there was a way in which the respondent could satisfy its obligations and therefore imposed conditions by which the first caveat could lapse. The second caveat did not lend itself to a directly parallel approach – I attached conditions to the order preserving that caveat.  The conditions gave the respondent the right to demonstrate that the applicants’ interest had been subsequently protected.

[6]      Leave was reserved to the parties to apply in relation to some aspects of the first judgment.

[7]      The first judgment was subsequently met by cross-applications filed by the parties.  Those applications were heard on 13 and 14 February 2013 leading to the second judgment (dated 5 March 2013).   In the second judgment, I ordered four amendments to the first judgment but otherwise dismissed a number of each parties’ applications.

The applicants’ position

[8]      The applicants seek costs in relation to both hearings.  Specifically they seek Scale 2C costs or alternatively Scale 2B costs with a 50 per cent uplift in respect of both judgments.

The respondent’s position

[9]      The  respondent  opposes  the  making  of  costs  orders  in  favour  of  the applicants. The respondent submits that costs should lie where they fall in relation to the first hearing and the first judgment and that the respondent should have costs on the second hearing and the second judgment on a 2B basis.

Principles

[10]   Counsel generally referred to similar principles as applicable to the determination  of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Philpott v Noble Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 830
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was called upon to decide costs in a proceeding brought by the applicants to sustain their caveats on the respondent's title. The applicants sought Scale 2C costs or, alternatively, Scale 2B costs with a 50% uplift. The respondent opposed the making of costs orders in favour of the applicants, arguing that costs should lie where they fall in relation to the first hearing and the first judgment, and that the respondent should have costs on the second hearing and the second judgment on a 2B basis.

The court assessed the outcome of each hearing and determined that the applicants succeeded in establishing that they had reasonably arguable cases in relation to both caveats in the first hearing, and that neither party could be categorised as the successful party at the second hearing. The court found that costs should lie where they fall on the new applications, that is to say there should be no costs order. The court declined the application for increased costs up to the first judgment. The court also decided that Band B was appropriate as reflecting the normal amount of time which was reasonable in this case, and a 2B award up to the first judgment was appropriate.

The court then proceeded to calculate the 2B award. The court found that the applicants' calculations were incorrect, and the appropriate daily rate to be applied was $1,880. The court reviewed the individual items claimed by the applicants and found that some items were not allowable under the High Court Rules. The court allowed certain items and disallowed others, and the resulting calculation for the 2B award was $14,100 plus $400 in disbursements.

In conclusion, the court ordered that in relation to this proceeding up to 28 June 2012 the respondent was to pay to the applicants costs in the sum of $14,100 and disbursements in the sum of $400.00, and that in relation to this proceeding after 28 June 2012 there was no order as to costs or disbursements.